Re: [Quickfixj-users] Unexpected "MsgSeqNum too low, expecting X but received Y"

SourceForge Headquarters 1320 Columbia Street Suite 310 San Diego, CA 92101 +1 (858) 422-6466

Hi,
Yeah, I agree with you .
When I deleted ToAppRejectMessageHandler ,the program is work well .

Thanks for your help !

Cheers.

Christoph John <chr...@ma...> 于2021年3月26日周五 下午7:47写道：

> Hi,
>
> I am not entirely sure since I cannot make sense of all of your logging
> output but I think the problem is as follows:
> You get this message:
>
> message=8=FIXT.1.1^9=369^35=8^34=55^43=Y^49=Initiator^52=20210326-08:42:35.718^56=Acceptor^122=20210326-08:42:35.703^1=108331^14=0^15=USD^17=1115569_1615646513221_927^22=971^37=1115569^38=1^39=0^40=4^44=290.2^48=BCH/USD^54=1^55=BCHUSD^59=1^60=20210313-14:41:53.099^150=0^151=1^167=CRYPTSPOT^423=3^460=15^581=1^965=1^1084=4^1138=0^453=2^448=MATX^447=G^452=22^448=MEHSAG1601PIND90805^447=D^452=3^10=113^
>
> and then seem to apply some logic to it in the
> "ToAppRejectMessageHandler". After that the same ExecReport is logged but
> with PossDup set to false (43=N):
>
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.718  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : added
> possDupFlag:8=FIXT.1.1^9=369^35=8^34=55^43=N^49=Initiator^52=20210326-08:42:35.718^56=Acceptor^122=20210326-08:42:35.703^1=108331^14=0^15=USD^17=1115569_1615646513221_927^22=971^37=1115569^38=1^39=0^40=4^44=290.2^48=BCH/USD^54=1^55=BCHUSD^59=1^60=20210313-14:41:53.099^150=0^151=1^167=CRYPTSPOT^423=3^460=15^581=1^965=1^1084=4^1138=0^453=2^448=MATX^447=G^452=22^448=MEHSAG1601PIND90805^447=D^452=3^10=102^
>
> And then I think you pass that ExecReport to QFJ instead of the original
> one with PossDup=Y.
>
> This would support what I wrote in my initial mail that something about
> the PossDup handling seems to be wrong.
> When the PossDup flag is not set or set to false then the seqnum of that
> message is checked against the next expected seqnum. Since the next
> expected seqnum is 56 the session is getting logged out.
>
> In general I would not suggest to interfere with the session-level
> processing but let QFJ do its job. :)
> What do you think? Does this make sense to you?
>
> Cheers,
> Chris.
>
>
>
>
> On 26.03.21 09:46, charles meng wrote:
>
>
> Here is the message log for 2.1.1.
>
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.704  INFO 40318 --- [nio-9051-exec-2]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : =>> Send toApp message to FIX
> gateway, MsgType=ExecutionReport(8), MsgSeqNum=55
> sessionId=FIXT.1.1:Initiator->Acceptor
>
> message=8=FIXT.1.1^9=338^35=8^34=55^49=Initiator^52=20210326-08:42:35.703^56=Acceptor^1=108331^14=0^15=USD^17=1115569_1615646513221_927^22=971^37=1115569^38=1^39=0^40=4^44=290.2^48=BCH/USD^54=1^55=BCHUSD^59=1^60=20210313-14:41:53.099^150=0^151=1^167=CRYPTSPOT^423=3^460=15^581=1^965=1^1084=4^1138=0^453=2^448=MATX^447=G^452=22^448=MEHSAG1601PIND90805^447=D^452=3^10=103^
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.704  INFO 40318 --- [nio-9051-exec-2]
> c.m.f.s.listener.SenderMessageCracker    : ExecutionReport - handle
> ExecutionReport message
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.707  INFO 40318 --- [nio-9051-exec-2]
> c.m.f.s.d.handle.MessageHandlerContext   : ===cracker type :TO_APP_REJECT
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.707  INFO 40318 --- [nio-9051-exec-2]
> c.m.f.s.d.handle.MessageHandlerContext   : ====do handle
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.707  INFO 40318 --- [nio-9051-exec-2]
> c.m.f.s.d.h.ToAppRejectMessageHandler    : ===not approved retransmit
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.708  INFO 40318 --- [nio-9051-exec-2]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : added
> possDupFlag:8=FIXT.1.1^9=343^35=8^34=55^43=N^49=Initiator^52=20210326-08:42:35.703^56=Acceptor^1=108331^14=0^15=USD^17=1115569_1615646513221_927^22=971^37=1115569^38=1^39=0^40=4^44=290.2^48=BCH/USD^54=1^55=BCHUSD^59=1^60=20210313-14:41:53.099^150=0^151=1^167=CRYPTSPOT^423=3^460=15^581=1^965=1^1084=4^1138=0^453=2^448=MATX^447=G^452=22^448=MEHSAG1601PIND90805^447=D^452=3^10=086^
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.708  INFO 40318 --- [nio-9051-exec-2]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : possDubFlag:false
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.711  INFO 40318 --- [nio-9051-exec-2]
> c.m.f.s.infra.SenderApplicationService   : [API Call]
> sendHigherSeqNoThanExcepted success，higherThanExpected=55, msgType=8
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.714  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : <<= Initiator received fromAdmin
