Re: [TCLCORE] CFV on small high-prio TIPs

[Kevin K. <ke...@ac...>]

Donal K. Fellows wrote:
>   TIP #171: Change Default <MouseWheel> Bindings Behavior
YES.
The special variety of YES called, "I thought we did that a long
time ago. Silly me, I was using as.tcl all along."

>   TIP #197: Text Widget Persistant Cursor
YES.

>   TIP #210: Add 'tempname' Subcommand to 'file'
YES.

>   TIP #238: Fire Event when Widget Created
YES,  but see below.

>   TIP #284: New 'invoke' and 'namespace invoke' Commands
PRESENT.  As the user who provided the motivating example, I
can't quite bring myself to vote NO, but we seem to be moving
beyond this proposal in a slightly different direction.

>   TIP #306: Auto-Naming Widgets
NO.  Breaks much existing code, for only a minor gain in performance.

>   TIP #307: Make TclTransferResult() Public
YES.  Inoffensive.

>   TIP #335: An API for Detecting Active Interpreters
YES -- in the version that has Tcl_InterpActive; (NO to the one
that queries the stack level.)

>   TIP #336: Supported Access To interp->errorline
YES. With an apology for leaving this piece out of TIP #330.

>   TIP #337: Make TclBackgroundException() Public
YES.  Necessary.

>   TIP #338: Embedder Access to Startup Scripts of *_Main()
YES.  Tk limiting itself to the public API.  How cool is that?

-- 
73 de ke9tv/2, Kevin