opensync-users

[Opensync-users] P990 and syncml-obex-client

[Neil S. <ope...@mo...>]

Hi all,

Is syncml-obex-client supposed to work on the P990 yet?

I know you guys are working on other syncml tools but I haven't heard syn=
cml-obex-client mentioned.

I have libsyncml from svn - revision 202, openobex 1.3 and wbxml2-0.9.2.
I can't get the patch H=E5vard Wigtil sent to the devel list last week to=
 apply - has svn moved on since that patch was generated? Does that patch=
 affect syncml-obex-client or just syncml-http-server?


I'd like to add my encouragement and thanks to your UIQ3 efforts, I'm hap=
py to help if possible. (my C is very rusty and I know nothing of opensyn=
c/syncml, but I can test and try things out if it would be useful)


Also, which channel should I be connecting to on the P990? The only servi=
ce that says 'serial port' is this one:
Service Name: m-Router Connectivity
Service Class ID List:
  "Serial Port" (0x1101)
Protocol Descriptor List:
  "L2CAP" (0x0100)
  "RFCOMM" (0x0003)
    Channel: 2



See below for the section of the tracelog where I believe the error start=
s - I can send more if that would be helpful.


Cheers
Neil


syncml-obex-client -b <bluetooth address> 2 --wbxml --identifier "PC Suit=
e" --sync vcard Contacts

>>>>>>>  smlThreadStartCallback(0x60a3c0)
	+++++++++ This is the worker thread of thread 0x60a3c0 for context 0x609=
4c0 +++++++++
	>>>>>>>  smlTransportWorkerHandler(0x60c1a0, 0x6089c0)
		>>>>>>>  smlTransportObexClientConnect(0x60a3f0)
			connecting to bluetooth device 00:12:EE:B6:E2:B4 channel 2
			bluetooth connect done
			>>>>>>>  _smlObexEvent(0x60a4e0, 0x60d990, 0, 4, 0, 0)
				Link Error: 0
				>>>>>>>  smlTransportReceiveEvent(0x6089c0, (nil), 2, (nil), 0x60d8f0=
)
					>>>>>>>  _smlManagerDataHandler(0x6089c0, (nil), 2, (nil), 0x60d8f0,=
 0x609430)
						>>>>>>>  _smlManagerSendEvent(0x609430, 2, (nil), (nil), (nil), 0x6=
0d910)
						<<<<<<<  _smlManagerSendEvent
					<--- ERROR --- _smlManagerDataHandler: Link Error
				<<<<<<<  smlTransportReceiveEvent: 0
			<--- ERROR --- _smlObexEvent: Link Error
			>>>>>>>  smlTransportReceiveEvent(0x6089c0, (nil), 2, (nil), 0x60d8f0)
				>>>>>>>  _smlManagerDataHandler(0x6089c0, (nil), 2, (nil), 0x60d8f0, =
0x609430)
					>>>>>>>  _smlManagerSendEvent(0x609430, 2, (nil), (nil), (nil), 0x60=
dae0)
					<<<<<<<  _smlManagerSendEvent
				<--- ERROR --- _smlManagerDataHandler: Unable to get answer
			<<<<<<<  smlTransportReceiveEvent: 0
		<--- ERROR --- smlTransportObexClientConnect: Unable to get answer

Re: [Opensync-users] P990 and syncml-obex-client

[W. <ha...@pv...>]

lør, 14,.10.2006 kl. 17.24 +0100, skrev Neil Sedger:

> Hi all,
> 
> Is syncml-obex-client supposed to work on the P990 yet?


Are you sure that the P990 has support for syncing over OBEX? I haven't
seen anything about it, and I think that the bluetooth syncing on
Windows uses the Symbian specific mRouter transport protocol for
syncing. And isn't phones that support SyncML over OBEX supposed to show
this as a service when using e.g. "sdptool browse"?


> 
> I know you guys are working on other syncml tools but I haven't heard syncml-obex-client mentioned.
> 
> I have libsyncml from svn - revision 202, openobex 1.3 and wbxml2-0.9.2.
> I can't get the patch Håvard Wigtil sent to the devel list last week to apply - has svn moved on since that patch was generated? Does that patch affect syncml-obex-client or just syncml-http-server?


