Delete archive after extraction

Feroc
2010-07-05
2016-12-13
  • Feroc

    Feroc - 2010-07-05

    Hey,

    I really wish I could finally remove WinRAR from my machine, but it has one very important feature for me: It can delete the archive after successful extraction. I often have to extract a lot of archives (some multifile-archives, some single file archives, some rar, some zip, etc.).

    In WinRAR it is very easy, I just mark all file and let them extract in a different folder, WinRAR deletes everything that got successfully extracted and only leaves the archives, which weren't extracted. So I can easilie identify defect archives, have all my files extracted and the directory is cleaned up.

    Please please  please add a "Delete after extraction" option!

     
  • Vacon

    Vacon - 2010-07-05

    Hello everyone,

    yes, I read the word "option" you wrote above. But from my point of view it's kind of dangerous to have this. Imagine you have a backup of some files (documents or pictures for instance) and unpack them with the mentioned option activated -> backup = gone. If you notice that *before* you modify your data, well, you can backup again. If you notice this *after* modification -> backup = gone…
    Deleting data is usually a task users should do by themselves. Options are sometimes seducing…

    Best regards!

     
  • David Galbraith

    David Galbraith - 2010-07-08

    Yes, by all means don't allow people to make their own decisions. It's no less dangerous to manually delete files than letting it be done automatically by the program so you don't have to sort through a cluttered folder of 7z or rar files. Have you ever heard of something called "restore" in the recycle bin? You insult our intelligence.

     
  • Vacon

    Vacon - 2010-07-08

    Hello everyone,

    :-)
    Recycle-bin… You are talking about *that* recycle-bin that eats 5 to 10% of your HDD to save you some space when you "delete" something…? And that is *never*ever* made empty? And programs like ReCuva, TestDisk/PhotoRec are made because users simply can look into RecycleBin?
    Sorry if I insulted your intelligence :-)

    Best regards!

     
  • Vacon

    Vacon - 2010-07-08

    Hello everyone,

    oh, I nearly missed one point:
    files that have been on an USB-stick and have been uncompressed from there are deleted too. Most probably *not* to recycle-bin…
    Same is true for network-drives, iirc.

    Best regards!

     
  • Anonymous - 2010-07-19

    Note that this is the default behavior in Mac OS X, so there are literally millions of people who routinely interact this way with archives. Safari even extracts and thrashes every zip it downloads, without even a prompt. This by itself isn't proof of anything, but it does go to show that this isn't all that crazy of an idea. Reasonable people have looked at the question and found that the benefit in user experience is worth the trade-off in risk of data loss.

    In any case, I suggest a happy medium: add an optional context-menu entries for "Extract and Trash Archive". That way you know that the user has explicitly requested the deletion.

     
  • rororo299

    rororo299 - 2010-07-23

    But 7zip sets errorlevel upon an error. So you could write a batch file:

    c:\Programme\7-Zip\7z x %1
    if errorlevel 1 goto :error
    del %1
    :error

    Or use a more sophisticated script language like Perl, Ruby, Python, etc.

     
  • Anonymous - 2010-12-04

    I need delete after extraction too!   I get a lot of archives from newsgroups, especially ones in like 100 parts. lol  So being able to automatically delete after successful extraction like WinRAR can is a big plus (and why I have to keep WinRAR installed too).

    Then again 7zip is free so don't expect much. :P

     
  • Roger Moser

    Roger Moser - 2010-12-05

    I have added to the File Manager and to the FAR plugin the feature to delete the files from the disk after successfully moving them to an archive and to delete the files from the archive after successfully extracting them:

    http://pamho.com/7z/7z920rm2bin.7z (735kB, 32-bit executables)
    http://pamho.com/7z/7z920rm2src.7z (110kB, changed source files)

    In the File Manager press Shift while draging the file from or to an archive, or click "Move". And in the FAR Manager press "F6". Moving files from one archive to another archive is not supported. Unlike WinRar, it does not delete the file if the extracting was not successful. I have not programmed that the archive file itself is deleted when it became empty.

     
  • Vacon

    Vacon - 2010-12-05

    Hello everyone,

    if I get you right, your code checks if the extraction was successful and only deletes the files in an archive if everything went right?
    And in case all files inside an archive were extracted an empty archive is kept?

    Best regards!

