Menu

#136 PD topography counter with faulty behavior

1.3.2.0
closed
None
2017-03-01
2017-01-31
No

I create a test case for testing the behavior of topography counter check from A.6.7 Table A.5.

I receive a PD with the given values below. The actual topography counter values are set as shown below. The first check is passed concerning case 4:

Actual topography counter values of the received telegram
etbTopoCnt opTrnTopoCnt
123 456

For the second test of the receiving PD, I use diffrent values submitted in the PD.subscribe. The second check is not passed, there is no case for this combination. But the PD is delivered successfully

values of the received telegram values submitted with the subscription
etbTopoCnt opTrnTopoCn t
123 456

As allready discused in ticket #123 the description of the behavior of the Topography counter in the specification is very bad and leads to misunderstanding. But for my opinion the above described combination should block the PD instead of transmitting.

Discussion

  • Bernd Löhr

    Bernd Löhr - 2017-03-01
    • status: open --> accepted
    • assigned_to: Bernd Löhr
    • Milestone: 1.4.0.0 --> 1.3.2.0
     
  • Bernd Löhr

    Bernd Löhr - 2017-03-01

    The topo count error is currently silently ignored, it should at least lead to an error callback.

     
  • Bernd Löhr

    Bernd Löhr - 2017-03-02
    • Status: accepted --> closed
     

Log in to post a comment.

MongoDB Logo MongoDB