I think that my patches should work with both http and OBEX, but as I
said above I don't think the P990 works with OBEX.
I updated my copy of the Subversion repository just now without getting
any conflicts, so I don't think the repository has changed
significantly. What sort of errors did you get?

That being said, my patches doesn't do anything useful yet, as there is
an unresolved problem when starting a real sync (as opposed to testing
with synml-http-server), see
http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/forum.php?thread_id=30684964&forum_id=44498


> 
> 
> I'd like to add my encouragement and thanks to your UIQ3 efforts, I'm happy to help if possible. (my C is very rusty and I know nothing of opensync/syncml, but I can test and try things out if it would be useful)


Thanks. Unfortunately there is not much to test yet, apart from
verifying that you get the same errors as I get.
But my C is also very rusty, and I know (almost) nothing of libsyncml /
opensync internals, so please just give it a try if you have the time to
spare. ;-)

  Håvard

--
Håvard Wigtil || http://wigtil.net

Re: [Opensync-users] P990 and syncml-obex-client

[Neil S. <ope...@mo...>]

H=C3=A5vard Wigtil wrote:
> l=C3=B8r, 14,.10.2006 kl. 17.24 +0100, skrev Neil Sedger:
>
>> Is syncml-obex-client supposed to work on the P990 yet?
>=20
> Are you sure that the P990 has support for syncing over OBEX?

Erm, no :-)

This just proves that I know even less than I thought! :-/


> I updated my copy of the Subversion repository just now without getting=
=20
> any conflicts, so I don't think the repository has changed=20
> significantly. What sort of errors did you get?

I got some hunk errors... but I aquired your patch by copy & paste from t=
he mailinglist archives on the web, so its very possible that it lost som=
e integrity at some point.

If my feedback (which you noted can only be that right now I get the same=
 errors as you!) would be useful then please send me the patch off-list a=
nd I'll apply and test.
Otherwise I'll keep an eye on the opensync-users and opensync-devel lists=
 and try again when I can give some useful feedback.


Thanks
Neil

Re: [Opensync-users] P990 and syncml-obex-client

[W. <ha...@pv...>]

tir, 17,.10.2006 kl. 20.18 +0100, skrev Neil Sedger:

> Håvard Wigtil wrote:
> > lør, 14,.10.2006 kl. 17.24 +0100, skrev Neil Sedger:
> >
> >> Is syncml-obex-client supposed to work on the P990 yet?
> > 
> > Are you sure that the P990 has support for syncing over OBEX?
> 
> Erm, no :-)
> 
> This just proves that I know even less than I thought! :-/

Note that I don't know for certain that P900 doesn't support SyncML over
OBEX, I don't know very much about OBEX support myself.

> 
> > I updated my copy of the Subversion repository just now without getting 
> > any conflicts, so I don't think the repository has changed 
> > significantly. What sort of errors did you get?
> 
> I got some hunk errors... but I aquired your patch by copy & paste from the mailinglist archives on the web, so its very possible that it lost some integrity at some point.
> 
> If my feedback (which you noted can only be that right now I get the same errors as you!) would be useful then please send me the patch off-list and I'll apply and test.
> Otherwise I'll keep an eye on the opensync-users and opensync-devel lists and try again when I can give some useful feedback.


I'll write a mail to the users list if there should be anything that
would be useful to test, or if I get something that has a small chance
of working. :-)

--
Håvard Wigtil || http://wigtil.net

Re: [Opensync-users] P990 and syncml-obex-client

[Stian J. <li...@jo...>]

On tir, 2006-10-17 at 21:57 +0200, H=C3=A5vard Wigtil wrote:
> > This just proves that I know even less than I thought! :-/
> Note that I don't know for certain that P900 doesn't support SyncML
> over OBEX, I don't know very much about OBEX support myself.=20

I don't know much about OBEX neither, but I have tried and failed. It
does not seem like P990 supports neither OBEX over Bluetooth nor USB.
Unfortunately :(

-Stian

Re: [Opensync-users] P990 and syncml-obex-client

[Neil S. <ope...@mo...>]

H=C3=A5vard Wigtil wrote:

> Note that I don't know for certain that P900 doesn't support SyncML ove=
r=20
> OBEX, I don't know very much about OBEX support myself.

...it would seem the OSX people arrived at the same point:

http://mobile.feisar.com/uiq3.html


Looks like they're waiting for Apple or SE to write OSX code that talks m=
-router...

Neil