Menu

#42 Improve Figure D.14

Corrigendum
closed
2024-01-23
2018-10-15
Martin
No

I would suggest the following changes:
a) Remove the red highlighted "<<operator>>" as it is only timer driven
b) Add the two green transitions, as otherwise Latched would be a final state
c) Specify the meaning of the blue highlighted transition. Is it related to the "History" of the <<signal activation="">> On state? Latched and On do not make sense, thus only Off and Acknowledged are reasonable states?!?</signal></operator>

1 Attachments

Related

11073-10207 Revision: #57

Discussion

  • Stefan Schlichting

    • assigned_to: David
    • Milestone: Errata --> Corrigenda
     
  • Stefan Schlichting

    From my perspective: The <<operator>> should be included as it can be <<timer>> or <<operator>> driven. Maybe we add just another transition.</operator></timer></operator>

    I think the changes proposed for Latched are ok.

    The blue highlighted transition needs to go to the "Off" state in the box as the condition is not present. I think the transition from "condition is present" to "On" is actually not ok and may be going to either of "On" or "Ack".

     
    • Stefan Schlichting

      Proposed removal of D.6 Alert signal generation

      Maybe include after fixing Table 9 to depict the content of Table 9.

       
  • Stefan Schlichting

    • labels: --> Table 9, D.6, Figure D.14
     
  • Stefan Schlichting

    • status: open --> accepted
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2022-03-25
    • Milestone: Corrigenda --> Revision
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2022-11-21
    • Milestone: Revision Draft 1 --> untriaged
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2023-03-06
    • labels: Table 9, D.6, Figure D.14 --> Table 9, D.6, Figure D.14, AlertSignal
    • assigned_to: David --> nobody
    • Milestone: untriaged --> Corrigendum
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2023-03-06

    Consider removing annex section D.6 in Corrigenda, then improve/reintroduce in Revision or APKP.

     

    Last edit: Björn Andersen 2024-01-15
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2024-01-15
    • status: accepted --> solved
    • assigned_to: Björn Andersen
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2024-01-15

    Removal does not alter scope.

     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2024-01-19
    • status: solved --> in-progress
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2024-01-19

    Solved in 943435b.

     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2024-01-23
    • status: in-progress --> closed
     

Log in to post a comment.