Re: [Numpy-discussion] how to use argsort result?

[Travis O. <oli...@ie...>]

Pau Gargallo wrote:
> On 7/12/06, Victoria G. Laidler <la...@st...> wrote:
>   
>> Hi,
>>
>> Pardon me if I'm reprising an earlier discussion, as I'm new to the list.
>>
>> But is there a reason that this obscure syntax
>>
>> A[arange(2)[:,newaxis],indexes]
>>
>> A[arange(A.shape[0])[:,newaxis],indexes]
>>
>> is preferable to the intuitively reasonable thing that the Original
>> Poster did?
>>
>> A[indexes]
>>
>>     
>
> i don't think so.
> The obscure syntax is just a way you can solve the problem with the
> current state of NumPy. Of course, a more clearer syntax would be
> better, but for this, something in NumPy should be changed.
>
> This other syntax is longer but clearer:
>   ind = indices(A.shape)
>   ind[ax] = A.argsort(axis=ax)
>   A[ind]
>
> Which brings me to the question:
>
> Would it be reasonable if argsort returned the complete tuple of
> indices, so that
> A[A.argsort(ax)] would work ?
>
>   
I think this is reasonable.  We would need a way for the argsort() 
function to work as it does now.  I'm not sure if anybody actually uses 
the multidimensional behavior of argsort now, but it's been in Numeric 
for a long time.

-Travis