Re: [TCLCORE] CFV: TIP 283

[miguel <ms...@us...>]

miguel wrote:
> As promised, here's the call for votes on
> 
> TIP #283: Modify Ensemble Command Resolution Behaviour

As both author and sponsor of the TIP, I would like to suspend the vote 
and withdraw the tip pending a clarification of the issues raised.

The patch was prepared and tested with the patch in [Bug 1577492], and 
submitted to a vote. That bugfix was later reverted for reasons 
independent of this TIP.

The adaptation of this TIP's implementation to function without that 
patch caused the [clock] auto initialisation to fail. That issue is easy 
enough to fix, but it worked as a canary. The failure has uncovered 
deeper issues that need to be thought about and resolved properly before 
considering this modification to the ensemble's resolution behaviour.

Should a withdrawal not be possible during a vote, I herewith change my 
vote to "NO". In any case, I expect to resubmit a similar TIP in the 
near future, in time for 8.5 consideration.

Please accept my apologies.

Miguel