Menu

Privacy without event dates

2009-02-12
2013-05-30
  • Wes Groleau

    Wes Groleau - 2009-02-12

    How does PGV check privacy if there are no BIRT/DEAT records?

    Looks like it does the right thing in at least one case.

    I created an INDI from a tax list.  So the only event/attribute I could add was RESI.  Of course, that implies birth some time earlier than that, but I did not explicitly list BIRT.

    I was surprised to see that I could get to the record while logged out.  Which is good, but I was expecting it to be private.

     
    • Stew Stronski

      Stew Stronski - 2009-02-12

      I'm not entirely sure of the calculations used but I think it boils down to making an estimate of the DoB and then adding the number of years you have set in the config for assuming death.

      I haven't really gone into it to check but I think if the indi has a child with a birth date then it gives an estimate for the parent of 30 years earlier. And I suppose the reverse may be true also.

       
      • Greg Roach

        Greg Roach - 2009-02-12

        IIRC;

        privacy calcs assume the earliest/latest possible age.

        estimated dates on lists try to give a realistic estimate, based on usual ages to get married, have children, etc.

         
    • Greg Roach

      Greg Roach - 2009-02-12

      Wes, you didn't say, but I presume you've entered a RESI with a date > MAX_AGE years ago.  Hence the person is alive.  If there is no birth, then death is worked out based on the oldest event + MAX AGE.

       
      • Wes Groleau

        Wes Groleau - 2009-02-13

        I think you mean "hence the person is not alive."

        Yes.  If Joe lives in OurTown in 1865, then clearly he was born before 1865.

        I was gratified to see that the estimating occurred, but it would not have surprised me if they did not.

        A lot of other programs are not that smart.  :-)

         
    • Stew Stronski

      Stew Stronski - 2009-02-13

      <<A lot of other programs are not that smart. :-) >>

      I haven't used it extensively to know for sure but It seems that TNG just goes by a user setting if there is no DoB. I decided to set it to "living" because I have quite a few indis that are living, or I'm just not sure of, where I don't know the DoB. So you have to make sure DEAT Y is set for others. Kind of an unsatisfactory way to do it.

       

Log in to post a comment.

Want the latest updates on software, tech news, and AI?
Get latest updates about software, tech news, and AI from SourceForge directly in your inbox once a month.