Re: [Quickfix-developers] QuickFix sending reject messages on my execution reports because of missing repeating group information

[Andrew C. <And...@Tw...>]

Of course I don't have control of the message being sent to me :)

I'll see if FXAll is willing to correct their messages - sometimes they
have the info, sometimes not.


Has repeating group info
=20
8=3DFIX.4.2=019=3D340=0135=3D8=0149=3DFXALL=0156=3Dfimatna=0134=3D165=015=
2=3D20060914-18:23:36=0137=3D
1187804=0176=3DBANK1=0117=3D1187804=0120=3D0=01150=3D2=0139=3D2=011=3Duse=
r1@fimatna=0164=3D20060918=01
55=3DEUR/USD=0154=3D1=0138=3D1000000=0115=3DEUR=0132=3D1000000=0131=3D1.2=
738=01194=3D1.2738=01195=3D0.
=0114=3D1000000=016=3D1.2738=0175=3D20060914=01119=3D1273800.=01120=3DUSD=
=01
6977=3D1=016978=3DBANK1=016979=3D1.2737=016980=3D0.00=016981=3D1.2737=016=
982=3D1.2738=016983=3D0.0
0=016984=3D1.2738=0110=3D080=01

Does not have repeating group info - why?
=20
8=3DFIX.4.2=019=3D261=0135=3D8=0149=3DFXALL=0156=3Dfimatna=0134=3D166=015=
2=3D20060914-18:23:36=0137=3D
1187805=0176=3DBANK1=0117=3D1187805=0120=3D0=01150=3D2=0139=3D2=011=3Duse=
r1@fimatna=0164=3D20060918=01
55=3DEUR/USD=0154=3D2=0138=3D1000000=0115=3DEUR=0132=3D1000000=0131=3D1.2=
737=01194=3D1.2737=01195=3D0.
=0114=3D1000000=016=3D1.2737=0175=3D20060914=01119=3D1273700.=01120=3DUSD=
=01
6977=3D1=0110=3D019=01

Associated rejections message
=20
8=3DFIX.4.2=019=3D129=0135=3D3=0134=3D134=0149=3Dfimatna=0152=3D20060914-=
18:23:35.747=0156=3DFXALL
=0145=3D166=0158=3DIncorrect NumInGroup count for repeating
group=01371=3D6977=01372=3D8=0110=3D037=01



-----Original Message-----
From: Oren Miller [mailto:or...@qu...]=20
Sent: Thursday, September 14, 2006 2:22 PM
To: And...@Tw...
Cc: qui...@li...
Subject: Re: [Quickfix-developers] QuickFix sending reject messages on
my execution reports because of missing repeating group information


The message is bad.  If there is no repeating group info, then the 6971
field should not be present.  A case could possibly be made that it you
could send it with a value of 0, but 1 is definately wrong.

Do you have the power to change how that message is being sent or is it
out of your control?  We don't currently have a setting for turning off
this validation, but it could potentially be added.

--oren

> Thanks in advance - couple of examples below - a good execution report

> (notice 6977=3D2 and we have repeating group info - I get this message =

> passed up to my app), a bad execution report (notice 6977=3D1, no=20
> repeating group info, QuickFix sends the reject message automatically