I can only imagine this is happening if you have it installed twice. Maybe not even like that. Anyway something like in the EFI partition and again in the OSX partition. This is just a guess...
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
For some reason, the rEFInd OS selection UI shows up twice when I turn on my computer. How do I remove the duplicate?
I can only imagine this is happening if you have it installed twice. Maybe not even like that. Anyway something like in the EFI partition and again in the OSX partition. This is just a guess...