Re: [oll-user] schumann questions

[Janek W. <lem...@gm...>]

2014/1/11 Urs Liska <ul...@op...>

> Am Freitag, den 10.01.2014, 15:57 -0700 schrieb Marc Sabatella:
> > Really these are kind of general, but I am for now interesting in the
> > answer for the Schumann in particular.
> >
> > 1) To what extent are we trying to copy the exact layout?  Where the
> > line breaks occur, how the slurs attach, etc?  I could see arguments for
> > trying to copy exactly but also for using our own editorial judgement
> > (which would be influenced for most us, no doubt, by the defaults of our
> > chosen software).
>
> No, we're not trying to copy the model exactly.
> We're trying to make the best possible edition of the piece.
> (Of course for our purpose we're not interested in scholarly review or
> stuff like that).
> Being influenced by the default of the capabilities of the software
> isn't bad, not even in our context ;-)
>

However, using the same line breaks would make comparing versions from
different programs easier.

j
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...