From: Genearic <gen...@gm...> - 2010-12-16 14:29:56
|
Hi, Why the tag PAGE is under the tag reference SOUR in Gramps while in GEDCOM tag PAGE is under too the tag definition SOUR ? Regards, --- Export GEDCOM from GRAMPS : 0 @I1@ INDI 1 SOUR @A1@ 2 PAGE 284 2 DATA 0 @A1@ SOUR 1 TITL Acte de Naissance de Pierre DUPOND 1 AUTH SARKOZY Nicolas, Officier d'Etat-Civil 1 PUBL Paris (Seine) 1 ABBR 254 1 REPO @R0000@ 1 CHAN 2 DATE 16 DEC 2010 3 TIME 11:02:13 --- >From GEDCOM : 0 @I1@ INDI 1 SOUR @A1@ 0 @A1@ SOUR 1 PAGE 284 1 DATA 2 DATE 15 FEB 1804 3 TIME 13:20 2 AGNC Paris (Seine) 1 TITL Acte de Naissance de Pierre DUPOND 1 AUTH SARKOZY Nicolas, Officier d'Etat-Civil 1 PUBL Paris (Seine) 1 ABBR 254 --- Standard GEDCOM : SOURCE_RECORD:= n @<XREF:SOUR>@ SOUR +1 DATA +2 EVEN <EVENTS_RECORDED> +3 DATE <DATE_PERIOD> +3 PLAC <SOURCE_JURISDICTION_PLACE> +2 AGNC <RESPONSIBLE_AGENCY> +2 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> +1 AUTH <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> +1 TITL <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> +1 ABBR <SOURCE_FILED_BY_ENTRY> +1 PUBL <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> +1 <<SOURCE_REPOSITORY_CITATION>> +1 REFN <USER_REFERENCE_NUMBER> +2 TYPE <USER_REFERENCE_TYPE> +1 RIN <AUTOMATED_RECORD_ID> +1 <<CHANGE_DATE>> +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> SOURCE_CITATION:= [ /* pointer to source record (preferred)*/ n SOUR @<XREF:SOUR>@ {1:1} p.27 +1 PAGE <WHERE_WITHIN_SOURCE> {0:1} p.64 +1 EVEN <EVENT_TYPE_CITED_FROM> {0:1} p.49 +2 ROLE <ROLE_IN_EVENT> {0:1} p.61 +1 DATA {0:1} +2 DATE <ENTRY_RECORDING_DATE> {0:1} p.48 +2 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 +3 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 | /* Systems not using source records */ n SOUR <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {1:1} p.61 +1 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {0:M} +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 ] --- |
From: Genearic <gen...@gm...> - 2010-12-16 14:39:27
|
I have the same problem with the tag TITL becomes AUTH after exporting to GEDCOM from GRAMPS : Original GEDCOM : 0 @S6@ SOUR 1 TITL Edouard MEL becomes : 0 @S6@ SOUR 1 AUTH Edouard MEL 1 CHAN 2 DATE 16 DEC 2010 3 TIME 13:27:36 2010/12/16 Genearic <gen...@gm...> > Hi, > > Why the tag PAGE is under the tag reference SOUR in Gramps while in GEDCOM > tag PAGE is under too the tag definition SOUR ? > Regards, > > --- > > Export GEDCOM from GRAMPS : > 0 @I1@ INDI > 1 SOUR @A1@ > 2 PAGE 284 > 2 DATA > > 0 @A1@ SOUR > 1 TITL Acte de Naissance de Pierre DUPOND > 1 AUTH SARKOZY Nicolas, Officier d'Etat-Civil > 1 PUBL Paris (Seine) > 1 ABBR 254 > 1 REPO @R0000@ > 1 CHAN > 2 DATE 16 DEC 2010 > 3 TIME 11:02:13 > > --- > > From GEDCOM : > 0 @I1@ INDI > 1 SOUR @A1@ > > 0 @A1@ SOUR > 1 PAGE 284 > 1 DATA > 2 DATE 15 FEB 1804 > 3 TIME 13:20 > 2 AGNC Paris (Seine) > 1 TITL Acte de Naissance de Pierre DUPOND > 1 AUTH SARKOZY Nicolas, Officier d'Etat-Civil > 1 PUBL Paris (Seine) > 1 ABBR 254 > > --- > > Standard GEDCOM : > > SOURCE_RECORD:= > n @<XREF:SOUR>@ SOUR > +1 DATA > +2 EVEN <EVENTS_RECORDED> > +3 DATE <DATE_PERIOD> > +3 PLAC <SOURCE_JURISDICTION_PLACE> > +2 AGNC <RESPONSIBLE_AGENCY> > +2 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> > +1 AUTH <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> > +1 TITL <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> > +1 ABBR <SOURCE_FILED_BY_ENTRY> > +1 PUBL <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> > +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> > +1 <<SOURCE_REPOSITORY_CITATION>> > +1 REFN <USER_REFERENCE_NUMBER> > +2 TYPE <USER_REFERENCE_TYPE> > +1 RIN <AUTOMATED_RECORD_ID> > +1 <<CHANGE_DATE>> > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> > > > > SOURCE_CITATION:= > [ /* pointer to source record (preferred)*/ > n SOUR @<XREF:SOUR>@ {1:1} p.27 > +1 PAGE <WHERE_WITHIN_SOURCE> {0:1} p.64 > +1 EVEN <EVENT_TYPE_CITED_FROM> {0:1} p.49 > +2 ROLE <ROLE_IN_EVENT> {0:1} p.61 > +1 DATA {0:1} > +2 DATE <ENTRY_RECORDING_DATE> {0:1} p.48 > +2 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 > +3 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 > +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 > | /* Systems not using source records */ > n SOUR <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {1:1} p.61 > +1 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {0:M} > +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 > +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 > +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 > ] > > --- > > > |
From: Genearic <gen...@gm...> - 2010-12-16 15:05:26
|
Disregard the last message: it is I who changed under Gramps. 2010/12/16 Genearic <gen...@gm...> > I have the same problem with the tag TITL becomes AUTH after exporting to GEDCOM > from GRAMPS : > > Original GEDCOM : > > 0 @S6@ SOUR > 1 TITL Edouard MEL > > becomes : > > 0 @S6@ SOUR > 1 AUTH Edouard MEL > > 1 CHAN > 2 DATE 16 DEC 2010 > 3 TIME 13:27:36 > > |
From: Genearic <gen...@gm...> - 2010-12-17 10:36:15
|
Please, is this a bug report on Mantis? 2010/12/16 Genearic <gen...@gm...> > Hi, > > Why the tag PAGE is under the tag reference SOUR in Gramps while in GEDCOM > tag PAGE is under too the tag definition SOUR ? > Regards, > > --- > > Export GEDCOM from GRAMPS : > 0 @I1@ INDI > 1 SOUR @A1@ > 2 PAGE 284 > 2 DATA > > 0 @A1@ SOUR > 1 TITL Acte de Naissance de Pierre DUPOND > 1 AUTH SARKOZY Nicolas, Officier d'Etat-Civil > 1 PUBL Paris (Seine) > 1 ABBR 254 > 1 REPO @R0000@ > 1 CHAN > 2 DATE 16 DEC 2010 > 3 TIME 11:02:13 > > --- > > From GEDCOM : > 0 @I1@ INDI > 1 SOUR @A1@ > > 0 @A1@ SOUR > 1 PAGE 284 > 1 DATA > 2 DATE 15 FEB 1804 > 3 TIME 13:20 > 2 AGNC Paris (Seine) > 1 TITL Acte de Naissance de Pierre DUPOND > 1 AUTH SARKOZY Nicolas, Officier d'Etat-Civil > 1 PUBL Paris (Seine) > 1 ABBR 254 > > --- > > Standard GEDCOM : > > SOURCE_RECORD:= > n @<XREF:SOUR>@ SOUR > +1 DATA > +2 EVEN <EVENTS_RECORDED> > +3 DATE <DATE_PERIOD> > +3 PLAC <SOURCE_JURISDICTION_PLACE> > +2 AGNC <RESPONSIBLE_AGENCY> > +2 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> > +1 AUTH <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> > +1 TITL <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> > +1 ABBR <SOURCE_FILED_BY_ENTRY> > +1 PUBL <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> > +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> > +1 <<SOURCE_REPOSITORY_CITATION>> > +1 REFN <USER_REFERENCE_NUMBER> > +2 TYPE <USER_REFERENCE_TYPE> > +1 RIN <AUTOMATED_RECORD_ID> > +1 <<CHANGE_DATE>> > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> > > > > SOURCE_CITATION:= > [ /* pointer to source record (preferred)*/ > n SOUR @<XREF:SOUR>@ {1:1} p.27 > +1 PAGE <WHERE_WITHIN_SOURCE> {0:1} p.64 > +1 EVEN <EVENT_TYPE_CITED_FROM> {0:1} p.49 > +2 ROLE <ROLE_IN_EVENT> {0:1} p.61 > +1 DATA {0:1} > +2 DATE <ENTRY_RECORDING_DATE> {0:1} p.48 > +2 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 > +3 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 > +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 > | /* Systems not using source records */ > n SOUR <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {1:1} p.61 > +1 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {0:M} > +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 > +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 > +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 > ] > > --- > > > |
From: lcc . <lcc...@gm...> - 2010-12-17 22:02:12
|
