Menu

#18 Type Coverage Remove button limitation

Beta-2
open
4
2009-04-12
2009-04-12
Anonymous
No

The "Remove" button allows removal of the latest move added only. To go back further, need to use "Reset" button.
Shouldn't the "Remove" button allow for more than 1 removal since the acceptable moves for each Pokemon is 4 ?

Although it will calculate base on a maximum of 4 moves for each Pokemon, you can add as many moves as available to the Pokemon. Shouldn't it set a limit of 4 moves that can be added for any Pokemon ?

It allows for moves belonging to more than 1 Pokemon to be added and calculated so long as it is 4 moves per Pokemon. This means that more than 4 moves can be used for the calculation.
Does it serve its purpose of identifying type that is weak to the move if more than 1 move is used in the calculation ?
The output does not differentiate which type is weak against which move if more than 1 move is added.

Pokefan

Discussion

  • MetalKid007

    MetalKid007 - 2009-04-12
    • milestone: --> Beta-2
    • priority: 5 --> 4
    • assigned_to: nobody --> metalkid007
     
  • MetalKid007

    MetalKid007 - 2009-04-12

    I'm not sure what/how the information should be displayed on this screen.

    I allow you to add as many moves as you want because I only let you add the same Pokemon once. If your team comprises of 2 of the same Pokemon, you need a way to specify all 8 moves.

    I will probably have to refactor this screen in the future since it isn't how I expected it to be.

     
  • Nobody/Anonymous

    For a start, I would suggest that you limit the number of Pokemon to be added to 2 only and number of moves to 4 per Pokemon. Currently, there is no limit.

    Also, it would help if you allow the "Remove" button to remove more tha the latest move added (should be able to remove all the way back to the first move added).

    As alot of info is displayed, you may want to display the type that the move is "Super Effective Against" rather than displaying the different combination which result in alot of duplication of same type even if they are under different combination.

    If more than 1 Pokemon and move is allowed to be added, then the output should show a correlation between Pokemon and its move against the Type effectiveness with the related Pokemons. Each Pokemon and its selected move will be a subsection of the output.

    For your consideration. Pokefan

     
  • MetalKid007

    MetalKid007 - 2009-05-03

    You have to be able to add 6 Pokemon for the "team".

     

Log in to post a comment.

MongoDB Logo MongoDB