From: Andrej N. G. <an...@re...> - 2012-10-05 20:00:35
|
Hello! There is a bug #3568358 in our bug tracker. The bug is about some behavior - when you double-click (or left-click in single-click mode) on any column other than name in Detailed List View mode then nothing will happen. Only FM which has similar behavior is Dolphin. Both Thunar and Nautilus activate the file/directory by double-clicking on any column of view. The same does ROX, and Xfe. That is a global incostistency but I'm not sure if we should follow the Dolphin or all others path. Hence if I have to do what is requested in that ticket or close it with "Won't fix". What everyone of you think? Andriy. |
From: <v_...@uk...> - 2012-10-06 09:33:47
|
Hello! On Fri, 5 Oct 2012 23:00:26 +0300 "Andrej N. Gritsenko" <an...@re...> wrote: > Hello! > > There is a bug #3568358 in our bug tracker. The bug is about some > behavior - when you double-click (or left-click in single-click mode) > on any column other than name in Detailed List View mode then nothing > will happen. Only FM which has similar behavior is Dolphin. Both > Thunar and Nautilus activate the file/directory by double-clicking on > any column of view. The same does ROX, and Xfe. That is a global > incostistency but I'm not sure if we should follow the Dolphin or all > others path. Hence if I have to do what is requested in that ticket > or close it with "Won't fix". What everyone of you think? > Opening the directory or file by double-clicking on its line seems more intuitively clear to me rather than just doing nothing. Doing nothing would not definitely cause any harm, but it might be not the kind of action the user expects. At least, not the kind of action that I would expect from double-clicking the file's or catalog's line in a file manager. Regards, Vladimir ----- <v_...@uk...> |
From: Martin B. / b. <br...@bs...> - 2012-10-08 12:45:37
|
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 On 2012-10-05 22:00, Andrej N. Gritsenko wrote: > There is a bug #3568358 in our bug tracker. The bug is about some > behavior - when you double-click (or left-click in single-click > mode) on any column other than name in Detailed List View mode then > nothing will happen. Only FM which has similar behavior is Dolphin. > Both Thunar and Nautilus activate the file/directory by > double-clicking on any column of view. The same does ROX, and Xfe. > That is a global incostistency but I'm not sure if we should follow > the Dolphin or all others path. Hence if I have to do what is > requested in that ticket or close it with "Won't fix". What > everyone of you think? Not doing anything for the columns other than "name" is a regression since 0.9.x series - if I understand this correct. This might be by design and wish, certainly not my wish. And I am an old Dolphin dude =) - -- brother http://sis.bthstudent.se -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.12 (GNU/Linux) Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/ iQEcBAEBCAAGBQJQcsriAAoJEJbdSEaj0jV72/wH/iJMGGVvDCTN9r6+ylDJDKi2 I9mf4acb3pFq5LEjIqFdcrQZ8UwdPOtLgRbMziE9yINhAlzgcCnSrGWVw7BEiU1w MsMRtNFH2oTXg+svX4pW+2JHKhju+gtVy+oAoF7cdDA0Mm9ZOL8+/vX+VPGh36Lp I6hzKTKU+Vc7dXs5jvXvi0q4ZZKGgkpkGx+IZzUJXcaUB29KfwX3RNvPW2SeJ20Q 3+P/s8NS82pLUFR/1OYWzbWhs42zk2bVtNckoltTTnvWZHnAI5W9jXPsLNE/WOP9 7fjIrwUcRU0JtkC87fkssJQYctHHrhZsFUakYA/b24EU1Sq8px3SBMQN2BfbFNA= =Ya2U -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- |
From: Andrej N. G. <an...@re...> - 2012-10-08 13:04:04
|
Hello! Martin Bagge / brother has written on Monday, 8 October, at 14:45: >On 2012-10-05 22:00, Andrej N. Gritsenko wrote: >> There is a bug #3568358 in our bug tracker. The bug is about some >> behavior - when you double-click (or left-click in single-click >> mode) on any column other than name in Detailed List View mode then >> nothing will happen. Only FM which has similar behavior is Dolphin. >> Both Thunar and Nautilus activate the file/directory by >> double-clicking on any column of view. The same does ROX, and Xfe. >> That is a global incostistency but I'm not sure if we should follow >> the Dolphin or all others path. Hence if I have to do what is >> requested in that ticket or close it with "Won't fix". What >> everyone of you think? > >Not doing anything for the columns other than "name" is a regression >since 0.9.x series - if I understand this correct. It was since very start, it's not a regression, see below. :) >This might be by design and wish, certainly not my wish. And I am an >old Dolphin dude =) Yes, that was done by design and wish: commit 012d2bb2487997f3bcfac820246ece5c4ad3982f Author: Hong Jen Yee (PCMan) <pcm...@gm...> Date: Sun Jan 3 16:36:49 2010 +0800 * Handles single click. * Update icons when desired icon sizes are changed. * Disable single click by default. [.......] @@ -339,6 +366,8 @@ void fm_folder_view_set_mode(FmFolderView* fv, FmFolderViewMode mode) gtk_tree_view_column_set_sizing(col, GTK_TREE_VIEW_COLUMN_FIXED); gtk_tree_view_column_set_fixed_width(col, 200); gtk_tree_view_append_column((GtkTreeView*)fv->view, col); + /* only this column is activable */ + exo_tree_view_set_activable_column((ExoTreeView*)fv->view, col); render = gtk_cell_renderer_text_new(); col = gtk_tree_view_column_new_with_attributes(_("Description"), render, "text", COL_FILE_DESC, NULL); But since there is a bug report I want to make sure if we all still want this behavior. WBR, Andriy. |
From: Martin B. / b. <br...@bs...> - 2012-10-08 13:12:53
|
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 On 2012-10-08 15:03, Andrej N. Gritsenko wrote: > It was since very start, it's not a regression, see below. :) To me and the reporter it is a regression. > Yes, that was done by design and wish: Ok. I have no further comments then. I won't oppose any direction of this design. - -- brother http://sis.bthstudent.se -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.12 (GNU/Linux) Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/ iQEcBAEBCAAGBQJQctFGAAoJEJbdSEaj0jV76gIH/i3McOPEdb5LMMAL26Xc40l0 nKxcfSnDRjB5zX5Arl29+Z7qxg35x0LHTrljE9Zo3CdujVhXV/CGFxHdYkj080MZ u6c9IaFWQS50OD4dQ7VkFHkSC3LB2vOdz9zve91FxBp+fFTNpD4a+MTrYDegSfMx pofIb2sOcUNgbxgJsgaqoqIXOpKMxO/TBABmdP+WD4Il+lTC1okld1MnT21HOKaL 1qFbFc/7gemh0Hip/1EOsJHe25rP8y52AVp7GaUbmPQP09zKz2TCpfW1fsybW4O6 1g2oTJ3YVBkvHy0kzmFTj7l6FKeS59aQkleusz/5RsmNA8F/5iZ/rsUrFhw6yuM= =pW55 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- |