Menu

#869 editing an allele in exisiting session

None
open
nobody
None
6
2015-07-07
2015-05-29
No

This might be OK, but I wanted to note it.

I changed an allele of cdc2 in an existing session to standardize it.
See screenshot cdc2-1w gene page
cdc2.1w is the same as cdc2-1w so I changed to -1w which is used on the rest of the page

The edit seemed to go OK, except in the title
New phenotype annotations fro this session...
it is still called SPBC1B10.09-cdc2.1w
(see screenshot cdc2-1w)

1 Attachments

Discussion

  • Valerie Wood

    Valerie Wood - 2015-05-29

    screenshot

     
  • Kim Rutherford

    Kim Rutherford - 2015-06-01

    Sorry, I don't understand this. Let's talk about it next time we chat.

     
  • Midori Harris

    Midori Harris - 2015-06-01

    I get it. Val has changed the name for an allele, but that didn't change the name of the corresponding single-allele genotype.

    It might be a bit clearer if you look at the genotype details:
    http://curation.pombase.org/pombe/curs/1cf6a37d7872772f/feature/genotype/view/5/ro

     
  • Kim Rutherford

    Kim Rutherford - 2015-06-02

    Ah, thanks. Currently the allele has name and the genotype has a name and they are stored separately. Changing the name of an allele of a genotype won't change the genotype name.

     
  • Midori Harris

    Midori Harris - 2015-06-02

    Definitely not essential for unleashing to the community, but this behavior would be nice:

    • Don't change a user-specified genotype name unless that field is explicitly edited (accept "my cool genotype" --> "the coolest genotype ever", but don't change the name upon "yfg1.17" --> "yfg1-17").

    • For a genotype that's just been added in a session, but not named by the user, do update an automagically-generated genotype name when any of the allele names from which it's built are changed.

    • Warn if an allele used in an existing genotype gets renamed. (We might have to think this one through a little more fully than I have just now.)

     
  • Valerie Wood

    Valerie Wood - 2015-07-07
    • Priority: 5 --> 6
     

Log in to post a comment.