Menu

Is Clam Sentinel discontinued?

websafe
2016-06-12
2016-06-14
  • websafe

    websafe - 2016-06-12

    Hello :-)

    Is this project still alive? I see the last update was 2014-07-18.
    The summary does not mention Windows 10...
    Alternative.to claims that Clam Sentinel is discontinued: http://alternativeto.net/software/clam-sentinel/

    What's the current status?

    Any chance this project moves to GitHub (If it's still alive)?

    TIA :-)

     
    • Robert Scroggins

      Hello:

      Yes, the Clam Sentinel Project has been discontinued as of around July
      2014. There will be no new versions. The Clam Sentinel heuristics are
      still good at detecting Windows executable malware, but they do not
      detect non-Windows malware like JavaScript, Word macros, etc.. More and
      more malware is using non-Windows executables. Clam Sentinel relies upon
      ClamWin for non-Windows executable malware detection. I am still using
      ClamSentinel and ClamWin, but I also use Forticlient free antivirus and
      Zemana Free antimalware.

      I recommend you use Fortinet's free Forticlient antivirus. It offers very
      good protection from browsing malicious web sites, and it has a very good
      malware overall detection rate. It is simple to use/configure and has
      several updates daily. Fortinet specializes in protecting major
      corporations from malware and intrusion threats, so it is very good. You
      do not really need any AV other than Forticlient for good protection.

      The ClamWin project is still currently in operation, but all the ClamWin
      developers do is preapare a Windows port, which sometimes does not include
      new protections that are in the Clam AV Linux program from which they
      prepare the Windows port. I do not think ClamWin will be around much
      longer.

      I plan to wait until Clam AV comes our with their version 1.0 to see what
      happens with Clam Sentinel and ClamWin. If they are not improved by then,
      I will discontinue using them.

      Thanks for using ClamWin/Clam Sentinel!

      Regards,

      Robert Scroggins

      On Sun, Jun 12, 2016 at 3:16 AM, websafe websafe@users.sf.net wrote:

      Hello :-)

      Is this project still alive? I see the last update was 2014-07-18.
      The summary does not mention Windows 10...
      Alternative.to claims that Clam Sentinel is discontinued:
      http://alternativeto.net/software/clam-sentinel/

      What's the current status?

      Any chance this project moves to GitHub (If it's still alive)?

      TIA :-)

      Is Clam Sentinel discontinued?
      https://sourceforge.net/p/clamsentinel/discussion/976132/thread/704fe0cf/?limit=25#e154


      Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in
      https://sourceforge.net/p/clamsentinel/discussion/976132/

      To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit
      https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/

       
      • websafe

        websafe - 2016-06-14

        Hello Robert, thank you for your answer.

        I'm using Forticlient on some machines too, but forticlient is sometimes very, very bad.
        Disappearing desktop folders (https://forum.fortinet.com/tm.aspx?m=129943) and worse, in one network I had strange problems with printers, it turned out I had on some machines on this segment (connected to one switch) "Block known communication channels" enabled in Forticlient (this option is disabled by default) and this caused Kyocera and OKI printers to hang (yes) and disappear from the network. After turning this option off everything was fine again. This was tested by me for about 2-3 weeks until I was sure it's forticlients fault, so I'm trying to NOT use Forticlient when it's possible. Another serious problem with forticlient is - it kills Windows Backups. I'm not able to run a windows backup (containing system images) with forticlient enabled, or even installed because it somehow blocks the Windows Backup process (Testet on Windows 10) because it does not allow the backup process to backup the EFI partition. So as You can see I was initially very excited by Forticlient, but now I'm no longer, I'm rather scared by all these problems :-)

         
        • Robert Scroggins

          Hello:

          I am using Forticlient on my home computer, so I don't have any problems
          like you described. You would think they would have gotten the bugs
          out--it's been around for a few years now. I guess it's hard to cover all
          the bases with a piece of software--it can't be tested in all
          configurations, so they rely upon users to tell them of any problems. I
          hope you told them about yours. They were very receptive when I told them
          they needed a whitelist when I tested version 1 shortly after it was
          released. Their primary experience was with "black box" security. Lately
          they seem just as interested in their stock price as they are in security!

          Regards,

          Robert Scroggins

          On Tue, Jun 14, 2016 at 3:25 AM, websafe websafe@users.sf.net wrote:

          Hello Robert, thank you for your answer.

          I'm using Forticlient on some machines too, but forticlient is sometimes
          very, very bad.
          Disappearing desktop folders (https://forum.fortinet.com/tm.aspx?m=129943)
          and worse, in one network I had strange problems with printers, it turned
          out I had on some machines on this segment (connected to one switch) "Block
          known communication channels" enabled in Forticlient (this option is
          disabled by default) and this caused Kyocera and OKI printers to hang (yes)
          and disappear from the network. After turning this option off everything
          was fine again. This was tested by me for about 2-3 weeks until I was sure
          it's forticlients fault, so I'm trying to NOT use Forticlient when it's
          possible. Another serious problem with forticlient is - it kills Windows
          Backups. I'm not able to run a windows backup (containing system images)
          with forticlient enabled, or even installed because it somehow blocks the
          Windows Backup process (Testet on Windows 10) because it does not allow the
          backup process to backup the EFI partition. So as You can see I was
          initially very excited by Forticlient, but now I'm no longer, I'm rather
          scared by all these problems :-)


          Is Clam Sentinel discontinued?
          https://sourceforge.net/p/clamsentinel/discussion/976132/thread/704fe0cf/?limit=25#e154/daa2/f6b3


          Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in
          https://sourceforge.net/p/clamsentinel/discussion/976132/

          To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit
          https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/

           

Log in to post a comment.