> message, MsgType=Resend(2), MsgSeqNum=42
> sessionId: FIXT.1.1:Initiator->Acceptor
> message:
> 8=FIXT.1.1^9=78^35=2^34=42^49=Acceptor^52=20210326-08:42:35.711^56=Initiator^369=49^7=50^16=0^10=063^
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.714  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.SenderMessageCracker    : ResendRequest - from,
> beginSeqNo=50, endSeqNo=0
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.718  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : =>> Send toApp message to FIX
> gateway, MsgType=ExecutionReport(8), MsgSeqNum=55
> sessionId=FIXT.1.1:Initiator->Acceptor
>
> message=8=FIXT.1.1^9=369^35=8^34=55^43=Y^49=Initiator^52=20210326-08:42:35.718^56=Acceptor^122=20210326-08:42:35.703^1=108331^14=0^15=USD^17=1115569_1615646513221_927^22=971^37=1115569^38=1^39=0^40=4^44=290.2^48=BCH/USD^54=1^55=BCHUSD^59=1^60=20210313-14:41:53.099^150=0^151=1^167=CRYPTSPOT^423=3^460=15^581=1^965=1^1084=4^1138=0^453=2^448=MATX^447=G^452=22^448=MEHSAG1601PIND90805^447=D^452=3^10=113^
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.718  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.SenderMessageCracker    : ExecutionReport - handle
> ExecutionReport message
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.718  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.d.handle.MessageHandlerContext   : ===cracker type :TO_APP_REJECT
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.718  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.d.handle.MessageHandlerContext   : ====do handle
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.718  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.d.h.ToAppRejectMessageHandler    : ===not approved retransmit
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.718  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : added
> possDupFlag:8=FIXT.1.1^9=369^35=8^34=55^43=N^49=Initiator^52=20210326-08:42:35.718^56=Acceptor^122=20210326-08:42:35.703^1=108331^14=0^15=USD^17=1115569_1615646513221_927^22=971^37=1115569^38=1^39=0^40=4^44=290.2^48=BCH/USD^54=1^55=BCHUSD^59=1^60=20210313-14:41:53.099^150=0^151=1^167=CRYPTSPOT^423=3^460=15^581=1^965=1^1084=4^1138=0^453=2^448=MATX^447=G^452=22^448=MEHSAG1601PIND90805^447=D^452=3^10=102^
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.718  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : possDubFlag:false
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.719  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : =>> Send toAdmin message to FIX
> gateway, MsgType=SequenceReset(4), MsgSeqNum=50
> sessionId: FIXT.1.1:Initiator->Acceptor
> message:
> 8=FIXT.1.1^9=104^35=4^34=50^43=Y^49=Initiator^52=20210326-08:42:35.719^56=Acceptor^122=20210326-08:42:35.718^36=55^123=Y^10=182^
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.719  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.SenderMessageCracker    : SequenceReset - to
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.719  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.SenderMessageCracker    : expected sender num compare to
> new seq no:true,NewSeqNo:55,ExpectedSenderNum:56
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.719  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.SenderMessageCracker    : SequenceReset
> finally:8=FIXT.1.1^9=104^35=4^34=50^43=Y^49=Initiator^52=20210326-08:42:35.719^56=Acceptor^122=20210326-08:42:35.718^36=55^123=Y^10=182^
> 2021-03-26 08:42:35.726  INFO 40318 --- [ssage Processor]
> c.m.f.s.listener.FixApplicationListener  : <<= Initiator received fromAdmin
> message, MsgType=Logout(5), MsgSeqNum=43
> sessionId: FIXT.1.1:Initiator->Acceptor
> message:
> 8=FIXT.1.1^9=126^35=5^34=43^49=Acceptor^52=20210326-08:42:35.723^56=Initiator^369=55^1128=9^58=MsgSeqNum
> too low, expecting 56 but received 55^10=010^
>
>
> Thanks
> Best regards.
>
> Christoph John <chr...@ma...> 于2021年3月26日周五 下午2:43写道：
>
>> Just saw that you are using 2.1.1. The other side uses the same version?
>> Could you maybe try to reproduce with version 2.2.0 and paste the
>> relevant message log? Or at least paste the message log from your currently
>> used version.
>> Thanks
>>
>> Am 26. März 2021 07:40:23 MEZ schrieb Christoph John <
>> chr...@ma...>:
>>>
>>> Hi,
>>> which version of QFJ are you and the other side using?
>>> Could you please directly paste the relevant message log from your side
>>> and if possible also from the acceptor?
>>> Thanks,
>>> Chris.
>>
>>
> --
> Christoph John
> Software Engineering
> T +49 241 557...@ma...
>
> MACD GmbH
> Oppenhoffallee 103
> 52066 Aachen, Germanywww.macd.com
>
> Amtsgericht Aachen: HRB 8151
> Ust.-Id: DE 813021663
> Geschäftsführer: George Macdonald
>
>