Re: [Phpwiki-talk] Re: User registration (was: PHPGW plugin)

[Seth C. <se...@eu...>]

> > I myself am running a Wiki with a lot of 'discussion' and feeling that
> > Wiki might be the wrong medium for it.  Some users like the ability to
> > edit, some don't. But it's haphazard and not very 'clean' to read.  A
> > good discussion board would probably replace those sections of the
> > Wiki. leaving the more Wiki aligned pages to grow.
>
> i'd like to see the story as a wiki page where it can slowly be refactored
> and evolve as comments and more information comes in, with weblog style
> comments attached because i think most people are more comfortable
> participating that way.

For an interesting take on  this, look at:
http://www.nbtsc.org/wiki/NBTSWikiWiki

Simply put, it's a wiki that has a comment attachment section at the bottom
of each
page.  So either you can edit the page AND/OR put a static comment at the
bottom.
I'm not sure I like this or not, but it's interesting.

I looked at Twiki, what with the new plugin API and all, and it's got some
features
I think are neat.  I think if possible, Standardizing a plugin api would be
a good
thing.  Jeff?  Have you looked at Twiki's plugins?  If so, what is good and
bad about them?

Someone should do a feature list of the various wiki clones and make a
Wikipage for it.
Or is there one?