Menu

#165 Distillation column does not meet the mass balance

5.0
wont-fix
2017-08-18
2017-08-18
No

Hi, the distillation column does not meet the mass balance but figures as resolved.

1 Attachments

Discussion

  • Daniel Medeiros

    Daniel Medeiros - 2017-08-18
    • status: open --> pending
     
  • Daniel Medeiros

    Daniel Medeiros - 2017-08-18

    Replace the Reboiled Absorber by a ChemSep column.

     
  • Juan Ignacio Manassaldi

    I can't find the chem sep column.

     
  • Daniel Medeiros

    Daniel Medeiros - 2017-08-18

    CAPE-OPEN Unit Operation, then select ChemSep.

     
  • Juan Ignacio Manassaldi

    Ok, i'm testing... Thanks You!

     
  • Juan Ignacio Manassaldi

    I was able to make it work.
    What is the problem with the native distillation collum?

     
  • Daniel Medeiros

    Daniel Medeiros - 2017-08-18

    I'm not supporting Reboiled/Refluxed Absorber columns in DWSIM anymore, they're there only for compatibility reasons.

     
  • Daniel Medeiros

    Daniel Medeiros - 2017-08-18
    • status: pending --> wont-fix
     
  • Juan Ignacio Manassaldi

    ok.
    I will try to use the native distillation collum with full reflux condenser
    Thanks!

     
  • Daniel Medeiros

    Daniel Medeiros - 2017-08-18

    If you're on Windows there's no reason not to use ChemSep unless you're working with compounds that it doesn't support. Other than that, ChemSep's column model is much superior to DWSIM's internal model.

     

    Last edit: Daniel Medeiros 2017-08-18
  • Juan Ignacio Manassaldi

    Yes, i use ChemSep without problems but we are introducing your simulator in our course.
    For teaching I prefer stay only in DWsim.
    Thanks!

     
  • Daniel Medeiros

    Daniel Medeiros - 2017-08-18

    I see. I usually try my column models first when I need them, if they fail to converge after a few tweaks, I change it to a ChemSep column. Even ChemSep has trouble converging in some cases...

     
MongoDB Logo MongoDB