[libdb-develop] Re: Movies and FRBR - What Approach?

[Morbus I. <mo...@di...>]

At 05:14 PM 1/12/2004, Morbus Iff wrote:
 >> ECHO:
 >>
 >>   W: 2001: A space odyssey
 >>    E1: The film "2001: A space odyssey" by Stanley Kubrick
 >>     M1: The 35 mm format
 >>     M2: The DVD from Paramount (or wherever).
 >>      I1: The one I own, located in box 17.
 >>
 >> Martha M. Yee:
 >>
 >>  If you look at FRBR itself, the work (W) would be the film 2001: a space
 >>  odyssey; Arthur C. Clarke's original short story (Sentinel) would be a
 >>  related work, as would Clarke's 1999 science fiction novel that came out
 >>  after the film.  An example of an expression of the film might be a DVD
 >>  version with an audio commentary by Kubrick or some such...
 >>
 >> My meandering:
 >>
 >>  W1: 2001: A space odyssey (film)
 >>   E1: 2001: A space odyssey (directed by Stanley Kubrick)
 >>    M1: The DVD from Paramount (or wherever).
 >>     I1: The one I own, located in box 17.

I think I'm going to end up going with my approach:

   W1: Texas chainsaw massacre (film)
    E1: Texas chainsaw massacre (original; directed by Tobe Hooper)
     M1: The VHS from Paramount (or wherever).
     M2: The special edition DVD from Paramount.
    E2: Texas chainsaw massacre (remake; directed by some other guy)
     M1: The DVD from New Line.

   W1: Texas chainsaw massacre (comics)
    E1: Texas chainsaw massacre (written by person).

etc., etc. Any thoughts on this? The one downside, as mentioned previously, 
is the lack of authority for the Work, but I can't think of any immediate 
way that would remove the seeming duplication of the Expression:

   W1: Texas chainsaw massacre (directed by Tobe Hooper)
    E1: Texas chainsaw massacre (directed by Tobe Hooper)
    E2: Texas chainsaw massacre (remake; directed by some other guy)



-- 
Morbus Iff ( i put the demon back in codemonkey )
Culture: http://www.disobey.com/ and http://www.gamegrene.com/
Spidering Hacks: http://amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0596005776/disobeycom
icq: 2927491 / aim: akaMorbus / yahoo: morbus_iff / jabber.org: morbus