[Tcl-bugs] [Tk] (fvogel) tkt (New): Inconsistency between grid info, place info and pack info

[<no...@tc...>]

Automated mail by fx, on behalf of no...@tc...

Ticket Change [6814c59b6b05a467f8367e51949f74dc372a11f4751474fa92c65b56c7584057]
  [Inconsistency between grid info, place info and pack info]
  By      fvogel
  For     Tk
  On      2024-09-29T20:24:22.713
  Details https://core.tcl-lang.org/tk/tinfo?name=6814c59b6b05a467f8367e51949f74dc372a11f4751474fa92c65b56c7584057
  Ticket  https://core.tcl-lang.org/tk/tktview/3f5867c997a98d045bd656439a218c78ab4053a1

Changed Fields
  assignee:        nobody
  closer:          nobody
  comment:         With an un-gridded, un-placed, un-packed window, [grid info] and
                   [place info] return "" but [pack info] returns an error:

                   <verbatim>  % package require Tk  8.6.9  % frame .f  .f  % grid info
                   .f  % place info .f  % pack info .f  window ".f" isn't packed  %
                   </verbatim>

                   This looks inconsistent.

                   Note that this inconsistency is enforced in the test suite:

                   * the behavior of [pack info] in this case is tested by pack-17.2 (an
                   error is the expected result)  * the behavior of [grid info] in this
                   case is tested by grid-5.4 (the empty string is the expected result)
                   * the behavior of [place info] in this case is not tested
  foundin:         core-8-6-branch
  is_private:      0
  login:           fvogel
  priority:        5 Medium
  private_contact: a013af67114eccc19ad12b04f14923acea9e96b7
  resolution:      None
  severity:        Minor
  status:          Open
  submitter:       fvogel
  subsystem:       49. [grid]
  title:           Inconsistency between grid info, place info and pack info
  type:            Bug

------------------------------------------------------------
See Tcl/Tk development @ http://core.tcl-lang.org/
------------------------------------------------------------