Menu

#2032 Launcher Won't Launch Float Versions of DeHavilland Aircraft

2018.2.3
Invalid
Medium
2019-06-06
2018-07-02
trennor
No

[code]FlightGear version: 2017.3.1
Revision: none
Build-Id: none
Build-Type: Dev
FG_ROOT=/usr/share/flightgear
FG_HOME=/root/.fgfs
FG_SCENERY=/root/.fgfs/TerraSync:/usr/share/flightgear/Scenery
SimGear version: 2017.3.1
OSG version: 3.4.1
PLIB version: 185 [/code]

FG launcher will not permit float versions of the DeHavilland DHC2 Beaver, DCH3 Otter or the DHC6 Twin Otters. Float option simply isn't there, and cannot be defined in Settings. Note, this is not an aircraft issue, but a launcher issue. Calling up Launcher, only Wheels versions of these planes are available, when a float version should also appear in the launcher. I tried aircraft=dhc2f in Settings, and Launcher ignored it and launched wheeled version instead; wonderful if you try this on a lake! Yet the Aircraft package ships with a float version, so why is that version not being read?

Related

Tickets: #2032

Discussion

  • James Turner

    James Turner - 2018-07-02

    I'm able to select float-base aircraft such as the DHC6 floats and otter with floats using my development build. Are you able to test that version (or 2018.2.x?)

     
  • James Turner

    James Turner - 2018-07-02
    • status: New --> NeedInfo
    • assigned_to: James Turner
     
    • trennor

      trennor - 2018-07-03

      FlightGear version: 2017.3.1 -- Floats don't work in launcher.

      You said:
      "Are you able to test that version (or 2018.2.x?)"

      Test? my test is whether it works or not with my current version, and it
      doesn't, which is why I filed the bug report. I'm not using 2018.x.x yet,
      I'm still on FC 27 and won't be upgrading for some time. Fedora repository
      doesn't have 2018.x.x listed, and with the complexity of FG now, I'm not
      compiling manually. Wouldn't it be easier to simply write a patch and add
      it to the repository so this basic function is included?

      On Mon, Jul 2, 2018 at 4:53 PM, James Turner <jmturner@users.sourceforge.net

      wrote:

      • status: New --> NeedInfo
      • assigned_to: James Turner

      Status: NeedInfo
      Milestone: 2018.2.3
      Labels: launcher DeHavillland float version
      Created: Mon Jul 02, 2018 05:56 PM UTC by trennor
      Last Updated: Mon Jul 02, 2018 09:52 PM UTC
      Owner: James Turner

      [code]FlightGear version: 2017.3.1
      Revision: none
      Build-Id: none
      Build-Type: Dev
      FG_ROOT=/usr/share/flightgear
      FG_HOME=/root/.fgfs
      FG_SCENERY=/root/.fgfs/TerraSync:/usr/share/flightgear/Scenery
      SimGear version: 2017.3.1
      OSG version: 3.4.1
      PLIB version: 185 [/code]

      FG launcher will not permit float versions of the DeHavilland DHC2 Beaver,
      DCH3 Otter or the DHC6 Twin Otters. Float option simply isn't there, and
      cannot be defined in Settings. Note, this is not an aircraft issue, but a
      launcher issue. Calling up Launcher, only Wheels versions of these planes
      are available, when a float version should also appear in the launcher. I
      tried aircraft=dhc2f in Settings, and Launcher ignored it and launched
      wheeled version instead; wonderful if you try this on a lake! Yet the
      Aircraft package ships with a float version, so why is that version not
      being read?


      Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in
      https://sourceforge.net/p/flightgear/codetickets/2032/

      To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit
      https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/

       

      Related

      Tickets: #2032

      • trennor

        trennor - 2018-07-03

        I've GIVEN you the info I have! You're a Dev, now it's up to YOU to figure
        it out, why the hell are you coming back to ME?! I'm not a geek! I've
        reported what I've found. By the sounds of this you're not going to do
        anything, are you?! For chrissakes, fire up a copy of
        2017.3.whatever and test
        it for yourself!
        That way, you're getting first hand information and
        not relying on an unreliable non-geek to provide you with he knows not what
        you want!!

        Cya!

        On Tue, Jul 3, 2018 at 2:01 AM, trennor trennor@users.sourceforge.net
        wrote:

        FlightGear version: 2017.3.1 -- Floats don't work in launcher.

        You said:
        "Are you able to test that version (or 2018.2.x?)"

        Test? my test is whether it works or not with my current version, and it
        doesn't, which is why I filed the bug report. I'm not using 2018.x.x yet,
        I'm still on FC 27 and won't be upgrading for some time. Fedora repository
        doesn't have 2018.x.x listed, and with the complexity of FG now, I'm not
        compiling manually. Wouldn't it be easier to simply write a patch and add
        it to the repository so this basic function is included?

