From: <ku...@us...> - 2007-09-07 04:41:47
|
Revision: 138 http://dl-learner.svn.sourceforge.net/dl-learner/?rev=138&view=rev Author: kurzum Date: 2007-09-06 21:38:46 -0700 (Thu, 06 Sep 2007) Log Message: ----------- changed some examples Modified Paths: -------------- trunk/examples/arch/arch.conf trunk/examples/arch/arch_owl.conf trunk/examples/forte/forte_uncle.conf trunk/examples/forte/forte_uncle_owl.conf trunk/examples/moral_reasoner/moral_43examples_complex.conf trunk/examples/moral_reasoner/moral_43examples_complex_owl.conf Added Paths: ----------- trunk/examples/moral_reasoner/moral_43examples_simple owl.conf trunk/examples/moral_reasoner/moral_43examples_simple.conf trunk/examples/moral_reasoner/moral_all_examples_simple.conf Modified: trunk/examples/arch/arch.conf =================================================================== --- trunk/examples/arch/arch.conf 2007-09-05 21:30:47 UTC (rev 137) +++ trunk/examples/arch/arch.conf 2007-09-07 04:38:46 UTC (rev 138) @@ -1,5 +1,6 @@ /***************************** + Example created from these predicates: arch(A, B, C) A, B and C form an arch with lintel A @@ -11,13 +12,17 @@ parallelpiped(A, B) A is a brick or a wedge Solution: arch(A, B, C) <- left-of(B, C), supports(B, A), not touches(B, C) - + + Solution EXISTS hasPillar.EXISTS leftof.TOP <-TOO OBVIOUS all constructions c1,c2,c3,c4 AND EXISTS hasPillar.EXISTS supports.TOP <-IS FOUND [c1, c3, c4] AND NOT EXISTS hasPillar.EXISTS touches.TOP <- Not found (open world assumption) work around with freeStandingPillar +New Solution: +EXISTS hasPillar.(freeStandingPillar AND EXISTS leftof.EXISTS supports.TOP) + See the pictures for an illustration of the input data. Originally published in Winston, P.H. (1975). Learning structural descriptions Modified: trunk/examples/arch/arch_owl.conf =================================================================== --- trunk/examples/arch/arch_owl.conf 2007-09-05 21:30:47 UTC (rev 137) +++ trunk/examples/arch/arch_owl.conf 2007-09-07 04:38:46 UTC (rev 138) @@ -1,7 +1,8 @@ /***************************** -Example created from this: +Example created from these predicates: + arch(A, B, C) A, B and C form an arch with lintel A supports(A, B) A supports B left-of(A, B) A is left of B @@ -16,11 +17,17 @@ EXISTS hasPillar.EXISTS leftof.TOP <-TOO OBVIOUS all constructions c1,c2,c3,c4 AND EXISTS hasPillar.EXISTS supports.TOP <-IS FOUND [c1, c3, c4] AND NOT EXISTS hasPillar.EXISTS touches.TOP <- Not found (open world assumption) - work around with freeStandingPillar -see picture arch.jpg +New Solution: +EXISTS hasPillar.(freeStandingPillar AND EXISTS leftof.EXISTS supports.TOP) +See the pictures for an illustration of the input data. +Originally published in Winston, P.H. (1975). Learning structural descriptions +from examples. In P.H. Winstons (Ed.), The psychology of computer vision. New +York: Mc Graw- Hill. + + ***************************/ //reasoner = kaon2; @@ -29,12 +36,13 @@ refinement.writeSearchTree = false; refinement.searchTreeFile = "searchTree.txt"; refinement.quiet = false; -import("arch.owl"); // hidePrefix="http://localhost/foo#"; /** background knowledge **/ +import("arch.owl"); + /** examples **/ +arch("http://localhost/foo#c1"). +arch("http://localhost/foo#c4"). Modified: trunk/examples/forte/forte_uncle.conf =================================================================== --- trunk/examples/forte/forte_uncle.conf 2007-09-05 21:30:47 UTC (rev 137) +++ trunk/examples/forte/forte_uncle.conf 2007-09-07 04:38:46 UTC (rev 138) @@ -4,12 +4,12 @@ * * http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/ml/forte.html * - * possible solution: (male AND (EXISTS hasSibling.EXISTS hasChild.TOP - * OR EXISTS married.EXISTS hasSibling.EXISTS hasChild.TOP)) + * solution: (male AND (EXISTS hasSibling.EXISTS hasChild.TOP + * OR EXISTS married.EXISTS hasSibling.EXISTS hasChild.TOP)) */ // control output -// showIndividuals = true; +showIndividuals = true; showConcepts = true; showRoles = true; // showInternalKB = true; @@ -17,6 +17,9 @@ algorithm = refinement; + + +/** background knowledge **/ BOTTOM = (male AND female). Symmetric(sibling). @@ -279,6 +282,9 @@ married(prissie, peter). married(jane, jack). married(christy, carlos). married(regina, ray). + +/** examples **/ + /* small example set +isUncle(art). +isUncle(calvin). Modified: trunk/examples/forte/forte_uncle_owl.conf =================================================================== --- trunk/examples/forte/forte_uncle_owl.conf 2007-09-05 21:30:47 UTC (rev 137) +++ trunk/examples/forte/forte_uncle_owl.conf 2007-09-07 04:38:46 UTC (rev 138) @@ -1,5 +1,39 @@ +/** + * Extracted from the FORTE (First Order Revision of Theories from Examples) + * data set + * + * http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/ml/forte.html + * + * solution: (male AND (EXISTS hasSibling.EXISTS hasChild.TOP + * OR EXISTS married.EXISTS hasSibling.EXISTS hasChild.TOP)) + */ + + +/** background knowledge **/ + import("forte.owl"); +/** examples **/ + +/* small example set ++isUncle(art). ++isUncle(calvin). ++isUncle(carlos). ++isUncle(david). ++isUncle(eric). ++isUncle(fred). ++isUncle(frederick). ++isUncle(george). + +-isUncle(alfred). +-isUncle(alice). +-isUncle(angela). +-isUncle(bob). +-isUncle(carl). +-isUncle(christy). +-isUncle(karl). +*/ + // complete example set +isUncle(art). +isUncle(calvin). Modified: trunk/examples/moral_reasoner/moral_43examples_complex.conf =================================================================== --- trunk/examples/moral_reasoner/moral_43examples_complex.conf 2007-09-05 21:30:47 UTC (rev 137) +++ trunk/examples/moral_reasoner/moral_43examples_complex.conf 2007-09-07 04:38:46 UTC (rev 138) @@ -1,8 +1,6 @@ /*********************** - solution should be: - guilty = NOT justified AND (responsible OR vicarious) - - Found: ((NOT justified) AND (vicarious OR (negligent_c AND responsible))) + solution is: + (severity_harm AND (NOT benefit_victim) AND (vicarious OR voluntary)) @@ -10,7 +8,6 @@ 23 positive 20 negative - ***********************/ /** settings **/ @@ -30,6 +27,10 @@ refinement.writeSearchTree = false; refinement.searchTreeFile = "searchTree.txt"; + // writeDIGProtocol = true; + //digProtocolFile = "dig.log"; + + // control output showIndividuals = false; showConcepts = true; @@ -40,26 +41,19 @@ /** background knowledge **/ -"Number"(v0). -"Number"(v1). +//"Number"(v0). +//"Number"(v1). -greater(v1,v0) . -smaller(v0,v1) . +//greater(v1,v0) . +//smaller(v0,v1) . intend_mental_state = (NOT reckless_mental_state AND (NOT negligent_mental_state AND NOT neither_mental_state)). reckless_mental_state = (NOT intend_mental_state AND (NOT negligent_mental_state AND NOT neither_mental_state)). negligent_mental_state = (NOT reckless_mental_state AND (NOT intend_mental_state AND NOT neither_mental_state)). neither_mental_state = (NOT reckless_mental_state AND (NOT negligent_mental_state AND NOT intend_mental_state)). -/*BOTTOM = (intend_mental_state AND reckless_mental_state). -BOTTOM = (intend_mental_state AND negligent_mental_state). -BOTTOM = (intend_mental_state AND neither_mental_state). -BOTTOM = (neither_mental_state AND reckless_mental_state). -BOTTOM = (neither_mental_state AND reckless_mental_state). -BOTTOM = (negligent_mental_state AND reckless_mental_state).*/ - cause = (produce_harm OR (necessary_for_harm OR sufficient_for_harm)). @@ -131,16 +125,16 @@ ( outrank_perpetrator AND control_perpetrator )). - -/*blameworthy = ( responsible AND - ( EXISTS severity_harm.EXISTS greater.TOP AND - ( EXISTS benefit_victim.EXISTS smaller.TOP AND +/* +blameworthy = ( responsible AND + ( severity_harm AND + ( NOT benefit_victim AND NOT justified ))). - + vicarious_blame = ( vicarious AND - (EXISTS severity_harm.EXISTS greater.TOP AND - (EXISTS benefit_victim.EXISTS smaller.TOP AND + ( severity_harm AND + ( NOT benefit_victim AND NOT justified ))). */ // complement checked @@ -150,6 +144,10 @@ NOT goal_achieveable_less_harmful)). //guilty = (blameworthy OR vicarious_blame ). +/*test= (severity_harm AND + ( NOT benefit_victim AND + ( vicarious OR + voluntary))).