     
  • Roger Moser

    Roger Moser - 2010-12-05

    If "move files" is selected, my versions deletes those files that have been successfully compressed or extracted. It deletes them also even if some files failed or if you answered "No" to some files. When you move all files from a achive, an empty archive remains, like if you move all files from a folder, an empty folder remains. You can then delete the empty archive by three clicks.

     
  • Vacon

    Vacon - 2010-12-05

    Hello everyone,

    It deletes them also even if some files failed or if you answered "No" to some files.

    yup. That's why I'm no real friend of automated deleting. And to be honest: regarding that feature, I always backed Igor to stand tall.
    And I'm curious how long it will take until people cry because they now have to delete *empty* archives after extraction instead of the original archives (there were people that felt strongly forced to tell us about the fact that they download some films or games spanned over 100 parts and wanted a feature to delete this 100 parts after extraction, because they are to laggard to do this manually…)

    Best regards!

     
  • Roger Moser

    Roger Moser - 2010-12-06

    That's why I'm no real friend of automated deleting.

    Then don't press the Shift key while you are draging the files but always press the Ctrl key. And never click "Move" or press  "F6".

     
  • Arto65

    Arto65 - 2011-03-24

    I have been using automatic deletion after successful exctraction since two years, and I can tell you one thing: it's awesome.
    The best extraction utility I use is "The unarchiver", on OS X. It has an option to extract the archive in a folder if there are more than 1 item at root: so it always behave exactly like myself, but it just takes less time! When I have 20 archives in a folder and I don't know what's inside it, it takes me 10 minutes to go through it. What a waste of time !!
    Another software to use that feature is Sabnzbd through winrar.

    There are millions of people using that feature and just loving it.
    I wished there were a program as convenient as The unarchiver on Windows.

     
  • xkiter

    xkiter - 2011-08-10

    Wonderful. Just what I was looking for several years. Only WinRAR had it and is ESSENTIAL for archiving. Is it going to be included in the official mainstream version?

     
  • vp1988

    vp1988 - 2011-09-12

    Deletion-after-extraction would be very time-saving feature for me too. For example, WinRAR also providing an option of asking user after extraction whether he want to delete the unpacked archive or not. Very useful for me, can't switch to 7-zip just because of that.

     
  • titus

    titus - 2011-09-19

    I archived a file and selected option to delete, however it's only deleting files not folder. Any help?

     
  • S

    S - 2012-03-31

    They should have it as a flag you can enter in the dos based version, so you have to choose -XD for example (with path and delete)
    Doesn't have to be in the GUI version if they don't want 'dummies' using the feature but I need it.

     
  • fernando

    fernando - 2012-03-31

    @abrasion

    7z e archive.7z && del archive.7z

    …not so difficult…

     
  • S

    S - 2012-03-31

    I assume the && is piping it back to a dos command?  
    That's not ideal, what if the rar file for example is
    HAM.RAR

    7z e HAM.RAR && del HAM.RAR

    I believe HAM.R01 HAM.R02 would be left on the disk then.
    Much better to do it the way WinRAR does it now.

     
  • xxx

    xxx - 2013-06-03

    Is there any way to get "Extract & delete archives" now ?
    Could be very useful

     
  • Veloce

    Veloce - 2016-07-19

    So it looks like people have been requesting this feature for 6 years.

    Any progress?

    Or are we being controlled by people who won't let us have scissors in case we run with them? :-)

     
  • KrashDummy

    KrashDummy - 2016-07-20

    I'm somehow mostly agreed to the statements saying that is actually a dangerous option, and I personally would vote it down.

    However, I assume this is a fairly easy task to do by using Autohotkey. In Explorer/Registry just assign a new application for that unpacking+delete task - that points to the ahk script.

     
  • Belfegor Vegeta

    Belfegor Vegeta - 2016-12-13

    I don't get the argument that it's dangerous, if you give the user the choice and disable this feature by default, give them a warning when enabling it, I don't see the issue. Stores shoudln't sell knives because it's dangerous?
    Better, how about like WinRAR you give the users another choice that is to have a pop up dialog at the end of a decompression to delete the files that constitute the sucessfully decompressed archive?
    "Delete archives after decompression?"
    * No (Default)
    * Ask
    * Yes (Use at your own risk)

     

Log in to post a comment.