Linknx / Discussion / Help: Evaluation error with TimerCondition

chris_14 - 2009-10-22

Hello.

For closing my blinds I use two rules, for presence an not presence:

        <rule id="rollo_runter_1">
            <condition type="and">
                <condition type="timer" trigger="true">
                    <at type="sunset" offset="0"/>
                    <until hour="23" min="59" />
                </condition>
            <condition type="object" id="anwesend" value="false" trigger="true" />
            </condition>
            <actionlist>
                <action type="set-value" id="zentralsteuerung_rollos" value="1" />
            </actionlist>
        </rule>
        <rule id="rollo_runter_2">
            <condition type="and">
                <condition type="timer" trigger="true">
                    <at hour="21" min="45" />
                    <until hour="23" min="59" />
                </condition>
            <condition type="object" id="anwesend" value="true" trigger="true" />
            </condition>
            <actionlist>
                <action type="set-value" id="zentralsteuerung_rollos" value="1" />
            </actionlist>
        </rule>

But every time, I change the object "anwesend" to false (presence = false) the blinds are going down. This seems to be caused by a wrong evaluation of the AND condition (last line):

    2009-10-22 16:17:41 Condition: TimerCondition evaluated as '1'
    2009-10-22 16:17:41 SwitchingObject: SwitchingObject (id=anwesend): Compare value_m='1' to value='0'
    2009-10-22 16:17:41 Condition: ObjectCondition (id='anwesend') evaluated as '0'
    2009-10-22 16:17:41 Condition: TimerCondition evaluated as '0'
    2009-10-22 16:17:41 FilePersistentStorage: Writing 'on' for object 'anwesend'

    2009-10-22 16:18:25 Condition: TimerCondition evaluated as '1'
    2009-10-22 16:18:26 SwitchingObject: SwitchingObject (id=anwesend): Compare value_m='0' to value='0'
    2009-10-22 16:18:26 Condition: ObjectCondition (id='anwesend') evaluated as '1'
    2009-10-22 16:18:26 Condition: TimerCondition evaluated as '0'
    2009-10-22 16:18:26 FilePersistentStorage: Writing 'off' for object 'anwesend'
    2009-10-22 16:18:26 Action: Execute SetValueAction with value on

The configuration looks like this:

    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Rule: Rule: Configuring rollo_runter_1 (active=1)
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 TimeSpec: 1899-0-1 -1:-1:0 (wdays=0; exception=2)
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 TimeSpec: 1899-0-1 23:59:0 (wdays=0; exception=2)
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 SolarTimeSpec: sun_rise_set date 2009-10-22
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 SolarTimeSpec: sun_rise_set returned 18:24
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 SolarTimeSpec: adjustTime date 2009-10-22
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 SolarTimeSpec: adjustTime returned 16:16
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 PeriodicTask: Rescheduled at 2009-10-22 16:16:17 (1256220977)
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Condition: ObjectCondition: configured value_m='off'
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Rule: ActionList: Configuring
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Action: SetValueAction: Configured for object zentralsteuerung_rollos with value on
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Rule: Rule: Configuration done
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Rule: Rule: Configuring rollo_runter_2 (active=1)
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 TimeSpec: 1899-0-1 21:45:0 (wdays=0; exception=2)
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 TimeSpec: 1899-0-1 23:59:0 (wdays=0; exception=2)
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 PeriodicTask: Rescheduled at 2009-10-22 16:16:17 (1256240700)
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Condition: ObjectCondition: configured value_m='on'
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Rule: ActionList: Configuring
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Action: SetValueAction: Configured for object zentralsteuerung_rollos with value on
    2009-10-22 16:16:17 Rule: Rule: Configuration done

For me, it looks like that the evaluation of the TimerCondition with sunset is not correct. Any idea?

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

chris_14 - 2009-10-22

Here are the rules again in readable form (I hope):

    <rule id="rollo_runter_1">
        <condition type="and">
            <condition type="timer" trigger="true">
                <at type="sunset" offset="0"/>
                <until hour="23" min="59" />
            </condition>
        <condition type="object" id="anwesend" value="false" trigger="true" />
        </condition>
        <actionlist>
            <action type="set-value" id="zentralsteuerung_rollos" value="1" />
        </actionlist>
    </rule>
    <rule id="rollo_runter_2">
        <condition type="and">
            <condition type="timer" trigger="true">
                <at hour="21" min="45" />
                <until hour="23" min="59" />
            </condition>
        <condition type="object" id="anwesend" value="true" trigger="true" />
        </condition>
        <actionlist>
            <action type="set-value" id="zentralsteuerung_rollos" value="1" />
        </actionlist>
    </rule>

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

chris_14 - 2009-10-22

Last try:
`<rule id="rollo_runter_1">
    <condition type="and">
        <condition type="timer" trigger="true">
            <at type="sunset" offset="0"/>
            <until hour="23" min="59" />
        </condition>
    <condition type="object" id="anwesend" value="false" trigger="true" />
    </condition>
    <actionlist>
        <action type="set-value" id="zentralsteuerung_rollos" value="1" />
    </actionlist>
</rule>
<rule id="rollo_runter_2">
    <condition type="and">
        <condition type="timer" trigger="true">
            <at hour="21" min="45" />
            <until hour="23" min="59" />
        </condition>
    <condition type="object" id="anwesend" value="true" trigger="true" />
    </condition>
    <actionlist>
        <action type="set-value" id="zentralsteuerung_rollos" value="1" />
    </actionlist>
</rule>`

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Peter - 2009-10-22

Hallo chris_14,

      </condition>
    <condition type="object" id="anwesend" value="false" trigger="true" />
    </condition>

change to

    <condition type="object" id="anwesend" value="false" trigger="true" />
< /condition>
</condition>

my rule:
    <rule id="Souterrain_abwesend_2">
              <condition type="and">
                  <condition type="object" id="KG_abwesend" value="on" />
                   <condition type="timer" trigger="true">
                         <at type='sunset' wdays='1234567' offset="1250" />
                   </condition>
               </condition>
              <actionlist>
                <action type="set-value" id="Rolladen_Souterrain" value="1" />
              </actionlist>
            </rule>

Viele Grüße
Peter

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

jef2000 - 2009-10-25

Hi,

I think you have the same problem as described here:
http://sourceforge.net/projects/linknx/forums/forum/743670/topic/3308230

I suspect that this problem is caused by the logging facility. I discovered some time after I released 0.0.1.26 with improved logging that the date/time functions used in log messages were interfering with date/time functions used in sunrise/sunset or timers. I already fixed it in CVS. If you want to be sure that you see the same problem, you can add <loggging format="simple"/> to your config file (inside the <config> element, at the same level as <rules>, <objects> and <sevices>). This will remove the timestamps from log messages and perhaps solve your problem.

Regards,

Jean-François

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Evaluation error with TimerCondition

Forums

Help

Evaluation error with TimerCondition document.SUBSCRIPTION_OPTIONS = { "thing": "topic", "subscribed": false, "url": "subscribe", "icon": { "css": "fa fa-envelope-o" } };

Evaluation error with TimerCondition