#1812 HtmlUnit load only the SRC not the Page after (If Image the Frame-Src, i got a Image) corejs.javascript.EvaluatorExceptio‌​n

[Sebastian Richter]

(please, don't help with ask for a minimal testcase, i don't know what you meen, i only wan't help with a answer to my Problem. Sorry, i don't have access to the javascript of this Onlinebanking Website. I can only give you my login credentials to have a look on the original site.)

I have a Frameset like this:

<frameset id="frameSet_main" border="0" framespacing="0" frameborder="0" cols="*">
    <frameset onload="resize('TL')" id="frameSet1" border="0" framespacing="0" frameborder="0" rows="155,*,20">
      <frame onload="checkFrameValidity_frame_top();" title="top menu frame" marginheight="0" marginwidth="0" scrolling="no" noresize="noresize" src="RRMNU05.html" name="frame_top"/>
      <frameset id="frameSet2" cols="185,*">
        <frame onload="checkFrameValidity_frame_menu();" src="images/loading.gif" title="left menu frame" scrolling="" marginheight="0" marginwidth="0" noresize="true" target="main" name="frame_menu"/>
        <frameset id="setRight" cols="*,3">
          <frameset id="entityframeset" rows="0,*">
            <frame onload="checkFrameValidity_entityframe();" frameborder="0" noresize="true" scrolling="no" marginheight="0" marginwidth="0" id="entityframe" name="entityframe"/>
            <frameset id="dataframe" rows="0,*">
              <frame onload="checkFrameValidity_messageFrame();" frameborder="0" noresize="true" scrolling="no" marginheight="0" marginwidth="0" name="messageFrame" src="display_message.htm"/>
              <frame onload="checkFrameValidity_frame_txn();addFocus ();" border="0" marginheight="0" marginwidth="0" scrolling="auto" src="images/loading.gif" name="frame_txn"/>
            </frameset>
          </frameset>
        </frameset>
      </frameset>
      <frame onload="checkFrameValidity_footerframe();" src="footer.htm" name="frame_footer" scrolling="no" marginwidth="0" marginheight="0" border="0" noresize="true" title="footer frame"/>
    </frameset>
    <span id="VBar" style="position: absolute; top: 0px; left: 0px; height: 0px; width: 2px; background: silver; border-left: 1px dotted black; display: none;">
    </span>
  </frameset>

When i want to get the Content of Frame "messageFrame", all is fine and i get the HTML-Code, because the src-Attribute from this Frame is:

src="display_message.htm"

The Problem is, i want the Page from the Frame "frame_txn" and every Time i get only the Image from the src-Attribute from this Frame:

src="images/loading.gif"

as a UnexceptedPage ...

All Tests with the Workarounds that i know are not working, like:

WebClient syncWebClient = new WebClient(BrowserVersion.CHROME);
syncWebClient.getOptions().setJavaScriptEnabled(true);
syncWebClient.setAjaxController(new NicelyResynchronizingAjaxController());
syncWebClient.waitForBackgroundJavaScriptStartingBefore(10000);
syncWebClient.waitForBackgroundJavaScript(50000);

.....
The Frame with the "html-Src" is working with this Code after Page-GET:

FrameWindow frameTXN = pageContent.getFrameByName("messageFrame");
Page frameTXNpage = frameTXN.getEnclosedPage();
System.out.println("frameTXNpage: " + frameTXNpage);
System.out.println("frameTXNpageXML:\n" + ((HtmlPage) frameTXNpage).asXml());

This Code for the Frame with the "Image-Src" brings every Time only the Image as UnexceptedPage on this Code:

FrameWindow frameTXN = pageContent.getFrameByName("frame_txn");
Page frameTXNpage = frameTXN.getEnclosedPage();
System.out.println("frameTXNpage: " + frameTXNpage);
System.out.println("frameTXNpageXML:\n" + ((HtmlPage)     frameTXNpage).asXml());

Please, every body help me ...
Or is this a big Bug in HTMLUnit?

i think this is my problem too: stackoverflow.com/questions/20315330/… then htmlunit is to hard to the bad javascript-code from bank of scotland, because i get many exceptions like this befor the main page is loading

Enclosed exception: 
net.sourceforge.htmlunit.corejs.javascript.EvaluatorException: No node attached to this object (script in banking.bankofscotland.de/netbankingde/internet from (1, 598) to (1762, 10)#1700)

In normal browser is the page working, because is more flexible then hmtlunit that can't parse a page like this ...

Greats

[RBRi]

Hi Sebastian

(please, don't help with ask for a minimal testcase, i don't know what you meen, i only wan't help with a answer to my Problem. Sorry, i don't have access to the javascript of this Onlinebanking Website. I can only give you my login credentials to have a look on the original site.)

There is some description for bug reports.
* http://htmlunit.sourceforge.net/submittingBugs.html
* http://htmlunit.sourceforge.net/submittingJSBugs.html

Outside of this i'm not sure, what your expectations for open source projects are. If you have a look at OpenHUB (https://www.openhub.net/p/HtmlUnit/estimated_cost) you might notice that you get source code for $ 4,640,616 for free (this does not include the used libraries). This model only works, iff all the users are donating back some time/effort to the project. Usualy they have to spend some quality time with debugging there problem down to the root cause to give us a chance to fix this. Thats more or less the way this kind of projects are working.

Regarding your problem:
Can you please send your code (without credentials - luckily i have an accont for this bank also ;-) and i will try to reproduce your problem. But to not expect a quick solution because there is far too much work on my desk.
If you need get faster help you can try to buy support (http://htmlunit.sourceforge.net/professionalSupport.html).

Hopes that helps a bit for the moment, cross your fingers the BoS page seems to be a real monster....

[RBRi]

Hi Sebastian,

have done my usual simple test; have written a Wetator test that tries to login to the BoS page. The tests works fine (with the latest HtmlUnit code) and i was able to reach the page 'Sicherheitsfrage'.
Of course i got some js errors. Do you face your problem before or after this page?
If you like we can continue this discussion by private mail (and maybe in german).

[Sebastian Richter]

Hi,
yes is right. The Login and the Security Question+Answer (Sicherheits- Frage+Antwort) are working perfect ...

The Problem is the "frame_txn" from the Mainpage "after" the Login is done ...

I want to get the Content of this Frame:
<frame onload="checkFrameValidity_frame_txn();addFocus ();" border="0" marginheight="0" marginwidth="0" scrolling="auto" src="images/loading.gif" name="frame_txn"/>
after the Login.
That is all what i say at all time.
The Frame bevor with the src="display_message.htm" working perfect.

This is my private Mail.German is my language ;)

[RBRi]

Please send me a mail from you private account to my one.

[Sebastian Richter]

is here any new info? on Version 2.24 the problem still exist ... :(

[RBRi]

Sorry but i found no time to work on that. And i fear it will be the same for the next weeks....

RBRi

[Sebastian Richter]

don't worry, but don't forget it ;) greats

[Sebastian Richter]

is here any new info? on Version 2.25 the problem still exist ... greats

[Sebastian Richter]

is here any new info? on Version 2.28 the problem still exist ... greats
Or if is not poosible with HTMLUnit? I think the JS-Support of HTMLUnit is bad and goes very worse in the future because is Rhino-Engine.
I think we have to change to PhantomJS or Chrome-Headless...
Or not?

[RBRi]

Sorry nothing new so far...

[Kalinrow]

Hi,
it seems the issue is still present in version 2.31. Are the any news? Will it be implemented at all?
Best regards