Re: fetchmail/qmail/-scanner/SpamAss. integration (was: [fetchmail-users] Hello i have problem :()

[Ozgur Y. <mr...@gm...>]

On 5/4/06, Ozgur YILMAZ <mr...@gm...> wrote:
>
>  Hello
>
> firstly thanks for your answer.
> i have not one user it is only my test user
> if it works, i will add a lot of domains and user
>
> i use fetchmail ---> fetch mail from external mail server
> qmail ---> mda and pop3 server
> SA ---> spam filter
>
> i want to fetch mail from external server to my internal server ( for 150
> user).
> and then i use spam filter and my user connect pop3 server and then
> recieve mail.
> is is possible
> it setup one and they work alone
>
> .fethmailrc use this settings
>
> poll 72.29.74.211 protocol pop3
>
> user 'oz...@ne...' there with password 'mypass' is
> 'de...@co...' here
>
>  my mail in my inbox but not scanning spamm :(
>
> what do i do ?
>
>
>
>
> On 5/3/06, Matthias Andree <mat...@gm...> wrote:
> >
> > "Ozgur YILMAZ" <mr...@gm...> writes:
> >
> > > i want to local spam scanner for office
> > > i setup fetchmail + qmail + vpopmail + qmailscanner + SA
> > >
> > > i fetch mail by fetchmail and i recived qmail pop3
> > > and SA works test command but my fetch mail is not scanned by SA
> >
> > Özgür,
> >
> > qmail is not a modern MTA by any standard and full of flaws that other
> > MTAs do not share. <http://home.pages.de/~mandree/qmail-bugs.html>
> >
> > > here my .fetchmailrc
> > >
> > > poll my.externalserver.com protocol pop3
> > > user 'oz...@ne...' there with password 'mypass' is
> > > 'de...@co...' here
> > > mda "/usr/bin/spamc -e | /var/spool/qmailscan/qmail-queue" ( i have
> > problem this line i do not write )
> >
> > What do you need vpopmail for if there is only one user?
> >
> > The MDA option doesn't look correct. Spamc expects a command after -e,
> > and qmail-queue programs (and substitutes) expect two file descriptors
> > for input. One for the envelope, one for the data.
> >
> > Is there a particular reason why you're using the "mda" option?
> > And then in a way that loses envelope information?
> >
> > I wonder how you are getting messages at all with this setup, you should
> > get something like:  /usr/bin/spamc: option requires an argument -- e
> >
> > Besides that, qmail-scanner claims to integrate with SpamAssassin - so
> > there should be some qmail-scanner documentation on that topic.
> >
> > Try checking the documentation and understanding or describing to
> > somebody
> >
> > - what you want to achieve
> >
> > - how you can get there
> >
> > rather than taking lines out of a context and trying them out.
> >
> > A systematic approach will probably be more successful than guessing
> > here.
> >
> > --
> > Matthias Andree
> >
>
>