        On Mon, Jul 2, 2018 at 4:53 PM, James Turner <jmturner@users.sourceforge.
        net

        wrote:

        • status: New --> NeedInfo
        • assigned_to: James Turner

        Status: NeedInfo
        Milestone: 2018.2.3
        Labels: launcher DeHavillland float version
        Created: Mon Jul 02, 2018 05:56 PM UTC by trennor
        Last Updated: Mon Jul 02, 2018 09:52 PM UTC
        Owner: James Turner

        [code]FlightGear version: 2017.3.1
        Revision: none
        Build-Id: none
        Build-Type: Dev
        FG_ROOT=/usr/share/flightgear
        FG_HOME=/root/.fgfs
        FG_SCENERY=/root/.fgfs/TerraSync:/usr/share/flightgear/Scenery
        SimGear version: 2017.3.1
        OSG version: 3.4.1
        PLIB version: 185 [/code]

        FG launcher will not permit float versions of the DeHavilland DHC2 Beaver,
        DCH3 Otter or the DHC6 Twin Otters. Float option simply isn't there, and
        cannot be defined in Settings. Note, this is not an aircraft issue, but a
        launcher issue. Calling up Launcher, only Wheels versions of these planes
        are available, when a float version should also appear in the launcher. I
        tried aircraft=dhc2f in Settings, and Launcher ignored it and launched
        wheeled version instead; wonderful if you try this on a lake! Yet the
        Aircraft package ships with a float version, so why is that version not
        being read?


        Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in
        https://sourceforge.net/p/flightgear/codetickets/2032/

        To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit
        https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/


        Status: NeedInfo
        Milestone: 2018.2.3
        Labels: launcher DeHavillland float version
        Created: Mon Jul 02, 2018 05:56 PM UTC by trennor
        Last Updated: Mon Jul 02, 2018 09:53 PM UTC
        Owner: James Turner

        [code]FlightGear version: 2017.3.1
        Revision: none
        Build-Id: none
        Build-Type: Dev
        FG_ROOT=/usr/share/flightgear
        FG_HOME=/root/.fgfs
        FG_SCENERY=/root/.fgfs/TerraSync:/usr/share/flightgear/Scenery
        SimGear version: 2017.3.1
        OSG version: 3.4.1
        PLIB version: 185 [/code]

        FG launcher will not permit float versions of the DeHavilland DHC2 Beaver,
        DCH3 Otter or the DHC6 Twin Otters. Float option simply isn't there, and
        cannot be defined in Settings. Note, this is not an aircraft issue, but a
        launcher issue. Calling up Launcher, only Wheels versions of these planes
        are available, when a float version should also appear in the launcher. I
        tried aircraft=dhc2f in Settings, and Launcher ignored it and launched
        wheeled version instead; wonderful if you try this on a lake! Yet the
        Aircraft package ships with a float version, so why is that version not
        being read?


        Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in
        https://sourceforge.net/p/flightgear/codetickets/2032/

        To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit
        https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/

         

        Related

        Tickets: #2032

        • Stuart Buchanan

          Stuart Buchanan - 2018-07-03

          Hi Trennor,

          Stepping in here as I think you are over-reacting to what was a
          straightforward question. It’s quite OK to explain that you can’t check
          against the latest version. What is not OK is swearing at volunteer
          developers.

          There are only a small number of developers of FlightGear and the more help
          you can provide the more effective they can be. For example if you were
          able to reproduce the problem on 2018.3 then we’d know that it hasn’t been
          fixed already. However if it was fixed already in 2018.3 (as James can’t
          reproduce himself) then we would know to look for an existing fix. Plus
          you’d have it working :)

          BTW - I don’t think we have way to patch the Fedora repository. And we
          rarely back-apply fixes to old releases.

          Hopefully this will explain the reason for James’s question.

          Best regards,

          Stuart Buchanan

          On Tue, 3 Jul 2018 at 09:33, trennor trennor@users.sourceforge.net wrote:

          I've GIVEN you the info I have! You're a Dev, now it's up to YOU to figure
          it out, why the hell are you coming back to ME?! I'm not a geek! I've
          reported what I've found. By the sounds of this you're not going to do
          anything, are you?! For chrissakes, fire up a copy of
          2017.3.whatever and
          test it for yourself! That way, you're getting first hand information
          and
          not relying on an unreliable non-geek to provide you with he knows not what
          you want!!

          Cya!

          On Tue, Jul 3, 2018 at 2:01 AM, trennor trennor@users.sourceforge.net
          wrote:

          FlightGear version: 2017.3.1 -- Floats don't work in launcher.

          You said:
          "Are you able to test that version (or 2018.2.x?)"

          Test? my test is whether it works or not with my current version, and it
          doesn't, which is why I filed the bug report. I'm not using 2018.x.x yet,
          I'm still on FC 27 and won't be upgrading for some time. Fedora repository
          doesn't have 2018.x.x listed, and with the complexity of FG now, I'm not
          compiling manually. Wouldn't it be easier to simply write a patch and add
          it to the repository so this basic function is included?

