Re: [Rails-devel] 18GA

[Erik V. <eri...@xs...>]

What is the value of green Augusta in v2? Blackwater Station says 40, but my
v1 tile has 30, and that is also what you specified in your list.

 

Van: Erik Vos [mailto:eri...@xs...] 
Verzonden: vrijdag 1 april 2011 20:59
Aan: 'Scott Petersen'
Onderwerp: RE: [Rails-devel] 18GA

 

No, better do it right the first time, but we're still in the middle of a
discussion trying to define: what is right?  I will not do anything before
that has been agreed upon.

 

There is no difference between v1 and v2, except that in v1 the tiles were
unnumbered, which is the source of the whole confusion.

 

I agree that it is probably best to conform to JDG's (v2) tile formats. So I
will change the tiles accordingly. I will also create a replacement for
#170.

The main open question for me is: will we keep using Thomas/Rocci's 3xx
internal numbers, or will I change to use Galt's 4xx numbers, with 1000
added to maintain uniqueness?

I tend to prefer the second option, as Blackwater Station is widely regarded
as authorative.

(as regards adding 1000: I think 1854 deserves the preference in using the
4xx numbers; IIRC that game was first to use that range).

 

Any other opinions?  I know that tile numbering questions often create
controversies, so I want to be sure.

 

Erik.

 

Van: sco...@gm... [mailto:sco...@gm...] Namens
Scott Petersen
Verzonden: vrijdag 1 april 2011 15:42
Aan: Development list for Rails: an 18xx game
CC: Erik Vos
Onderwerp: Re: [Rails-devel] 18GA

 

On Fri, Apr 1, 2011 at 8:34 AM, Erik Vos < <mailto:eri...@xs...>
eri...@xs...> wrote:

Yes, I can tweak the tiles any way I want, and even change their (internal)
numbers if required so. 

 

Erik.

 

Erik, unless you want to make the v2 tiles sometime soon (it looks like you
maybe do not), I'll use the v1 tiles and we can revise later.