phpxpath-users

idw - continued

[Peter R. <ph...@pe...>]

can't say I've been inundated with solutions to my previous posting :-(, but 
it's actually easy to fix w/o recompiling PHP as Dan suggests. Just escape 
the underscores in eregs, i.e. on lines 1990 and 2778.

Having fixed that, I now have a different problem.

I have an xml file with large numbers of child (+ grandchild ...) nodes which 
may or may not be present. My old phpxml script did an evaluate for the top 
level and then get_Contents for any children it needed; if a child didn't 
exist, phpxml simply set the variable to null. phpxpath, however, seems to 
throw an error and refuse to continue if you try and getData or getDataParts 
for a child or attribute that doesn't exist. If I have to do a match/evaluate 
for each of these nodes before getData, not only is that a lot of extra work 
but I'll probably have to rewrite the logic. 

Can phpxpath be changed to be like phpxml and simply set the variable to null 
if getData doesn't find the node?

Re: idw - continued

[Nigel S. <nig...@us...>]

(I know this thread is kinda old, but it's been in my inbox all month...)


> can't say I've been inundated with solutions to my previous posting :-(,
but
> it's actually easy to fix w/o recompiling PHP as Dan suggests. Just escape
> the underscores in eregs, i.e. on lines 1990 and 2778.

That's cos you ask hard questions :o)

> Having fixed that, I now have a different problem.
>
> I have an xml file with large numbers of child (+ grandchild ...) nodes
which
> may or may not be present. My old phpxml script did an evaluate for the
top
> level and then get_Contents for any children it needed; if a child didn't
> exist, phpxml simply set the variable to null. phpxpath, however, seems to
> throw an error and refuse to continue if you try and getData or
getDataParts
> for a child or attribute that doesn't exist. If I have to do a
match/evaluate
> for each of these nodes before getData, not only is that a lot of extra
work
> but I'll probably have to rewrite the logic.
>
> Can phpxpath be changed to be like phpxml and simply set the variable to
null
> if getData doesn't find the node?

A good point.  Sounds annoying.  :o(

I think the plan is to support different levels of error reporting, so when
you build the class, you set an option to say what kind of errors you want.
So what you'd do then is say that you don't want errors if the node doesn't
exist and you'd be happy, and if you want it to complain, you can leave the
errors on.  So yeah, we are aiming for this too :o)

Nigel

===========================
For the most recent version of Php.XPath, and an archive of this list visit:
http://www.sourceforge.net/projects/phpxpath

Re: idw - continued

[Peter R. <php...@pe...>]

On Friday 18 Jan 2002 12:02 am, Nigel Swinson wrote:
>
> I think the plan is to support different levels of error reporting, so when
> you build the class, you set an option to say what kind of errors you want.
> So what you'd do then is say that you don't want errors if the node doesn't
> exist and you'd be happy, and if you want it to complain, you can leave the
> errors on.  So yeah, we are aiming for this too :o)

sounds good to me.

Don't want to be a pest, but . . . got any idea of an ETA? At the moment, I'm 
still running the original phpxml script, which is not the most rapid . . .

Re: idw - continued

[Nigel S. <nig...@us...>]

> > I think the plan is to support different levels of error reporting, so
when
> > you build the class, you set an option to say what kind of errors you
want.
> > So what you'd do then is say that you don't want errors if the node
doesn't
> > exist and you'd be happy, and if you want it to complain, you can leave
the
> > errors on.  So yeah, we are aiming for this too :o)
>
> sounds good to me.
>
> Don't want to be a pest, but . . . got any idea of an ETA? At the moment,
I'm
> still running the original phpxml script, which is not the most rapid . .
.

Think the plan is something as follows:

- Finish the test harness

V2.3 - February/March

- Tidy and clean up whitespace issues

V2.4 - April/May

- Enhance and optimize

V2.5- Summer

But then you know how these things go.  The brakes have been on fairly hard
over Christmas as I was building my new hardware and software.  Sam and Dan
have both been very busy too.  Under no circumstances should you "plan"
round these release dates.  I'm just giving you an idea as to what the
targets are in my mind.

:o)

Nigel

Re: variable node structure (was idw - continued)

[Peter R. <php...@pe...>]

Going back to this thread, I've been looking into this a bit further and I 
find that getAttributes works as I would like whereas getData doesn't. So if 
I do 

getAttributes( ... specific attribute that doesn't exist)

it returns false, so I can do

if ($var = getAttributes)
   do whatever with $var;

which is what I want. Bizarrely, if I do the same with getData, i.e. for a 
path to an attribute that doesn't exist, it fails with an error.

So rather than different levels of reporting, I think all I really need is 
for getData (and for that matter nodeName, which has the same problem) to 
behave like getAttributes and return false if the node does not exist.

At the moment, given a xml file with variable structure, evaluate seems to be 
the only way of getting, for example, a list of child nodes or finding if a 
particular node exists. Evaluate, though, seems to really slow things down. 
I've just converted one such file from phpxml to phpxpath, thinking that it 
would speed things up, and it's actually substantially slower - I think 
because of all the evaluates that I have to include to check whether child 
nodes exist or not.


On Friday 18 Jan 2002 12:02 am, Nigel Swinson wrote:
> >
> > I have an xml file with large numbers of child (+ grandchild ...) nodes 
which
> > may or may not be present. My old phpxml script did an evaluate for the
> top
> > level and then get_Contents for any children it needed; if a child didn't
> > exist, phpxml simply set the variable to null. phpxpath, however, seems
> > to throw an error and refuse to continue if you try and getData or
> getDataParts
>
> > for a child or attribute that doesn't exist. If I have to do a
>
> match/evaluate
>
> > for each of these nodes before getData, not only is that a lot of extra
>
> work
>
> > but I'll probably have to rewrite the logic.
> >
> > Can phpxpath be changed to be like phpxml and simply set the variable to
>
> null
>
> > if getData doesn't find the node?
>
> A good point.  Sounds annoying.  :o(
>
> I think the plan is to support different levels of error reporting, so when
> you build the class, you set an option to say what kind of errors you want.
> So what you'd do then is say that you don't want errors if the node doesn't
> exist and you'd be happy, and if you want it to complain, you can leave the
> errors on.  So yeah, we are aiming for this too :o)