openlilylib-user

[oll-user] [Challenges] New challenge

[Urs L. <ul...@op...>]

I've put up a new challenge:
https://github.com/openlilylib/engraving-challenges/blob/2-schumann-challenge/challenge02-schumann/README.md

I did *not* want to make it even simpler because I think this is a score 
that should be feasible by any program without posing esoteric problems.

I hope everyone is fine with that.

And of course everybody can also start/continue with the other one too.

Best
Urs

Re: [oll-user] [Challenges] New challenge

[Marc S. <ma...@ou...>]

Better.  I personally would still have preferred something without 
incomplete voices or mixed voices on a single stem - both decidedly 
"special" cases even if not that uncommon in Romantic era piano music.  
Those two features of this piece will surely dominate this challenge and 
I'd rather have had one that was truly just about the basics.  But it's 
not my project, and I appreciate the effort in finding a more suitable 
choice.

Marc

Re: [oll-user] [Challenges] New challenge

[Phil H. <ma...@ph...>]

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Urs Liska" <ul...@op...>
To: "oll-user" <ope...@li...>
Sent: Friday, January 10, 2014 4:39 PM
Subject: [oll-user] [Challenges] New challenge


> I've put up a new challenge:
> https://github.com/openlilylib/engraving-challenges/blob/2-schumann-challenge/challenge02-schumann/README.md
>
> I did *not* want to make it even simpler because I think this is a score
> that should be feasible by any program without posing esoteric problems.
>
> I hope everyone is fine with that.
>
> And of course everybody can also start/continue with the other one too.
>
> Best
> Urs

I would like to see a vocal challenge: something like solo voice with piano. 
I've seen a lot of very bad attempts using Sibelius.

If you're not aware of what's available, Songs of Travel by Vaughan Williams 
would provide some possible.

--
Phil Holmes 

Re: [oll-user] [Challenges] New challenge

[Janek W. <lem...@gm...>]

2014/1/10 Urs Liska <ul...@op...>

> I've put up a new challenge:
>
> https://github.com/openlilylib/engraving-challenges/blob/2-schumann-challenge/challenge02-schumann/README.md
>

Looks nice.
Should you perhaps move the master branch to include appropriate commit?

2014/1/10 Phil Holmes <ma...@ph...>

> I would like to see a vocal challenge: something like solo voice with
> piano.
>

+1, and also maybe single-staff solo instrument.
And maybe SATB choir.  that should cover a wide range of engraving issues.

Janek
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...

Re: [oll-user] [Challenges] New challenge

[Urs L. <ul...@op...>]

Am 10.01.2014 20:25, schrieb Janek Warchoł:
> 2014/1/10 Urs Liska <ul...@op...>
>
>> I've put up a new challenge:
>>
>> https://github.com/openlilylib/engraving-challenges/blob/2-schumann-challenge/challenge02-schumann/README.md
>>
>
> Looks nice.
> Should you perhaps move the master branch to include appropriate commit?
>
> 2014/1/10 Phil Holmes <ma...@ph...>
>
>> I would like to see a vocal challenge: something like solo voice with
>> piano.
>>
>
> +1, and also maybe single-staff solo instrument.
> And maybe SATB choir.  that should cover a wide range of engraving issues.
>
> Janek
>

Of course we're going to extend this, but one after another.

voice/piano is of course my favourite combination, this actually makes 
the biggest portion of my physical scores. The songs of Vaughan Williams 
are very nice, but of course copyright.
One candidate with very complex songs would be Alban Berg. But there 
would be interesteing ones with Liszt for example.

Urs

-- 
Urs Liska
www.openlilylib.org