RE: [Phpwebsite-developers] Comment View

[<re...@ki...>]

=20

> -----Urspr=FCngliche Nachricht-----
> Von: php...@li...=20
> [mailto:php...@li...] Im=20
> Auftrag von php...@li...
> Gesendet: Dienstag, 03. Mai 2005 05:18
> An: php...@li...
> Betreff: Phpwebsite-developers digest, Vol 1 #808 - 2 msgs
>=20
> > Anyway, I wanted to check with the devs before taking this=20
> mindset 100%
> > (I'm at 98% so far).
>=20
> Flat is fine with me, and that is all that really matters.

Just to be sure I understood that: Matt is rewriting the comment module =
and
wants to remove all views but the flat one? To be honest, I don't like =
the
idea to only have flat in later revisions of the comment module.=20

In fact, for me it's the other way round: I love the threaded / nested =
view
and would also want it in the phpwsbb module. The reason is pretty =
simple:
Laziness. People don't use quotes but the hierarchy of comments to =
outline
dependencies

Take for example the Visitors article
<http://www.kiesler.at/article148.html> or the Typo3 article
<http://www.kiesler.at/article174.html>.

If you remove the nesting here, you don't have any chance of following =
the
discussions. Please keep also in mind, that one can change post-titles, =
so
they wouldn't help either even if people only use to reply to the newest
posts. That's why I usually prefer "threaded" views and "threaded"
newsclients.


see also
http://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=3Ddetail&aid=3D1166323&group_id=3D15=
539&atid=3D
365539


regards,

Ren=E9 C. Kiesler!