Re: [Qutecsound-devel] how to include files in example
Brought to you by:
mantaraya36
Menu
▾
▴
Re: [Qutecsound-devel] how to include files in example
|
From: joachim h. <jh...@jo...> - 2021-08-19 13:10:57
|
i did some work on the examples and just pushed. so please merge any time you like. just to let you know i get these linker issues at the very end of my compilation: /usr/bin/ld: /home/jh/src/Qt5/5.15.2/gcc_64/lib/libQt5WebEngineCore.so: .dynsym local symbol at index 3 (>= sh_info of 3) /usr/bin/ld: /home/jh/src/Qt5/5.15.2/gcc_64/lib/libQt5WebEngineCore.so: .dynsym local symbol at index 4 (>= sh_info of 3) ... etc up to /usr/bin/ld: /home/jh/src/Qt5/5.15.2/gcc_64/lib/libQt5WebEngineCore.so: .dynsym local symbol at index 20 (>= sh_info of 3) not sure it is in any way related to the examples (probably not). it does not prevent me from building CsoundQt either. cheers - j On 17/08/2021 22:34, joachim heintz wrote: > yes definitely! i will try your changes and clean some examples > tomorrow; if all is ok please merge then. > cheers - > j > > > On 16/08/2021 23:02, Tarmo Johannes wrote: >> Hi! >> >> Thanks for noticing this! There was a hardcoded limit to filling the >> menus, I increased that to 256, so even big folders should build up >> nicely. >> Pushed to git. >> >> Does it seem OK to merge it to the develop branch (after some tiding >> up) soon? >> >> Best! >> tarmo >> >> Kontakt joachim heintz (<jh...@jo... >> <mailto:jh...@jo...>>) kirjutas kuupäeval R, 13. august 2021 >> kell 22:54: >> >> wonderful! >> >> i checked several examples, and all worked fine =) >> >> i found one issue in the FLOSS examples, 05 Sound Modification: >> i see only examples up to 05H02 in the dropdown menu. >> the other examples (05H03 and following) are in the source folder but >> not in my built. >> >> can you check if it is the same for you? >> >> (please pull first; idid some small changes to some examples.) >> >> cheers - >> joachim >> >> >> >> >> On 12/08/2021 22:37, Tarmo Johannes wrote: >> > Hi! >> > >> > I finished now a new system for managing examples, it is done >> at the >> > moment in separate path "examples": >> > https://github.com/CsoundQt/CsoundQt/tree/examples >> <https://github.com/CsoundQt/CsoundQt/tree/examples> >> > <https://github.com/CsoundQt/CsoundQt/tree/examples >> <https://github.com/CsoundQt/CsoundQt/tree/examples>> >> > >> > 1) I moved the examples from source root directory to >> > src/Examples/CsoundQt (maybe there is a better name for it, >> Joachim?). >> > src/Examples will be the place where we can put all the examples >> from now on >> > 2) the Examples menu is filled automatically according the >> subfolders in >> > the Examples path. It means we can easily add new categories, >> regroup >> > the examples etc - managing the examples does not require >> touching the >> > CsoundQt source code any more >> > 3) I moved source materials from FLOSS ans McCurdy one level >> up, to >> > src/Examples/SourceMateriald and got rid of the duplicates this >> way. I >> > changed the current references to ../../SourceMaterials in >> csd-s. New >> > source materials can be put there, too, if needed for new >> examples. >> > 4) The examples folder should be found automatically in most >> cases, but >> > for special occasions, I added an option under >> > Configuration->Environment to set the path of examples folder, if >> user >> > needs to. >> > >> > I still think it is good to move the examples out to another repo >> > (CsoundQt/Examples perhaps?) and use it as a git submodule - so >> it can >> > be pulled easily together with CsoundQt source but it is >> possible to >> > pull also just source, without examples (this is probably good >> for linux >> > packagers), too. The benefit is that managing examples gets >> independent, >> > you can always download newest version from git as zip, also it >> gets >> > more easy and clearer to handle, so we can hope to get more >> people to >> > contribute and take care of the example base. I don't know how >> to do >> > the submodule thing, to be honest, but I will figure out, if you >> agree >> > it makes sense. >> > >> > Joachim, if you have a chance to test if the examples work, would >> be great! >> > >> > tarmo >> > >> > >> > Kontakt joachim heintz (<jh...@jo... >> <mailto:jh...@jo...> >> > <mailto:jh...@jo... <mailto:jh...@jo...