Moving to Gramps-devel, but according to the specification you pasted below, the PAGE tag is not accepted at the source definition, only at the source reference. It seems Gramps is actually fixing your broken Gedcom. Do you see a PAGE tag below? > SOURCE_RECORD:= > n @<XREF:SOUR>@ SOUR > +1 DATA > +2 EVEN <EVENTS_RECORDED> > +3 DATE <DATE_PERIOD> > +3 PLAC <SOURCE_JURISDICTION_PLACE> > +2 AGNC <RESPONSIBLE_AGENCY> > +2 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> > +1 AUTH <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> > +1 TITL <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> > +1 ABBR <SOURCE_FILED_BY_ENTRY> > +1 PUBL <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> > +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> > +1 <<SOURCE_REPOSITORY_CITATION>> > +1 REFN <USER_REFERENCE_NUMBER> > +2 TYPE <USER_REFERENCE_TYPE> > +1 RIN <AUTOMATED_RECORD_ID> > +1 <<CHANGE_DATE>> > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> On the other hand, the PAGE tag is acceptable at the source citation/reference: > SOURCE_CITATION:= > [ /* pointer to source record (preferred)*/ > n SOUR @<XREF:SOUR>@ {1:1} p.27 > +1 PAGE <WHERE_WITHIN_SOURCE> {0:1} p.64 > +1 EVEN <EVENT_TYPE_CITED_FROM> {0:1} p.49 > +2 ROLE <ROLE_IN_EVENT> {0:1} p.61 > +1 DATA {0:1} > +2 DATE <ENTRY_RECORDING_DATE> {0:1} p.48 > +2 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 > +3 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 > +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 > | /* Systems not using source records */ > n SOUR <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {1:1} p.61 > +1 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {0:M} > +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 > +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 > +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 > ] Others on Gramps-devel should check this but this is my take so far. On 12/16/10, Genearic <gen...@gm...> wrote: > Hi, > > Why the tag PAGE is under the tag reference SOUR in Gramps while in GEDCOM > tag PAGE is under too the tag definition SOUR ? > Regards, > > --- > > Export GEDCOM from GRAMPS : > 0 @I1@ INDI > 1 SOUR @A1@ > 2 PAGE 284 > 2 DATA > > 0 @A1@ SOUR > 1 TITL Acte de Naissance de Pierre DUPOND > 1 AUTH SARKOZY Nicolas, Officier d'Etat-Civil > 1 PUBL Paris (Seine) > 1 ABBR 254 > 1 REPO @R0000@ > 1 CHAN > 2 DATE 16 DEC 2010 > 3 TIME 11:02:13 > > --- > > >From GEDCOM : > 0 @I1@ INDI > 1 SOUR @A1@ > > 0 @A1@ SOUR > 1 PAGE 284 > 1 DATA > 2 DATE 15 FEB 1804 > 3 TIME 13:20 > 2 AGNC Paris (Seine) > 1 TITL Acte de Naissance de Pierre DUPOND > 1 AUTH SARKOZY Nicolas, Officier d'Etat-Civil > 1 PUBL Paris (Seine) > 1 ABBR 254 > > --- > > Standard GEDCOM : > > SOURCE_RECORD:= > n @<XREF:SOUR>@ SOUR > +1 DATA > +2 EVEN <EVENTS_RECORDED> > +3 DATE <DATE_PERIOD> > +3 PLAC <SOURCE_JURISDICTION_PLACE> > +2 AGNC <RESPONSIBLE_AGENCY> > +2 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> > +1 AUTH <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_ORIGINATOR> > +1 TITL <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE> > +1 ABBR <SOURCE_FILED_BY_ENTRY> > +1 PUBL <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS> > +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> > +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> > +1 <<SOURCE_REPOSITORY_CITATION>> > +1 REFN <USER_REFERENCE_NUMBER> > +2 TYPE <USER_REFERENCE_TYPE> > +1 RIN <AUTOMATED_RECORD_ID> > +1 <<CHANGE_DATE>> > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> > > > > SOURCE_CITATION:= > [ /* pointer to source record (preferred)*/ > n SOUR @<XREF:SOUR>@ {1:1} p.27 > +1 PAGE <WHERE_WITHIN_SOURCE> {0:1} p.64 > +1 EVEN <EVENT_TYPE_CITED_FROM> {0:1} p.49 > +2 ROLE <ROLE_IN_EVENT> {0:1} p.61 > +1 DATA {0:1} > +2 DATE <ENTRY_RECORDING_DATE> {0:1} p.48 > +2 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 > +3 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 > +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 > | /* Systems not using source records */ > n SOUR <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {1:1} p.61 > +1 [CONC|CONT] <SOURCE_DESCRIPTION> {0:M} > +1 TEXT <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} p.63 > +2 [CONC|CONT] <TEXT_FROM_SOURCE> {0:M} > +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> {0:M} p.37, 26 > +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>> {0:M} p.37 > +1 QUAY <CERTAINTY_ASSESSMENT> {0:1} p.43 > ] > > --- > |