Menu ▾ ▴

#1640 Newer release can reduce unlock difficulty of older database

Next release
open
nobody
None
Medium
20 hours ago
20 hours ago
Larry Ellis
No

Observed Behavior

Possibly since version 3.71, opening an older database can inadvertently cause the Unlock Difficulty setting for the database to be reduced.

Example workflow:

  1. Open a 3.68 database which has an Unlock Difficulty setting of 1 (541,200 iterations).
  2. Open the Settings Menu and then the Security tab.
  3. the difficulty slider now shows 0, because the slider increment has changed from 521,200 to 1,082,401.
  4. If the user clicks OK, the unlock difficulty of the database is changed from 541,200 to 327,680, even if neither the slider or any other setting has been touched

The database is updated for the new setting with out warning or advice to the user.

Expected Behavior
The unlock difficulty should not be reduced without clear intent by the user. It could also be argued that the difficulty should not be increased without the intent of the user. My personal opinion is that the unlock difficulty should not be changed unless the user moves the slider. There is the thorny problem that newer slider increments differ from those of older versions, but to silently reduce the unlock difficulty setting without clear user intent is unacceptable in any case.

Discussion


Log in to post a comment.