Menu

#24 [select] doesn't always work with symbol selector

open
puredata (322)
5
2005-06-20
2005-04-26
No

a [select] without a creation argument cannot use a
symbol selector. A float will work fine on the right
inlet, but a symbol will not.

Also, a [select] with a symbol argument won't take a
float on the right inlet, and vice-versa.

Discussion

  • Hans-Christoph Steiner

    pd patch illustrating bugs

     
  • IOhannes m zmölnig

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=564396

    i always considered this "well defined behaviour" of
    [select] and not a bug.

    it reacts similar to [route], but this should be documented
    in the reference-patch

     
  • IOhannes m zmölnig

    • assigned_to: nobody --> millerpuckette
     
  • Jonathan Wilkes

    Jonathan Wilkes - 2013-02-06

    I already changed [select] in pd-l2ork so you can mix symbol and float args together. I suppose I could also make the right inlet a proxy inlet so it can also take a float or symbol message, which is way more useful since people seem to rarely mix float and symbol args in [select] anyway.

     
  • Nobody/Anonymous

    both are useful, and would be great patches to submit.

     
  • Jonathan Wilkes

    Jonathan Wilkes - 2013-02-19

    fix attempted with patch #3605240

     

Anonymous
Anonymous

Add attachments
Cancel