Menu

#2448 When i choose the "Solid" option, it doesnt show "Solid 7-Zip SFX Archive" but just "7-Zip SFX Archive"

None
closed-rejected
nobody
None
5
2024-02-06
2024-02-04
Zadge PC
No

When i choose the "Solid" option, it doesnt show "Solid 7-Zip SFX Archive" but just "7-Zip SFX Archive"

1 Attachments

Discussion

  • Igor Pavlov

    Igor Pavlov - 2024-02-04

    It's not bug.
    And that window is not provided by 7-Zip.
    Some another program shows these properties for you.

     
    • Zadge PC

      Zadge PC - 2024-02-04

      wait, so its solid?

       
  • Zadge PC

    Zadge PC - 2024-02-04

    but my friend made a 7zip solid archive and it shows this for him:

     
    • Igor Pavlov

      Igor Pavlov - 2024-02-04

      1) archives can be different.
      2) there is some program that shows these properties (it's not 7-zip program). And these programs can be different (different versions) on two computers.

       
  • Zadge PC

    Zadge PC - 2024-02-04

    I put it on my computer and it shows solid

     
    • Igor Pavlov

      Igor Pavlov - 2024-02-04

      I put it on my computer and it shows solid

      what is "it" two times?

      Describe more details:
      there is
      user-1.
      computer 1
      windows version-1.
      7-zip version-1.
      that user-1 selects some files (what number of files?), selects some settings "what exact settings" and creates archive-1.
      Then user looks properties with some way.

      Then describe same things for user-2/computer-2.

      Also open archive in 7-zip with "Open archive" operation.
      And press "Info" button.

       

      Last edit: Igor Pavlov 2024-02-04
  • Zadge PC

    Zadge PC - 2024-02-05

    i made it solid but it shows as non-solid even in 7-zip (7-zip latest version 23.01)

     

    Last edit: Zadge PC 2024-02-05
    • Igor Pavlov

      Igor Pavlov - 2024-02-05

      There is no option for "Deflate" method in "7z " archive type in
      7-Zip.
      So what way did you create that archive?
      Create more examples (sfx and non-sfx), describe all selected settings.
      We must see the number of files and number of blocks at least.

       
  • Zadge PC

    Zadge PC - 2024-02-06

    this one is non-sfx

     
    • Igor Pavlov

      Igor Pavlov - 2024-02-06

      archive with 1 file cannot be solid.
      solid is used for 2 and more files.

       
      • Zadge PC

        Zadge PC - 2024-02-06

        with winrar it works with 1 file tho

         
        • Igor Pavlov

          Igor Pavlov - 2024-02-06

          rar have the field for "solid" status in archive.
          There is no such "solid field" in 7z archive.
          7-Zip analyses the content, and detects "solid" status.
          The archive with 1 solid file and archive iwth 1 non-solid file are identical.

           

          Last edit: Igor Pavlov 2024-02-06
          • Zadge PC

            Zadge PC - 2024-02-06

            ah ok thank you i understand now you can close the ticket :)

             
  • Zadge PC

    Zadge PC - 2024-02-06

    this one is sfx

     
  • Igor Pavlov

    Igor Pavlov - 2024-02-06
    • status: open --> closed-rejected
    • Group: -->
     

Log in to post a comment.