nice to have. but isn't this will render content less portable with RSS feed? i.e content with relative url in atom (and xml:base) will work fine, but what happened if the same content is used to generate RSS or OPML ? the relative url inside rss and opml will fail, this create inconsistencies between atom and rss feeds.
shouldn't users be disciplined to use absolute URL when generating multiple feed format using feedcreator? (the same content can be use for rss and atom)
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
You are very correct that ideally all links should be absolute, and a search for
atom xml:base
on Google will bring up all the negative thing about it in the first link. That said, in PhpGedView, we are re-wrapping content that is already on the site in the form that the user entered them in the case of the news articles, and in many cases they contain relative links. In this case it would be nice to be able to better deal with such relative links. All URLs that are generated by PhpGedView are already absolute full URLs. I am just trying to fix this issue when we can (ATOM) for these user entered links.
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
Logged In: YES
user_id=458301
Originator: NO
nice to have. but isn't this will render content less portable with RSS feed? i.e content with relative url in atom (and xml:base) will work fine, but what happened if the same content is used to generate RSS or OPML ? the relative url inside rss and opml will fail, this create inconsistencies between atom and rss feeds.
shouldn't users be disciplined to use absolute URL when generating multiple feed format using feedcreator? (the same content can be use for rss and atom)
Logged In: YES
user_id=634811
Originator: YES
You are very correct that ideally all links should be absolute, and a search for
atom xml:base
on Google will bring up all the negative thing about it in the first link. That said, in PhpGedView, we are re-wrapping content that is already on the site in the form that the user entered them in the case of the news articles, and in many cases they contain relative links. In this case it would be nice to be able to better deal with such relative links. All URLs that are generated by PhpGedView are already absolute full URLs. I am just trying to fix this issue when we can (ATOM) for these user entered links.