          On Mon, Jul 2, 2018 at 4:53 PM, James Turner <jmturner@users.sourceforge.
          net

          wrote:

          • status: New --> NeedInfo
          • assigned_to: James Turner

          Status: NeedInfo
          Milestone: 2018.2.3
          Labels: launcher DeHavillland float version
          Created: Mon Jul 02, 2018 05:56 PM UTC by trennor
          Last Updated: Mon Jul 02, 2018 09:52 PM UTC
          Owner: James Turner

          [code]FlightGear version: 2017.3.1
          Revision: none
          Build-Id: none
          Build-Type: Dev
          FG_ROOT=/usr/share/flightgear
          FG_HOME=/root/.fgfs
          FG_SCENERY=/root/.fgfs/TerraSync:/usr/share/flightgear/Scenery
          SimGear version: 2017.3.1
          OSG version: 3.4.1
          PLIB version: 185 [/code]

          FG launcher will not permit float versions of the DeHavilland DHC2 Beaver,
          DCH3 Otter or the DHC6 Twin Otters. Float option simply isn't there, and
          cannot be defined in Settings. Note, this is not an aircraft issue, but a
          launcher issue. Calling up Launcher, only Wheels versions of these planes
          are available, when a float version should also appear in the launcher. I
          tried aircraft=dhc2f in Settings, and Launcher ignored it and launched
          wheeled version instead; wonderful if you try this on a lake! Yet the
          Aircraft package ships with a float version, so why is that version not
          being read?


          Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in
          https://sourceforge.net/p/flightgear/codetickets/2032/

          To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit
          https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/


          Status: NeedInfo
          Milestone: 2018.2.3
          Labels: launcher DeHavillland float version
          Created: Mon Jul 02, 2018 05:56 PM UTC by trennor
          Last Updated: Mon Jul 02, 2018 09:53 PM UTC
          Owner: James Turner

          [code]FlightGear version: 2017.3.1
          Revision: none
          Build-Id: none
          Build-Type: Dev
          FG_ROOT=/usr/share/flightgear
          FG_HOME=/root/.fgfs
          FG_SCENERY=/root/.fgfs/TerraSync:/usr/share/flightgear/Scenery
          SimGear version: 2017.3.1
          OSG version: 3.4.1
          PLIB version: 185 [/code]

          FG launcher will not permit float versions of the DeHavilland DHC2 Beaver,
          DCH3 Otter or the DHC6 Twin Otters. Float option simply isn't there, and
          cannot be defined in Settings. Note, this is not an aircraft issue, but a
          launcher issue. Calling up Launcher, only Wheels versions of these planes
          are available, when a float version should also appear in the launcher. I
          tried aircraft=dhc2f in Settings, and Launcher ignored it and launched
          wheeled version instead; wonderful if you try this on a lake! Yet the
          Aircraft package ships with a float version, so why is that version not
          being read?


          Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in
          https://sourceforge.net/p/flightgear/codetickets/2032/

          To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit
          https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/


          Status: NeedInfo
          Milestone: 2018.2.3
          Labels: launcher DeHavillland float version
          Created: Mon Jul 02, 2018 05:56 PM UTC by trennor
          Last Updated: Mon Jul 02, 2018 09:53 PM UTC
          Owner: James Turner

          [code]FlightGear version: 2017.3.1
          Revision: none
          Build-Id: none
          Build-Type: Dev
          FG_ROOT=/usr/share/flightgear
          FG_HOME=/root/.fgfs
          FG_SCENERY=/root/.fgfs/TerraSync:/usr/share/flightgear/Scenery
          SimGear version: 2017.3.1
          OSG version: 3.4.1
          PLIB version: 185 [/code]

          FG launcher will not permit float versions of the DeHavilland DHC2 Beaver,
          DCH3 Otter or the DHC6 Twin Otters. Float option simply isn't there, and
          cannot be defined in Settings. Note, this is not an aircraft issue, but a
          launcher issue. Calling up Launcher, only Wheels versions of these planes
          are available, when a float version should also appear in the launcher. I
          tried aircraft=dhc2f in Settings, and Launcher ignored it and launched
          wheeled version instead; wonderful if you try this on a lake! Yet the
          Aircraft package ships with a float version, so why is that version not
          being read?


          Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in
          https://sourceforge.net/p/flightgear/codetickets/2032/

          To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit
          https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/

           

          Related

          Tickets: #2032

  • waldo kitty

    waldo kitty - 2018-07-04

    i cannot confirm this bug in the latest development code for FG 2018.3.0... launcher development is moving too fast for problems reports related to it in older FG versions... FG 2017.3.1 is 10 months old and there's been two more releases since then... even the latest 2018.2.1 release has bugs in the launcher that are already fixed in the development code...

     
  • xDraconian

    xDraconian - 2018-09-29
    • labels: launcher DeHavillland, float version --> Launcher, DeHavilland, Floats
     
  • Gijs

    Gijs - 2019-06-06
    • status: NeedInfo --> Invalid
     
  • Gijs

    Gijs - 2019-06-06

    Since this cannot be reproduced with the most recent releases, we assume that this is fixed in the meantime. Please re-open if proven false.

     

Log in to post a comment.