#12 bone tissue vs bone

closed-fixed
None
1
2012-10-23
2012-08-29
No

After the skeletal meeting the VSAO followed FMA, Uberon and others in distinguishing bone from bone tissue. The recommendation is that AOs are consistent with this (though they need not implement the full scheme)

XAO has:

......po XAO:0000169 ! bone tissue *** [SYNONYM: "bone" (related)]
.......is_a XAO:0000214 ! auditory ossicle
.......is_a XAO:0003080 ! urostyle
.......is_a XAO:0003207 ! carpus
.......is_a XAO:0003208 ! metacarpus
.......is_a XAO:0003211 ! tarsus
.......is_a XAO:0003212 ! metatarsus
.......is_a XAO:0004035 ! osteoid
........df XAO:0004040 ! mineralized bone tissue
.........is_a XAO:0004195 ! cellular bone tissue
.......is_a XAO:0004040 ! mineralized bone tissue
........is_a XAO:0004195 ! cellular bone tissue

Most of these are bone elements, rather than tissue types per se. The only tissue type is cellular bone tissue which is_a AND df mineralized (the is_a is in VSAO, the df is not).

Discussion

  • Erik Segerdell

    Erik Segerdell - 2012-09-18
    • assigned_to: nobody --> seger
    • status: open --> pending-accepted
     
  • Erik Segerdell

    Erik Segerdell - 2012-10-23
    • status: pending-accepted --> closed-fixed
     
  • Erik Segerdell

    Erik Segerdell - 2012-10-23

    Fixed in new XAO version on OBO Foundry 23 Oct 2012.

     

Log in to post a comment.