Menu

#100 Add further explanations to InvocationRequested and InvocationRequired

Revision
needs-review
nobody
2024-04-22
2019-08-05
Martin
No

Add notes to the element descriptions what it means to be "required"/"requested" to be invoked? Does the POC MEDICAL DEVICE not work as long as all required operations have been invoked? What does "requested" means? Maybe it is requested to perform a white balancing at a camera system?

Related

11073-10207 Revision: #354

Discussion

  • David

    David - 2021-01-18
    • status: open --> accepted
    • assigned_to: David
     
  • David

    David - 2021-01-18

    Add notes:
    - Required: the intended function of the device/module cannot be executed until the corresponding operations are invoked
    - Requested: the intended function of the device/module can be executed but an it is recommended to invoke the corresponding operations

     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2022-03-25
    • Milestone: Corrigenda --> Revision
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2022-11-21
    • Milestone: Revision Draft 1 --> untriaged
     
  • David

    David - 2023-03-20
    • Milestone: untriaged --> Corrigendum
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2024-02-05
    • status: accepted --> open
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2024-02-05
    • labels: --> B.360, B.361
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2024-03-11
    • status: open --> needs-review
    • assigned_to: David --> Martin
     
  • Björn Andersen

    Björn Andersen - 2024-03-11

    Consensus: Doesn't make sense in a SOA/SODA/SOMDA. Consider forbidding the use of these attributes entirely.

    @codimon: Check as to whether this is used in an actual implementation.
    @martinuro: Are You happy with scrapping these?

    Otherwise we would have to come up with an actual meaning, which is going to prove hard...

     
    • Björn Andersen

      Björn Andersen - 2024-03-25

      Dräger does not use these attributes.

       
  • Martin

    Martin - 2024-04-22
    • assigned_to: Martin --> nobody
    • Milestone: Corrigendum --> Revision
     
  • Martin

    Martin - 2024-04-22

    [tCon 22.04.2024]

    We discussed some use cases, e.g., calibration of headless providers or required to set a patient weight for therapy purposes.
    Heterogeneous opinions regarding scrapping or improving. Fear of forbidding something that is later needed, especially, because the xC-PKP is not yet ready.
    Decision: Postpone this topic.

     

Log in to post a comment.