*/ /******************** @@ -173,8 +171,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p0). benefit_protagonist(p0). careful(p0). -benefit_victim(p0,v0). -severity_harm(p0,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p0). +severity_harm(p0). NOT achieve_goal(p0). NOT intervening_contribution(p0). high_foreseeability(p0). @@ -197,8 +195,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p1). benefit_protagonist(p1). NOT careful(p1). -benefit_victim(p1,v0). -severity_harm(p1,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p1). +severity_harm(p1). NOT achieve_goal(p1). foresee_intervention(p1). high_foreseeability(p1). @@ -221,8 +219,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p2). benefit_protagonist(p2). NOT careful(p2). -benefit_victim(p2,v0). -severity_harm(p2,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p2). +severity_harm(p2). NOT achieve_goal(p2). NOT intervening_contribution(p2). high_foreseeability(p2). @@ -245,8 +243,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p3). NOT achieve_goal(p3). NOT careful(p3). -benefit_victim(p3,v0). -severity_harm(p3,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p3). +severity_harm(p3). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p3). foresee_intervention(p3). high_foreseeability(p3). @@ -269,8 +267,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p4). NOT achieve_goal(p4). careful(p4). -benefit_victim(p4,v0). -severity_harm(p4,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p4). +severity_harm(p4). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p4). foresee_intervention(p4). high_foreseeability(p4). @@ -293,8 +291,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p5). NOT achieve_goal(p5). careful(p5). -benefit_victim(p5,v0). -severity_harm(p5,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p5). +severity_harm(p5). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p5). NOT intervening_contribution(p5). high_foreseeability(p5). @@ -317,8 +315,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p6). NOT achieve_goal(p6). careful(p6). -benefit_victim(p6,v0). -severity_harm(p6,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p6). +severity_harm(p6). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p6). foresee_intervention(p6). low_foreseeability(p6). @@ -341,8 +339,8 @@ NOT control_perpetrator(p7). benefit_protagonist(p7). NOT careful(p7). -benefit_victim(p7,v0). -severity_harm(p7,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p7). +severity_harm(p7). NOT achieve_goal(p7). foresee_intervention(p7). low_foreseeability(p7). @@ -365,8 +363,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p8). NOT benefit_protagonist(p8). NOT careful(p8). -benefit_victim(p8,v0). -severity_harm(p8,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p8). +severity_harm(p8). NOT achieve_goal(p8). NOT intervening_contribution(p8). low_foreseeability(p8). @@ -389,8 +387,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p9). NOT benefit_protagonist(p9). NOT careful(p9). -benefit_victim(p9,v0). -severity_harm(p9,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p9). +severity_harm(p9). NOT achieve_goal(p9). NOT intervening_contribution(p9). low_foreseeability(p9). @@ -413,8 +411,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p10). NOT achieve_goal(p10). careful(p10). -benefit_victim(p10,v0). -severity_harm(p10,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p10). +severity_harm(p10). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p10). foresee_intervention(p10). low_foreseeability(p10). @@ -422,8 +420,8 @@ negligent_mental_state(p10). produce_harm(p10). -/* -sufficient_for_harm(p11). + +/*sufficient_for_harm(p11). NOT plan_known(p11). plan_include_harm(p11). someone_else_cause_harm(p11). @@ -438,8 +436,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p11). NOT achieve_goal(p11). NOT careful(p11). -benefit_victim(p11,v0). -severity_harm(p11,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p11). +severity_harm(p11). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p11). NOT intervening_contribution(p11). low_foreseeability(p11). @@ -462,8 +460,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p12). achieve_goal(p12). reckless_mental_state(p12). -benefit_victim(p12,v0). -severity_harm(p12,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p12). +severity_harm(p12). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p12). NOT intervening_contribution(p12). NOT external_force(p12). @@ -486,8 +484,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p13). achieve_goal(p13). negligent_mental_state(p13). -benefit_victim(p13,v0). -severity_harm(p13,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p13). +severity_harm(p13). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p13). NOT intervening_contribution(p13). NOT external_force(p13). @@ -510,8 +508,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p14). NOT achieve_goal(p14). reckless_mental_state(p14). -benefit_victim(p14,v0). -severity_harm(p14,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p14). +severity_harm(p14). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p14). foresee_intervention(p14). NOT external_force(p14). @@ -534,8 +532,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p15). NOT achieve_goal(p15). negligent_mental_state(p15). -benefit_victim(p15,v0). -severity_harm(p15,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p15). +severity_harm(p15). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p15). foresee_intervention(p15). NOT external_force(p15). @@ -558,8 +556,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p16). achieve_goal(p16). reckless_mental_state(p16). -benefit_victim(p16,v0). -severity_harm(p16,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p16). +severity_harm(p16). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p16). NOT intervening_contribution(p16). NOT external_force(p16). @@ -582,8 +580,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p17). NOT achieve_goal(p17). neither_mental_state(p17). -benefit_victim(p17,v0). -severity_harm(p17,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p17). +severity_harm(p17). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p17). NOT intervening_contribution(p17). NOT external_force(p17). @@ -606,8 +604,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p18). NOT benefit_protagonist(p18). NOT careful(p18). -benefit_victim(p18,v0). -severity_harm(p18,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p18). +severity_harm(p18). NOT achieve_goal(p18). foresee_intervention(p18). high_foreseeability(p18). @@ -630,8 +628,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p19). NOT achieve_goal(p19). careful(p19). -benefit_victim(p19,v0). -severity_harm(p19,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p19). +severity_harm(p19). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p19). NOT intervening_contribution(p19). high_foreseeability(p19). @@ -654,8 +652,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p20). achieve_goal(p20). careful(p20). -benefit_victim(p20,v0). -severity_harm(p20,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p20). +severity_harm(p20). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p20). NOT intervening_contribution(p20). high_foreseeability(p20). @@ -663,7 +661,7 @@ reckless_mental_state(p20). produce_harm(p20). -/*sufficient_for_harm(p21,y). +sufficient_for_harm(p21). plan_known(p21). plan_include_harm(p21). someone_else_cause_harm(p21). @@ -678,8 +676,8 @@ NOT control_perpetrator(p21). NOT benefit_protagonist(p21). NOT careful(p21). -benefit_victim(p21,v0). -severity_harm(p21,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p21). +severity_harm(p21). NOT achieve_goal(p21). foresee_intervention(p21). high_foreseeability(p21). @@ -702,8 +700,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p22). benefit_protagonist(p22). NOT careful(p22). -benefit_victim(p22,v0). -severity_harm(p22,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p22). +severity_harm(p22). NOT achieve_goal(p22). NOT intervening_contribution(p22). high_foreseeability(p22). @@ -726,8 +724,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p23). benefit_protagonist(p23). careful(p23). -benefit_victim(p23,v0). -severity_harm(p23,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p23). +severity_harm(p23). NOT achieve_goal(p23). foresee_intervention(p23). high_foreseeability(p23). @@ -750,8 +748,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p24). NOT achieve_goal(p24). careful(p24). -benefit_victim(p24,v0). -severity_harm(p24,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p24). +severity_harm(p24). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p24). foresee_intervention(p24). low_foreseeability(p24). @@ -774,8 +772,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p25). NOT achieve_goal(p25). NOT careful(p25). -benefit_victim(p25,v0). -severity_harm(p25,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p25). +severity_harm(p25). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p25). NOT intervening_contribution(p25). low_foreseeability(p25). @@ -798,8 +796,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p26). achieve_goal(p26). NOT careful(p26). -benefit_victim(p26,v0). -severity_harm(p26,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p26). +severity_harm(p26). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p26). NOT intervening_contribution(p26). low_foreseeability(p26). @@ -822,8 +820,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p27). benefit_protagonist(p27). careful(p27). -benefit_victim(p27,v0). -severity_harm(p27,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p27). +severity_harm(p27). NOT achieve_goal(p27). foresee_intervention(p27). low_foreseeability(p27). @@ -846,8 +844,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p28). NOT achieve_goal(p28). careful(p28). -benefit_victim(p28,v0). -severity_harm(p28,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p28). +severity_harm(p28). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p28). NOT intervening_contribution(p28). low_foreseeability(p28). @@ -870,8 +868,8 @@ NOT control_perpetrator(p29). NOT benefit_protagonist(p29). careful(p29). -benefit_victim(p29,v0). -severity_harm(p29,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p29). +severity_harm(p29). NOT achieve_goal(p29). NOT intervening_contribution(p29). low_foreseeability(p29). @@ -894,8 +892,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p30). achieve_goal(p30). negligent_mental_state(p30). -benefit_victim(p30,v0). -severity_harm(p30,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p30). +severity_harm(p30). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p30). NOT intervening_contribution(p30). NOT external_force(p30). @@ -903,7 +901,7 @@ NOT careful(p30). necessary_for_harm(p30). -/* + produce_harm(p31). NOT plan_known(p31). plan_include_harm(p31). @@ -919,8 +917,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p31). NOT achieve_goal(p31). neither_mental_state(p31). -benefit_victim(p31,v0). -severity_harm(p31,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p31). +severity_harm(p31). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p31). foresee_intervention(p31). NOT external_force(p31). @@ -943,8 +941,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p32). achieve_goal(p32). negligent_mental_state(p32). -benefit_victim(p32,v0). -severity_harm(p32,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p32). +severity_harm(p32). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p32). foresee_intervention(p32). NOT external_force(p32). @@ -967,8 +965,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p33). NOT achieve_goal(p33). reckless_mental_state(p33). -benefit_victim(p33,v0). -severity_harm(p33,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p33). +severity_harm(p33). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p33). foresee_intervention(p33). NOT external_force(p33). @@ -991,8 +989,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p34). NOT achieve_goal(p34). negligent_mental_state(p34). -benefit_victim(p34,v0). -severity_harm(p34,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p34). +severity_harm(p34). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p34). foresee_intervention(p34). NOT external_force(p34). @@ -1015,8 +1013,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p35). achieve_goal(p35). reckless_mental_state(p35). -benefit_victim(p35,v0). -severity_harm(p35,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p35). +severity_harm(p35). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p35). NOT intervening_contribution(p35). NOT external_force(p35). @@ -1039,8 +1037,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p36). NOT achieve_goal(p36). NOT careful(p36). -benefit_victim(p36,v0). -severity_harm(p36,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p36). +severity_harm(p36). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p36). foresee_intervention(p36). high_foreseeability(p36). @@ -1063,8 +1061,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p37). achieve_goal(p37). NOT careful(p37). -benefit_victim(p37,v0). -severity_harm(p37,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p37). +severity_harm(p37). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p37). foresee_intervention(p37). high_foreseeability(p37). @@ -1087,8 +1085,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p38). achieve_goal(p38). careful(p38). -benefit_victim(p38,v0). -severity_harm(p38,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p38). +severity_harm(p38). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p38). foresee_intervention(p38). high_foreseeability(p38). @@ -1111,8 +1109,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p39). achieve_goal(p39). careful(p39). -benefit_victim(p39,v0). -severity_harm(p39,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p39). +severity_harm(p39). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p39). foresee_intervention(p39). high_foreseeability(p39). @@ -1135,8 +1133,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p40). NOT achieve_goal(p40). careful(p40). -benefit_victim(p40,v0). -severity_harm(p40,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p40). +severity_harm(p40). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p40). NOT intervening_contribution(p40). high_foreseeability(p40). @@ -1159,8 +1157,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p41). NOT achieve_goal(p41). NOT careful(p41). -benefit_victim(p41,v0). -severity_harm(p41,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p41). +severity_harm(p41). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p41). NOT intervening_contribution(p41). high_foreseeability(p41). @@ -1183,8 +1181,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p42). achieve_goal(p42). NOT careful(p42). -benefit_victim(p42,v0). -severity_harm(p42,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p42). +severity_harm(p42). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p42). NOT intervening_contribution(p42). low_foreseeability(p42). @@ -1207,8 +1205,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p43). benefit_protagonist(p43). careful(p43). -benefit_victim(p43,v0). -severity_harm(p43,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p43). +severity_harm(p43). NOT achieve_goal(p43). foresee_intervention(p43). low_foreseeability(p43). @@ -1231,8 +1229,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p44). benefit_protagonist(p44). NOT careful(p44). -benefit_victim(p44,v0). -severity_harm(p44,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p44). +severity_harm(p44). NOT achieve_goal(p44). NOT intervening_contribution(p44). low_foreseeability(p44). @@ -1255,8 +1253,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p45). achieve_goal(p45). careful(p45). -benefit_victim(p45,v0). -severity_harm(p45,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p45). +severity_harm(p45). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p45). NOT intervening_contribution(p45). low_foreseeability(p45). @@ -1279,8 +1277,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p46). achieve_goal(p46). NOT careful(p46). -benefit_victim(p46,v0). -severity_harm(p46,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p46). +severity_harm(p46). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p46). NOT intervening_contribution(p46). low_foreseeability(p46). @@ -1303,8 +1301,8 @@ NOT control_perpetrator(p47). benefit_protagonist(p47). careful(p47). -benefit_victim(p47,v0). -severity_harm(p47,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p47). +severity_harm(p47). NOT achieve_goal(p47). foresee_intervention(p47). low_foreseeability(p47). @@ -1325,8 +1323,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p48). NOT careful(p48). neither_mental_state(p48). -benefit_victim(p48,v0). -severity_harm(p48,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p48). +severity_harm(p48). NOT achieve_goal(p48). foresee_intervention(p48). high_foreseeability(p48). @@ -1349,8 +1347,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p49). careful(p49). reckless_mental_state(p49). -benefit_victim(p49,v0). -severity_harm(p49,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p49). +severity_harm(p49). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p49). foresee_intervention(p49). high_foreseeability(p49). @@ -1373,8 +1371,8 @@ achieve_goal(p50). NOT careful(p50). neither_mental_state(p50). -benefit_victim(p50,v0). -severity_harm(p50,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p50). +severity_harm(p50). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p50). foresee_intervention(p50). high_foreseeability(p50). @@ -1397,8 +1395,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p51). careful(p51). neither_mental_state(p51). -benefit_victim(p51,v0). -severity_harm(p51,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p51). +severity_harm(p51). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p51). NOT intervening_contribution(p51). high_foreseeability(p51). @@ -1421,8 +1419,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p52). NOT careful(p52). neither_mental_state(p52). -benefit_victim(p52,v0). -severity_harm(p52,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p52). +severity_harm(p52). NOT achieve_goal(p52). NOT intervening_contribution(p52). high_foreseeability(p52). @@ -1445,8 +1443,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p53). NOT careful(p53). reckless_mental_state(p53). -benefit_victim(p53,v0). -severity_harm(p53,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p53). +severity_harm(p53). NOT achieve_goal(p53). foresee_intervention(p53). high_foreseeability(p53). @@ -1469,8 +1467,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p54). NOT careful(p54). reckless_mental_state(p54). -benefit_victim(p54,v0). -severity_harm(p54,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p54). +severity_harm(p54). NOT achieve_goal(p54). NOT intervening_contribution(p54). low_foreseeability(p54). @@ -1493,8 +1491,8 @@ achieve_goal(p55). NOT careful(p55). reckless_mental_state(p55). -benefit_victim(p55,v0). -severity_harm(p55,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p55). +severity_harm(p55). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p55). NOT intervening_contribution(p55). low_foreseeability(p55). @@ -1517,8 +1515,8 @@ achieve_goal(p56). NOT careful(p56). negligent_mental_state(p56). -benefit_victim(p56,v0). -severity_harm(p56,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p56). +severity_harm(p56). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p56). foresee_intervention(p56). low_foreseeability(p56). @@ -1541,8 +1539,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p57). careful(p57). neither_mental_state(p57). -benefit_victim(p57,v0). -severity_harm(p57,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p57). +severity_harm(p57). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p57). NOT intervening_contribution(p57). low_foreseeability(p57). @@ -1565,8 +1563,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p58). NOT careful(p58). neither_mental_state(p58). -benefit_victim(p58,v0). -severity_harm(p58,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p58). +severity_harm(p58). NOT achieve_goal(p58). NOT intervening_contribution(p58). low_foreseeability(p58). @@ -1589,8 +1587,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p59). careful(p59). neither_mental_state(p59). -benefit_victim(p59,v0). -severity_harm(p59,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p59). +severity_harm(p59). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p59). NOT intervening_contribution(p59). low_foreseeability(p59). @@ -1615,8 +1613,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p60). NOT careful(p60). neither_mental_state(p60). -benefit_victim(p60,v0). -severity_harm(p60,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p60). +severity_harm(p60). NOT achieve_goal(p60). NOT intervening_contribution(p60). high_foreseeability(p60). @@ -1639,8 +1637,8 @@ achieve_goal(p61). NOT careful(p61). reckless_mental_state(p61). -benefit_victim(p61,v0). -severity_harm(p61,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p61). +severity_harm(p61). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p61). foresee_intervention(p61). high_foreseeability(p61). @@ -1663,8 +1661,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p62). NOT careful(p62). neither_mental_state(p62). -benefit_victim(p62,v0). -severity_harm(p62,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p62). +severity_harm(p62). NOT achieve_goal(p62). foresee_intervention(p62). high_foreseeability(p62). @@ -1687,8 +1685,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p63). careful(p63). reckless_mental_state(p63). -benefit_victim(p63,v0). -severity_harm(p63,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p63). +severity_harm(p63). NOT achieve_goal(p63). foresee_intervention(p63). high_foreseeability(p63). @@ -1711,8 +1709,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p64). NOT careful(p64). reckless_mental_state(p64). -benefit_victim(p64,v0). -severity_harm(p64,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p64). +severity_harm(p64). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p64). foresee_intervention(p64). high_foreseeability(p64). @@ -1735,8 +1733,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p65). careful(p65). negligent_mental_state(p65). -benefit_victim(p65,v0). -severity_harm(p65,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p65). +severity_harm(p65). NOT achieve_goal(p65). NOT intervening_contribution(p65). high_foreseeability(p65). @@ -1759,8 +1757,8 @@ achieve_goal(p66). NOT careful(p66). negligent_mental_state(p66). -benefit_victim(p66,v0). -severity_harm(p66,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p66). +severity_harm(p66). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p66). NOT intervening_contribution(p66). low_foreseeability(p66). @@ -1783,8 +1781,8 @@ achieve_goal(p67). NOT careful(p67). reckless_mental_state(p67). -benefit_victim(p67,v0). -severity_harm(p67,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p67). +severity_harm(p67). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p67). foresee_intervention(p67). low_foreseeability(p67). @@ -1807,8 +1805,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p68). NOT careful(p68). negligent_mental_state(p68). -benefit_victim(p68,v0). -severity_harm(p68,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p68). +severity_harm(p68). NOT achieve_goal(p68). foresee_intervention(p68). low_foreseeability(p68). @@ -1831,8 +1829,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p69). careful(p69). neither_mental_state(p69). -benefit_victim(p69,v0). -severity_harm(p69,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p69). +severity_harm(p69). NOT achieve_goal(p69). foresee_intervention(p69). low_foreseeability(p69). @@ -1855,8 +1853,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p70). NOT careful(p70). negligent_mental_state(p70). -benefit_victim(p70,v0). -severity_harm(p70,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p70). +severity_harm(p70). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p70). foresee_intervention(p70). low_foreseeability(p70). @@ -1879,8 +1877,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p71). careful(p71). neither_mental_state(p71). -benefit_victim(p71,v0). -severity_harm(p71,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p71). +severity_harm(p71). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p71). foresee_intervention(p71). low_foreseeability(p71). @@ -1903,8 +1901,8 @@ NOT control_perpetrator(p72). NOT careful(p72). reckless_mental_state(p72). -benefit_victim(p72,v0). -severity_harm(p72,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p72). +severity_harm(p72). NOT achieve_goal(p72). foresee_intervention(p72). high_foreseeability(p72). @@ -1927,8 +1925,8 @@ achieve_goal(p73). careful(p73). neither_mental_state(p73). -benefit_victim(p73,v0). -severity_harm(p73,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p73). +severity_harm(p73). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p73). NOT intervening_contribution(p73). high_foreseeability(p73). @@ -1951,8 +1949,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p74). NOT careful(p74). negligent_mental_state(p74). -benefit_victim(p74,v0). -severity_harm(p74,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p74). +severity_harm(p74). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p74). NOT intervening_contribution(p74). high_foreseeability(p74). @@ -1975,8 +1973,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p75). NOT careful(p75). reckless_mental_state(p75). -benefit_victim(p75,v0). -severity_harm(p75,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p75). +severity_harm(p75). NOT achieve_goal(p75). NOT intervening_contribution(p75). high_foreseeability(p75). @@ -1999,8 +1997,8 @@ achieve_goal(p76). NOT careful(p76). negligent_mental_state(p76). -benefit_victim(p76,v0). -severity_harm(p76,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p76). +severity_harm(p76). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p76). NOT intervening_contribution(p76). high_foreseeability(p76). @@ -2023,8 +2021,8 @@ control_perpetrator(p77). NOT careful(p77). reckless_mental_state(p77). -benefit_victim(p77,v0). -severity_harm(p77,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p77). +severity_harm(p77). NOT achieve_goal(p77). foresee_intervention(p77). high_foreseeability(p77). @@ -2047,8 +2045,8 @@ achieve_goal(p78). NOT careful(p78). reckless_mental_state(p78). -benefit_victim(p78,v0). -severity_harm(p78,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p78). +severity_harm(p78). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p78). foresee_intervention(p78). low_foreseeability(p78). @@ -2071,8 +2069,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p79). NOT careful(p79). neither_mental_state(p79). -benefit_victim(p79,v0). -severity_harm(p79,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p79). +severity_harm(p79). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p79). NOT intervening_contribution(p79). low_foreseeability(p79). @@ -2095,8 +2093,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p80). careful(p80). neither_mental_state(p80). -benefit_victim(p80,v0). -severity_harm(p80,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p80). +severity_harm(p80). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p80). foresee_intervention(p80). low_foreseeability(p80). @@ -2119,8 +2117,8 @@ NOT control_perpetrator(p81). NOT careful(p81). reckless_mental_state(p81). -benefit_victim(p81,v0). -severity_harm(p81,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p81). +severity_harm(p81). NOT achieve_goal(p81). foresee_intervention(p81). low_foreseeability(p81). @@ -2143,8 +2141,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p82). NOT careful(p82). negligent_mental_state(p82). -benefit_victim(p82,v0). -severity_harm(p82,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p82). +severity_harm(p82). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p82). foresee_intervention(p82). low_foreseeability(p82). @@ -2167,8 +2165,8 @@ achieve_goal(p83). NOT careful(p83). neither_mental_state(p83). -benefit_victim(p83,v0). -severity_harm(p83,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p83). +severity_harm(p83). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p83). NOT intervening_contribution(p83). low_foreseeability(p83). @@ -2191,8 +2189,8 @@ achieve_goal(p84). NOT careful(p84). negligent_mental_state(p84). -benefit_victim(p84,v0). -severity_harm(p84,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p84). +severity_harm(p84). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p84). foresee_intervention(p84). high_foreseeability(p84). @@ -2215,8 +2213,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p85). NOT careful(p85). reckless_mental_state(p85). -benefit_victim(p85,v0). -severity_harm(p85,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p85). +severity_harm(p85). NOT achieve_goal(p85). foresee_intervention(p85). high_foreseeability(p85). @@ -2239,8 +2237,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p86). careful(p86). neither_mental_state(p86). -benefit_victim(p86,v0). -severity_harm(p86,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p86). +severity_harm(p86). NOT goal_outweigh_harm(p86). NOT intervening_contribution(p86). high_foreseeability(p86). @@ -2263,8 +2261,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p87). careful(p87). reckless_mental_state(p87). -benefit_victim(p87,v0). -severity_harm(p87,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p87). +severity_harm(p87). NOT achieve_goal(p87). NOT intervening_contribution(p87). high_foreseeability(p87). @@ -2287,8 +2285,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p88). careful(p88). neither_mental_state(p88). -benefit_victim(p88,v0). -severity_harm(p88,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p88). +severity_harm(p88). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p88). foresee_intervention(p88). high_foreseeability(p88). @@ -2311,17 +2309,17 @@ benefit_protagonist(p89). careful(p89). neither_mental_state(p89). -benefit_victim(p89,v0). -severity_harm(p89,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p89). +severity_harm(p89). NOT achieve_goal(p89). NOT intervening_contribution(p89). high_foreseeability(p89). NOT external_force(p89). NOT external_cause(p89). necessary_for_harm(p89). - */ + sufficient_for_harm(p90). NOT produce_harm(p90). plan_known(p90). @@ -2337,8 +2335,8 @@ NOT achieve_goal(p90). NOT careful(p90). neither_mental_state(p90). -benefit_victim(p90,v0). -severity_harm(p90,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p90). +severity_harm(p90). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p90). NOT intervening_contribution(p90). low_foreseeability(p90). @@ -2361,8 +2359,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p91). careful(p91). negligent_mental_state(p91). -benefit_victim(p91,v0). -severity_harm(p91,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p91). +severity_harm(p91). NOT achieve_goal(p91). foresee_intervention(p91). low_foreseeability(p91). @@ -2385,8 +2383,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p92). careful(p92). neither_mental_state(p92). -benefit_victim(p92,v0). -severity_harm(p92,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p92). +severity_harm(p92). NOT achieve_goal(p92). foresee_intervention(p92). low_foreseeability(p92). @@ -2409,8 +2407,8 @@ benefit_protagonist(p93). NOT careful(p93). neither_mental_state(p93). -benefit_victim(p93,v0). -severity_harm(p93,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p93). +severity_harm(p93). NOT achieve_goal(p93). NOT intervening_contribution(p93). low_foreseeability(p93). @@ -2433,8 +2431,8 @@ NOT benefit_protagonist(p94). careful(p94). negligent_mental_state(p94). -benefit_victim(p94,v0). -severity_harm(p94,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p94). +severity_harm(p94). NOT achieve_goal(p94). foresee_intervention(p94). low_foreseeability(p94). @@ -2457,8 +2455,8 @@ achieve_goal(p95). NOT careful(p95). reckless_mental_state(p95). -benefit_victim(p95,v0). -severity_harm(p95,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p95). +severity_harm(p95). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p95). foresee_intervention(p95). low_foreseeability(p95). @@ -2483,8 +2481,8 @@ careful(p96). reckless_mental_state(p96). low_foreseeability(p96). -benefit_victim(p96,v0). -severity_harm(p96,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p96). +severity_harm(p96). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p96). control_perpetrator(p96). outrank_perpetrator(p96). @@ -2507,8 +2505,8 @@ careful(p97). negligent_mental_state(p97). no_foreseeability(p97). -benefit_victim(p97,v0). -severity_harm(p97,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p97). +severity_harm(p97). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p97). control_perpetrator(p97). outrank_perpetrator(p97). @@ -2531,8 +2529,8 @@ NOT careful(p98). negligent_mental_state(p98). high_foreseeability(p98). -benefit_victim(p98,v0). -severity_harm(p98,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p98). +severity_harm(p98). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p98). control_perpetrator(p98). outrank_perpetrator(p98). @@ -2555,8 +2553,8 @@ careful(p99). reckless_mental_state(p99). low_foreseeability(p99). -benefit_victim(p99,v0). -severity_harm(p99,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p99). +severity_harm(p99). NOT achieve_goal(p99). control_perpetrator(p99). outrank_perpetrator(p99). @@ -2579,8 +2577,8 @@ NOT careful(p100). reckless_mental_state(p100). no_foreseeability(p100). -benefit_victim(p100,v0). -severity_harm(p100,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p100). +severity_harm(p100). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p100). control_perpetrator(p100). outrank_perpetrator(p100). @@ -2603,8 +2601,8 @@ NOT careful(p101). negligent_mental_state(p101). low_foreseeability(p101). -benefit_victim(p101,v0). -severity_harm(p101,v1). +NOT benefit_victim(p101). +severity_harm(p101). goal_achieveable_less_harmful(p101). control_perpetrator(p101). outrank_perpetrator(p101). @@ -2630,8 +2628,8 @@ plan_known(n0). produce_harm(n0). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n0). -severity_harm(n0,v0). -benefit_victim(n0,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n0). +NOT benefit_victim(n0). reckless_mental_state(n0). NOT achieve_goal(n1). @@ -2654,8 +2652,8 @@ plan_known(n1). NOT produce_harm(n1). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n1). -severity_harm(n1,v0). -benefit_victim(n1,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n1). +benefit_victim(n1). neither_mental_state(n1). NOT achieve_goal(n2). @@ -2678,8 +2676,8 @@ plan_known(n2). produce_harm(n2). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n2). -severity_harm(n2,v1). -benefit_victim(n2,v1). +severity_harm(n2). +benefit_victim(n2). neither_mental_state(n2). NOT achieve_goal(n3). @@ -2702,12 +2700,12 @@ plan_known(n3). NOT produce_harm(n3). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n3). -severity_harm(n3,v0). -benefit_victim(n3,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n3). +benefit_victim(n3). neither_mental_state(n3). -/* -achieve_goal(n4). + +/*achieve_goal(n4). NOT benefit_protagonist(n4). NOT careful(n4). NOT control_perpetrator(n4). @@ -2727,8 +2725,8 @@ plan_known(n4). produce_harm(n4). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n4). -severity_harm(n4,v0). -benefit_victim(n4,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n4). +NOT benefit_victim(n4). reckless_mental_state(n4). */ @@ -2752,8 +2750,8 @@ plan_known(n5). produce_harm(n5). sufficient_for_harm(n5). -severity_harm(n5,v1). -benefit_victim(n5,v1). +severity_harm(n5). +benefit_victim(n5). neither_mental_state(n5). achieve_goal(n6). @@ -2776,8 +2774,8 @@ plan_known(n6). produce_harm(n6). sufficient_for_harm(n6). -severity_harm(n6,v1). -benefit_victim(n6,v0). +severity_harm(n6). +NOT benefit_victim(n6). neither_mental_state(n6). NOT achieve_goal(n7). @@ -2800,8 +2798,8 @@ plan_known(n7). produce_harm(n7). sufficient_for_harm(n7). -severity_harm(n7,v1). -benefit_victim(n7,v1). +severity_harm(n7). +benefit_victim(n7). reckless_mental_state(n7). achieve_goal(n8). @@ -2824,8 +2822,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n8). NOT produce_harm(n8). sufficient_for_harm(n8). -severity_harm(n8,v1). -benefit_victim(n8,v1). +severity_harm(n8). +benefit_victim(n8). reckless_mental_state(n8). NOT achieve_goal(n9). @@ -2848,8 +2846,8 @@ plan_known(n9). NOT produce_harm(n9). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n9). -severity_harm(n9,v0). -benefit_victim(n9,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n9). +NOT benefit_victim(n9). negligent_mental_state(n9). achieve_goal(n10). @@ -2872,8 +2870,8 @@ plan_known(n10). NOT produce_harm(n10). sufficient_for_harm(n10). -severity_harm(n10,v0). -benefit_victim(n10,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n10). +NOT benefit_victim(n10). negligent_mental_state(n10). /* @@ -2897,8 +2895,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n11). produce_harm(n11). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n11). -severity_harm(n11,v1). -benefit_victim(n11,v0). +severity_harm(n11). +NOT benefit_victim(n11). negligent_mental_state(n11). NOT achieve_goal(n12). @@ -2921,8 +2919,8 @@ plan_known(n12). produce_harm(n12). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n12). -severity_harm(n12,v0). -benefit_victim(n12,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n12). +benefit_victim(n12). negligent_mental_state(n12). achieve_goal(n13). @@ -2945,8 +2943,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n13). NOT produce_harm(n13). sufficient_for_harm(n13). -severity_harm(n13,v1). -benefit_victim(n13,v0). +severity_harm(n13). +NOT benefit_victim(n13). reckless_mental_state(n13). achieve_goal(n14). @@ -2969,8 +2967,8 @@ plan_known(n14). produce_harm(n14). sufficient_for_harm(n14). -severity_harm(n14,v1). -benefit_victim(n14,v1). +severity_harm(n14). +benefit_victim(n14). reckless_mental_state(n14). NOT achieve_goal(n15). @@ -2993,8 +2991,8 @@ plan_known(n15). produce_harm(n15). sufficient_for_harm(n15). -severity_harm(n15,v0). -benefit_victim(n15,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n15). +NOT benefit_victim(n15). reckless_mental_state(n15). NOT achieve_goal(n16). @@ -3017,8 +3015,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n16). NOT produce_harm(n16). sufficient_for_harm(n16). -severity_harm(n16,v0). -benefit_victim(n16,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n16). +NOT benefit_victim(n16). neither_mental_state(n16). NOT achieve_goal(n17). @@ -3041,8 +3039,8 @@ plan_known(n17). NOT produce_harm(n17). sufficient_for_harm(n17). -severity_harm(n17,v1). -benefit_victim(n17,v0). +severity_harm(n17). +NOT benefit_victim(n17). negligent_mental_state(n17). NOT achieve_goal(n18). @@ -3065,8 +3063,8 @@ plan_known(n18). produce_harm(n18). sufficient_for_harm(n18). -severity_harm(n18,v1). -benefit_victim(n18,v1). +severity_harm(n18). +benefit_victim(n18). negligent_mental_state(n18). achieve_goal(n19). @@ -3089,8 +3087,8 @@ plan_known(n19). NOT produce_harm(n19). sufficient_for_harm(n19). -severity_harm(n19,v0). -benefit_victim(n19,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n19). +benefit_victim(n19). negligent_mental_state(n19). achieve_goal(n20). @@ -3113,10 +3111,10 @@ plan_known(n20). NOT produce_harm(n20). sufficient_for_harm(n20). -severity_harm(n20,v1). -benefit_victim(n20,v1). +severity_harm(n20). +benefit_victim(n20). negligent_mental_state(n20). -/* + achieve_goal(n21). benefit_protagonist(n21). NOT careful(n21). @@ -3137,8 +3135,8 @@ plan_known(n21). NOT produce_harm(n21). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n21). -severity_harm(n21,v0). -benefit_victim(n21,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n21). +benefit_victim(n21). neither_mental_state(n21). achieve_goal(n22). @@ -3161,8 +3159,8 @@ plan_known(n22). NOT produce_harm(n22). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n22). -severity_harm(n22,v0). -benefit_victim(n22,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n22). +NOT benefit_victim(n22). neither_mental_state(n22). achieve_goal(n23). @@ -3185,8 +3183,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n23). NOT produce_harm(n23). sufficient_for_harm(n23). -severity_harm(n23,v1). -benefit_victim(n23,v1). +severity_harm(n23). +benefit_victim(n23). negligent_mental_state(n23). NOT achieve_goal(n24). @@ -3209,8 +3207,8 @@ plan_known(n24). produce_harm(n24). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n24). -severity_harm(n24,v0). -benefit_victim(n24,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n24). +NOT benefit_victim(n24). neither_mental_state(n24). achieve_goal(n25). @@ -3233,8 +3231,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n25). NOT produce_harm(n25). sufficient_for_harm(n25). -severity_harm(n25,v0). -benefit_victim(n25,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n25). +benefit_victim(n25). neither_mental_state(n25). achieve_goal(n26). @@ -3257,8 +3255,8 @@ plan_known(n26). produce_harm(n26). sufficient_for_harm(n26). -severity_harm(n26,v0). -benefit_victim(n26,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n26). +benefit_victim(n26). reckless_mental_state(n26). NOT achieve_goal(n27). @@ -3281,8 +3279,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n27). NOT produce_harm(n27). sufficient_for_harm(n27). -severity_harm(n27,v0). -benefit_victim(n27,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n27). +NOT benefit_victim(n27). neither_mental_state(n27). NOT achieve_goal(n28). @@ -3305,8 +3303,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n28). produce_harm(n28). sufficient_for_harm(n28). -severity_harm(n28,v1). -benefit_victim(n28,v0). +severity_harm(n28). +NOT benefit_victim(n28). negligent_mental_state(n28). NOT achieve_goal(n29). @@ -3329,11 +3327,11 @@ NOT plan_known(n29). produce_harm(n29). sufficient_for_harm(n29). -severity_harm(n29,v0). -benefit_victim(n29,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n29). +NOT benefit_victim(n29). reckless_mental_state(n29). -/* + achieve_goal(n30). benefit_protagonist(n30). careful(n30). @@ -3354,8 +3352,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n30). produce_harm(n30). sufficient_for_harm(n30). -severity_harm(n30,v0). -benefit_victim(n30,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n30). +benefit_victim(n30). neither_mental_state(n30). achieve_goal(n31). @@ -3378,8 +3376,8 @@ plan_known(n31). produce_harm(n31). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n31). -severity_harm(n31,v1). -benefit_victim(n31,v1). +severity_harm(n31). +benefit_victim(n31). reckless_mental_state(n31). achieve_goal(n32). @@ -3402,8 +3400,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n32). produce_harm(n32). sufficient_for_harm(n32). -severity_harm(n32,v0). -benefit_victim(n32,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n32). +NOT benefit_victim(n32). neither_mental_state(n32). NOT achieve_goal(n33). @@ -3426,8 +3424,8 @@ plan_known(n33). produce_harm(n33). sufficient_for_harm(n33). -severity_harm(n33,v1). -benefit_victim(n33,v1). +severity_harm(n33). +benefit_victim(n33). reckless_mental_state(n33). achieve_goal(n34). @@ -3450,8 +3448,8 @@ plan_known(n34). produce_harm(n34). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n34). -severity_harm(n34,v1). -benefit_victim(n34,v0). +severity_harm(n34). +NOT benefit_victim(n34). neither_mental_state(n34). NOT achieve_goal(n35). @@ -3474,8 +3472,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n35). produce_harm(n35). sufficient_for_harm(n35). -severity_harm(n35,v1). -benefit_victim(n35,v0). +severity_harm(n35). +NOT benefit_victim(n35). negligent_mental_state(n35). NOT achieve_goal(n36). @@ -3498,8 +3496,8 @@ plan_known(n36). NOT produce_harm(n36). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n36). -severity_harm(n36,v0). -benefit_victim(n36,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n36). +NOT benefit_victim(n36). neither_mental_state(n36). achieve_goal(n37). @@ -3522,8 +3520,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n37). produce_harm(n37). sufficient_for_harm(n37). -severity_harm(n37,v1). -benefit_victim(n37,v0). +severity_harm(n37). +NOT benefit_victim(n37). neither_mental_state(n37). NOT achieve_goal(n38). @@ -3546,8 +3544,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n38). produce_harm(n38). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n38). -severity_harm(n38,v0). -benefit_victim(n38,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n38). +NOT benefit_victim(n38). negligent_mental_state(n38). NOT achieve_goal(n39). @@ -3570,8 +3568,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n39). produce_harm(n39). sufficient_for_harm(n39). -severity_harm(n39,v0). -benefit_victim(n39,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n39). +NOT benefit_victim(n39). negligent_mental_state(n39). NOT achieve_goal(n40). @@ -3594,8 +3592,8 @@ plan_known(n40). NOT produce_harm(n40). sufficient_for_harm(n40). -severity_harm(n40,v0). -benefit_victim(n40,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n40). +benefit_victim(n40). reckless_mental_state(n40). achieve_goal(n41). @@ -3618,8 +3616,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n41). NOT produce_harm(n41). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n41). -severity_harm(n41,v0). -benefit_victim(n41,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n41). +NOT benefit_victim(n41). neither_mental_state(n41). NOT achieve_goal(n42). @@ -3642,8 +3640,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n42). NOT produce_harm(n42). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n42). -severity_harm(n42,v0). -benefit_victim(n42,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n42). +benefit_victim(n42). negligent_mental_state(n42). NOT achieve_goal(n43). @@ -3666,8 +3664,8 @@ plan_known(n43). produce_harm(n43). sufficient_for_harm(n43). -severity_harm(n43,v1). -benefit_victim(n43,v1). +severity_harm(n43). +benefit_victim(n43). reckless_mental_state(n43). achieve_goal(n44). @@ -3690,8 +3688,8 @@ plan_known(n44). NOT produce_harm(n44). sufficient_for_harm(n44). -severity_harm(n44,v0). -benefit_victim(n44,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n44). +NOT benefit_victim(n44). negligent_mental_state(n44). NOT achieve_goal(n45). @@ -3714,8 +3712,8 @@ plan_known(n45). NOT produce_harm(n45). sufficient_for_harm(n45). -severity_harm(n45,v1). -benefit_victim(n45,v1). +severity_harm(n45). +benefit_victim(n45). neither_mental_state(n45). achieve_goal(n46). @@ -3738,8 +3736,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n46). NOT produce_harm(n46). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n46). -severity_harm(n46,v0). -benefit_victim(n46,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n46). +NOT benefit_victim(n46). negligent_mental_state(n46). NOT achieve_goal(n47). @@ -3762,8 +3760,8 @@ plan_known(n47). NOT produce_harm(n47). sufficient_for_harm(n47). -severity_harm(n47,v0). -benefit_victim(n47,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n47). +benefit_victim(n47). negligent_mental_state(n47). NOT achieve_goal(n48). @@ -3786,8 +3784,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n48). produce_harm(n48). sufficient_for_harm(n48). -severity_harm(n48,v1). -benefit_victim(n48,v1). +severity_harm(n48). +benefit_victim(n48). negligent_mental_state(n48). NOT achieve_goal(n49). @@ -3810,8 +3808,8 @@ plan_known(n49). NOT produce_harm(n49). sufficient_for_harm(n49). -severity_harm(n49,v0). -benefit_victim(n49,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n49). +NOT benefit_victim(n49). neither_mental_state(n49). achieve_goal(n50). @@ -3834,8 +3832,8 @@ plan_known(n50). produce_harm(n50). sufficient_for_harm(n50). -severity_harm(n50,v1). -benefit_victim(n50,v1). +severity_harm(n50). +benefit_victim(n50). negligent_mental_state(n50). NOT achieve_goal(n51). @@ -3858,8 +3856,8 @@ plan_known(n51). produce_harm(n51). sufficient_for_harm(n51). -severity_harm(n51,v0). -benefit_victim(n51,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n51). +NOT benefit_victim(n51). reckless_mental_state(n51). NOT achieve_goal(n52). @@ -3882,8 +3880,8 @@ plan_known(n52). NOT produce_harm(n52). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n52). -severity_harm(n52,v0). -benefit_victim(n52,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n52). +NOT benefit_victim(n52). neither_mental_state(n52). NOT achieve_goal(n53). @@ -3906,8 +3904,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n53). produce_harm(n53). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n53). -severity_harm(n53,v0). -benefit_victim(n53,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n53). +NOT benefit_victim(n53). negligent_mental_state(n53). achieve_goal(n54). @@ -3930,8 +3928,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n54). NOT produce_harm(n54). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n54). -severity_harm(n54,v0). -benefit_victim(n54,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n54). +NOT benefit_victim(n54). neither_mental_state(n54). achieve_goal(n55). @@ -3954,8 +3952,8 @@ plan_known(n55). produce_harm(n55). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n55). -severity_harm(n55,v0). -benefit_victim(n55,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n55). +NOT benefit_victim(n55). reckless_mental_state(n55). NOT achieve_goal(n56). @@ -3978,8 +3976,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n56). produce_harm(n56). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n56). -severity_harm(n56,v1). -benefit_victim(n56,v1). +severity_harm(n56). +benefit_victim(n56). reckless_mental_state(n56). NOT achieve_goal(n57). @@ -4002,8 +4000,8 @@ plan_known(n57). NOT produce_harm(n57). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n57). -severity_harm(n57,v1). -benefit_victim(n57,v0). +severity_harm(n57). +NOT benefit_victim(n57). neither_mental_state(n57). NOT achieve_goal(n58). @@ -4026,8 +4024,8 @@ plan_known(n58). produce_harm(n58). sufficient_for_harm(n58). -severity_harm(n58,v0). -benefit_victim(n58,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n58). +benefit_victim(n58). negligent_mental_state(n58). achieve_goal(n59). @@ -4050,8 +4048,8 @@ plan_known(n59). produce_harm(n59). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n59). -severity_harm(n59,v0). -benefit_victim(n59,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n59). +NOT benefit_victim(n59). neither_mental_state(n59). NOT achieve_goal(n60). @@ -4074,8 +4072,8 @@ plan_known(n60). produce_harm(n60). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n60). -severity_harm(n60,v0). -benefit_victim(n60,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n60). +benefit_victim(n60). neither_mental_state(n60). NOT achieve_goal(n61). @@ -4098,8 +4096,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n61). NOT produce_harm(n61). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n61). -severity_harm(n61,v0). -benefit_victim(n61,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n61). +benefit_victim(n61). reckless_mental_state(n61). achieve_goal(n62). @@ -4122,8 +4120,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n62). NOT produce_harm(n62). sufficient_for_harm(n62). -severity_harm(n62,v0). -benefit_victim(n62,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n62). +NOT benefit_victim(n62). reckless_mental_state(n62). achieve_goal(n63). @@ -4146,8 +4144,8 @@ plan_known(n63). produce_harm(n63). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n63). -severity_harm(n63,v0). -benefit_victim(n63,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n63). +NOT benefit_victim(n63). neither_mental_state(n63). NOT achieve_goal(n64). @@ -4170,8 +4168,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n64). NOT produce_harm(n64). sufficient_for_harm(n64). -severity_harm(n64,v0). -benefit_victim(n64,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n64). +NOT benefit_victim(n64). negligent_mental_state(n64). NOT achieve_goal(n65). @@ -4194,8 +4192,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n65). produce_harm(n65). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n65). -severity_harm(n65,v1). -benefit_victim(n65,v0). +severity_harm(n65). +NOT benefit_victim(n65). negligent_mental_state(n65). NOT achieve_goal(n66). @@ -4218,8 +4216,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n66). NOT produce_harm(n66). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n66). -severity_harm(n66,v1). -benefit_victim(n66,v0). +severity_harm(n66). +NOT benefit_victim(n66). negligent_mental_state(n66). NOT achieve_goal(n67). @@ -4242,8 +4240,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n67). NOT produce_harm(n67). sufficient_for_harm(n67). -severity_harm(n67,v1). -benefit_victim(n67,v0). +severity_harm(n67). +NOT benefit_victim(n67). neither_mental_state(n67). achieve_goal(n68). @@ -4266,8 +4264,8 @@ plan_known(n68). NOT produce_harm(n68). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n68). -severity_harm(n68,v0). -benefit_victim(n68,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n68). +NOT benefit_victim(n68). negligent_mental_state(n68). NOT achieve_goal(n69). @@ -4290,8 +4288,8 @@ plan_known(n69). produce_harm(n69). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n69). -severity_harm(n69,v0). -benefit_victim(n69,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n69). +NOT benefit_victim(n69). reckless_mental_state(n69). achieve_goal(n70). @@ -4314,8 +4312,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n70). produce_harm(n70). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n70). -severity_harm(n70,v0). -benefit_victim(n70,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n70). +NOT benefit_victim(n70). negligent_mental_state(n70). NOT achieve_goal(n71). @@ -4338,8 +4336,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n71). produce_harm(n71). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n71). -severity_harm(n71,v0). -benefit_victim(n71,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n71). +benefit_victim(n71). neither_mental_state(n71). NOT achieve_goal(n72). @@ -4362,8 +4360,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n72). NOT produce_harm(n72). sufficient_for_harm(n72). -severity_harm(n72,v1). -benefit_victim(n72,v0). +severity_harm(n72). +NOT benefit_victim(n72). neither_mental_state(n72). NOT achieve_goal(n73). @@ -4386,8 +4384,8 @@ plan_known(n73). produce_harm(n73). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n73). -severity_harm(n73,v1). -benefit_victim(n73,v0). +severity_harm(n73). +NOT benefit_victim(n73). neither_mental_state(n73). NOT achieve_goal(n74). @@ -4410,8 +4408,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n74). NOT produce_harm(n74). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n74). -severity_harm(n74,v0). -benefit_victim(n74,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n74). +NOT benefit_victim(n74). reckless_mental_state(n74). NOT achieve_goal(n75). @@ -4434,8 +4432,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n75). NOT produce_harm(n75). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n75). -severity_harm(n75,v1). -benefit_victim(n75,v0). +severity_harm(n75). +NOT benefit_victim(n75). neither_mental_state(n75). achieve_goal(n76). @@ -4458,8 +4456,8 @@ plan_known(n76). produce_harm(n76). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n76). -severity_harm(n76,v1). -benefit_victim(n76,v1). +severity_harm(n76). +benefit_victim(n76). neither_mental_state(n76). achieve_goal(n77). @@ -4482,8 +4480,8 @@ plan_known(n77). NOT produce_harm(n77). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n77). -severity_harm(n77,v0). -benefit_victim(n77,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n77). +NOT benefit_victim(n77). reckless_mental_state(n77). achieve_goal(n78). @@ -4506,8 +4504,8 @@ plan_known(n78). NOT produce_harm(n78). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n78). -severity_harm(n78,v1). -benefit_victim(n78,v1). +severity_harm(n78). +benefit_victim(n78). neither_mental_state(n78). achieve_goal(n79). @@ -4530,8 +4528,8 @@ plan_known(n79). produce_harm(n79). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n79). -severity_harm(n79,v0). -benefit_victim(n79,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n79). +benefit_victim(n79). reckless_mental_state(n79). achieve_goal(n80). @@ -4554,8 +4552,8 @@ plan_known(n80). NOT produce_harm(n80). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n80). -severity_harm(n80,v1). -benefit_victim(n80,v1). +severity_harm(n80). +benefit_victim(n80). reckless_mental_state(n80). achieve_goal(n81). @@ -4578,8 +4576,8 @@ plan_known(n81). NOT produce_harm(n81). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n81). -severity_harm(n81,v1). -benefit_victim(n81,v1). +severity_harm(n81). +benefit_victim(n81). neither_mental_state(n81). achieve_goal(n82). @@ -4602,8 +4600,8 @@ plan_known(n82). produce_harm(n82). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n82). -severity_harm(n82,v0). -benefit_victim(n82,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n82). +benefit_victim(n82). negligent_mental_state(n82). achieve_goal(n83). @@ -4626,8 +4624,8 @@ plan_known(n83). produce_harm(n83). sufficient_for_harm(n83). -severity_harm(n83,v1). -benefit_victim(n83,v1). +severity_harm(n83). +benefit_victim(n83). reckless_mental_state(n83). NOT achieve_goal(n84). @@ -4650,8 +4648,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n84). NOT produce_harm(n84). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n84). -severity_harm(n84,v1). -benefit_victim(n84,v0). +severity_harm(n84). +NOT benefit_victim(n84). reckless_mental_state(n84). achieve_goal(n85). @@ -4674,8 +4672,8 @@ plan_known(n85). produce_harm(n85). sufficient_for_harm(n85). -severity_harm(n85,v0). -benefit_victim(n85,v1). +NOT severity_harm(n85). +benefit_victim(n85). neither_mental_state(n85). achieve_goal(n86). @@ -4698,8 +4696,8 @@ plan_known(n86). NOT produce_harm(n86). sufficient_for_harm(n86). -severity_harm(n86,v1). -benefit_victim(n86,v1). +severity_harm(n86). +benefit_victim(n86). neither_mental_state(n86). achieve_goal(n87). @@ -4722,8 +4720,8 @@ plan_known(n87). NOT produce_harm(n87). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n87). -severity_harm(n87,v1). -benefit_victim(n87,v0). +severity_harm(n87). +NOT benefit_victim(n87). reckless_mental_state(n87). NOT achieve_goal(n88). @@ -4746,8 +4744,8 @@ plan_known(n88). produce_harm(n88). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n88). -severity_harm(n88,v0). -benefit_victim(n88,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n88). +NOT benefit_victim(n88). reckless_mental_state(n88). achieve_goal(n89). @@ -4770,10 +4768,11 @@ NOT plan_known(n89). NOT produce_harm(n89). sufficient_for_harm(n89). -severity_harm(n89,v1). -benefit_victim(n89,v0). +severity_harm(n89). +NOT benefit_victim(n89). negligent_mental_state(n89). */ + NOT achieve_goal(n90). NOT benefit_protagonist(n90). NOT careful(n90). @@ -4794,8 +4793,8 @@ plan_known(n90). produce_harm(n90). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n90). -severity_harm(n90,v1). -benefit_victim(n90,v0). +severity_harm(n90). +NOT benefit_victim(n90). neither_mental_state(n90). achieve_goal(n91). @@ -4818,8 +4817,8 @@ plan_known(n91). NOT produce_harm(n91). sufficient_for_harm(n91). -severity_harm(n91,v1). -benefit_victim(n91,v1). +severity_harm(n91). +benefit_victim(n91). negligent_mental_state(n91). achieve_goal(n92). @@ -4842,8 +4841,8 @@ plan_known(n92). NOT produce_harm(n92). NOT sufficient_for_harm(n92). -severity_harm(n92,v0). -benefit_victim(n92,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n92). +NOT benefit_victim(n92). neither_mental_state(n92). achieve_goal(n93). @@ -4866,8 +4865,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n93). NOT produce_harm(n93). sufficient_for_harm(n93). -severity_harm(n93,v0). -benefit_victim(n93,v0). +NOT severity_harm(n93). +NOT benefit_victim(n93). negligent_mental_state(n93). achieve_goal(n94). @@ -4890,8 +4889,8 @@ NOT plan_known(n94). produce_harm(n94). sufficient_for_harm(n94). -severity_harm(n94,v1). -benefit_victim(n94,v1). +severity_harm(n94). +benefit_victim(n94). neither_mental_state(n94). NOT achieve_goal(n95). @@ -4914,8 +4913,8 @@ plan_known(n95). NOT produce_harm(n95). sufficient_for_harm(n95). -severi... [truncated message content] |