Re: [OctDev] Implementation of importdata belonging to Octave Core or Octave-Forge?

[Jordi G. H. <jo...@oc...>]

On 19 October 2012 09:37, Juan Pablo Carbajal <aju...@gm...> wrote:
> On Tue, Oct 16, 2012 at 9:04 PM, Erik Kjellson
> <eri...@us...> wrote:
>> Hello,
>>
>> I have written an implementation of the Matlab function 'importdata'. I'm
>> getting a bit confused about the borderline between Octave Core and
>> Octave-Forge, so I don't know where it belongs...
>>
>> My implementation covers most of the functionality in the Matlab version,
>> but not all. For example, I haven't implemented the automatic detection of
>> the column separator. Also, for some special cases (like if you in the data
>> section of the file would have some letters among numeric data) you still
>> get a slightly different output.
>>
>> The 'importdata' is, as far as I know, a part of Matlab Core rather than a
>> toolbox.
>> Does the implementation have to be complete to be able to have it in Octave
>> Core?
>>
>> Or is it better to add it to the Octave-Forge project for now?
>>
>> regards,
>> Erik
>
> Hi Erik,
>
> Cool!
>
> I would say that if compatibility is not complete then better to keep
> it in Forge.

Nah, we have tons of incomplete compatibility functions in core. One
more will do no harm. It should go in core.

> also, you should upload your function seomwhere so we can
> see the coding style, Octave core is very strict in this.

This is a minor thing. I can adapt its style as necessary.

- Jordi G. H.