>>>) >> kirjutas kuupäeval E, 2. august 2021 kell >> > 23:11: >> > >> > hi - >> > >> > sounds great what you say about your work on this! thanks a >> lot for >> > doing it so fast. >> > >> > i am not sure i understand your discussion well, about the >> own repo for >> > the examples. but i'd definitely prefer to have the examples >> > *included* >> > in CsoundQt, as it was. i think the examples are one of the >> pros for >> > CsoundQt, and we should not require to be always online or >> something (i >> > just was in the middle of germany and had no internet access, >> not even >> > mobile ...). >> > >> > cheers - >> > joachim >> > >> > >> > >> > On 02/08/2021 17:01, Tarmo Johannes wrote: >> > > Hi! >> > > >> > > 1) Started work on moving all examples to src/Examples. I >> do it in a >> > > separate branch (examples) just for any case. I have not >> pushed >> > it yet >> > > though. >> > > >> > > I moved the main examples to Examples/CsoundQt and >> expanded a bit >> > the >> > > folders where the examples can be found.. The only >> example/csd >> > that has >> > > to be delivered within the resources with the binary is >> Eduardo's >> > > AudioMidiTest.csd as I find it absolutely necessary to >> have it >> > by the >> > > program in all times. >> > > >> > > The menu gets populated automatically quite fine, it >> needs some >> > more >> > > work (Getting Started submenus and Stria Synth), I moved >> all >> > resources >> > > files to Examples/SourceMaterials Next step is to change >> McCurdy and >> > > Floss examples so that they would use the one path and >> would not >> > > duplicate the files. >> > > >> > > Now I have to finish but hopefully I will put it out for >> testing >> > soon. >> > > >> > > >> > > 2) Moving the examples to separate git repo is very good >> idea, I >> > think. >> > > Eduardo, did you have in mind that it is the CsoundQt >> program >> > that does >> > > the git pull or it the user/packager who pulls it via git >> submodules >> > > before building? The first case won't probably work since >> most of >> > users >> > > don't have git installed. >> > > >> > > >> > > Greetings, >> > > tarmo >> > > >> > > Kontakt Eduardo Moguillansky >> (<edu...@gm... >> <mailto:edu...@gm...> >> > <mailto:edu...@gm... >> <mailto:edu...@gm...>> >> > > <mailto:edu...@gm... >> <mailto:edu...@gm...> >> > <mailto:edu...@gm... >> <mailto:edu...@gm...>>>>) kirjutas kuupäeval R, 30. >> > > juuli 2021 kell 14:42: >> > > >> > > Another idea: >> > > >> > > Maybe the examples could be moved to their own repo. >> In linux >> > (or in >> > > the other platforms as well) this repo could be >> cloned/pulled by >> > > csoundqt. Then the examples and their resources would >> be in >> > > predictable places and the resources can be accessed by >> > relative paths. >> > > >> > > eduardo >> > > >> > > On 30.07.21 13:35, Tarmo Johannes wrote: >> > >> Yes, >> > >> >> > >> I agree it makes sense to rework it. On MacOs and >> Windows >> > with the >> > >> installers it is no problem, on Linux we must make >> sure that the >> > >> examples can be found, perhaps there should be an >> option in the >> > >> configuration. >> > >> >> > >> Greetings, >> > >> Tarmo >> > >> >> > >> R, 30. juuli 2021 13:43 joachim heintz >> <jh...@jo... <mailto:jh...@jo...> >> > <mailto:jh...@jo... <mailto:jh...@jo...>> >> > >> <mailto:jh...@jo... >> <mailto:jh...@jo...> <mailto:jh...@jo... >> <mailto:jh...@jo...>>>> >> > kirjutas: >> > >> >> > >> thanks for the reply, tarmo! >> > >> >> > >> the inclusion of sound files into some of the csd >> > examples is >> > >> not only >> > >> an issue for ImitativeAdditive.csd. there are a >> couple >> > of other >> > >> examples which i would like to change, too. so >> moving the >> > >> examples to >> > >> another category is no solution. >> > >> >> > >> after your explanation i have two ideas: >> > >> >> > >> 1. would it be possible (and not too hard) to >> treat the >> > current >> > >> /examples in the same way as src/Examples? this >> means that >> > >> they are not >> > >> compiled, but just copied. i think this is >> actually also >> > >> better because >> > >> then the users can access the csd files. and we >> could >> > add the >> > >> sound >> > >> files in a similar way i did it with the floss >> manual >> > examples. >> > >> i think this would be the best solution. >> > >> >> > >> 2. if not possible, the method you described >> should be >> > allright: >> > >> "Thus the fox.wav added this way should be >> copied (by >> > Qt) to a >> > >> temporary >> > >> location first and the path should be given to >> Csound via >> > >> --env:SSDIR+= >> > >> or setting environment variable." >> > >> >> > >> let me know what you think; cheers - >> > >> >> > >> joachim >> > >> >> > >> >> > >> On 30/07/2021 11:34, Tarmo Johannes wrote: >> > >> > Hi! >> > >> > >> > >> > Sorry, I did see your email but waited for a >> good >> > moment to >> > >> try it out. >> > >> > I did not yet but for now I can explain the >> background: >> > >> > >> > >> > there are two places for examples - <CsoundQt >> source >> > >> folder>/examples >> > >> > and and <source>/src/Examples >> > >> > >> > >> > The first gets compiled as binary code to >> CsoundQt as Qt >> > >> resource, the >> > >> > second, the "extended examples" (Floss, McCurdy, >> > Stria) gets >> > >> installed >> > >> > to the system as normal folders. >> > >> > >> > >> > The problem is that Qt can read from the >> compiled-in >> > >> resource but Csound >> > >> > not. Thus the fox.wav added this way should be >> copied (by >> > >> Qt) to a >> > >> > temporary location first and the path should be >> given to >> > >> Csound via >> > >> > --env:SSDIR+= or setting environment variable. >> Quite some >> > >> hassle. >> > >> > >> > >> > One solution is to add the material to the end >> of csd with >> > >> the <CsFileB >> > >> > filename="fox.wav"></CsFileB> (I forgot which >> tool >> > helps to >> > >> do it) (like >> > >> > in case of Synths/Scanned_Synthes_Sandbox.csd) >> > >> > but anyway - I think at some point Andés and >> René >> > discussed >> > >> it and >> > >> > decided that no large source materials are >> added to >> > >> src/examples - it >> > >> > makes just the CsoundQt binary grow. >> > >> > >> > >> > Much simpler way would be to put >> > ImitiativeAdditive.csd into >> > >> the real >> > >> > folder under "src/Examples" where fox.wav is >> is in >> > >> > src/Examples/FLOSS Manual >> Examples/SourceMaterials/ >> > and set >> > >> the SSDIR >> > >> > relative to the csd. Perhaps it makes sense to >> do another >> > >> folder like: >> > >> > >> > >> > src/Examples/Other (please think about a good >> name) >> > and then >> > >> > --env:SSDIR+=../FLOSS Manual >> Examples/SourceMaterials >> > >> > should work. >> > >> > >> > >> > I am not sure at the moment if the Examples >> menu gets >> > populated >> > >> > automatically or we need to create another >> entry. in >> > the code. >> > >> > >> > >> > Please let me know what you think and if I >> can help >> > somehow? >> > >> > >> > >> > tarmo >> > >> > >> > >> > Kontakt joachim heintz (<jh...@jo... >> <mailto:jh...@jo...> >> > <mailto:jh...@jo... <mailto:jh...@jo...>> >> > >> <mailto:jh...@jo... >> <mailto:jh...@jo...> <mailto:jh...@jo... >> <mailto:jh...@jo...>>> >> > >> > <mailto:jh...@jo... >> <mailto:jh...@jo...> >> > <mailto:jh...@jo... <mailto:jh...@jo...>> >> <mailto:jh...@jo... <mailto:jh...@jo...> >> > <mailto:jh...@jo... <mailto:jh...@jo...>>>>>) >> > >> kirjutas kuupäeval R, 30. juuli 2021 kell >> > >> > 10:31: >> > >> > >> > >> > hi tarmo, hi eduardo - >> > >> > >> > >> > i wrote an email to the csoundqt dev >> list. think this >> > >> would be >> > >> > great to >> > >> > include in csoundqt 1.0.0. can you >> help? the >> > text below. >> > >> > >> > >> > i want to include "fox.wav" in >> > >> Examples/Synths/ImitiativeAdditive.csd. >> > >> > >> > >> > what is the best way to achieve this? >> > >> > >> > >> > in the McCurdy and FLOSS examples, i once >> inserted the >> > >> option: >> > >> > --env:SSDIR+=../SourceMaterials >> > >> > >> > >> > i tried the same here (locally, no push to >> git): >> > >> > 1. i created a folder "SourceMaterials" >> in the >> > examples/ >> > >> directory, >> > >> > with >> > >> > fox.wav in it. >> > >> > 2. i inserted this around line 4600 in >> > src/qutecsound.cpp: >> > >> > QStringList sourceMaterials; >> > >> > sourceMaterials << >> > >> ":/examples/SourceMaterials/fox.wav"; >> > >> > subMenus << sourceMaterials; >> > >> > subMenuNames << >> tr("SourceMaterials"); >> > >> > 3. and in application.qrc: >> > >> > <file>../examples/SourceMaterials/fox.wav</file> >> > >> > >> > >> > after recompiling, the folder >> "SourceMaterials" >> > shows up >> > >> in the menu, >> > >> > but the fox.wav is not found by csound. >> > >> > >> > >> > perhaps i forgot one step? >> > >> > >> > >> > but anyway, i think it is a nasty way to do >> it. >> > so back >> > >> to the >> > >> > question >> > >> > above: how can it be done better, properly? >> > >> > >> > >> > cheers - >> > >> > joachim >> > >> > >> > >> >> > >> > >> > _______________________________________________ >> > Qutecsound-devel mailing list >> > Qut...@li... >> <mailto:Qut...@li...> >> > <mailto:Qut...@li... >> <mailto:Qut...@li...>> >> > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/qutecsound-devel >> <https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/qutecsound-devel> >> > >> <https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/qutecsound-devel >> <https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/qutecsound-devel>> >> > >> > > > _______________________________________________ > Qutecsound-devel mailing list > Qut...@li... > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/qutecsound-devel |
