Menu

#356 636 Steel Frame Ceilings and Floors don't have framing

Cleanup3
Fixed2014
None
Critical
Comp.Error
2016
TBD
CBECCr
2020-08-20
2014-08-08
No

Originally created by: bruceawi... (code.google.com)@gmail.com
Originally owned by: bruceawi... (code.google.com)@gmail.com

636

Steel framed walls work OK.  Steel framed floors and ceilings generate a construction with no framing, just insulated cavity.  This computes a U in CBECCr, runs fine in CSE and generates results and reports.  The problem is that the steel frame U is incorrectly lower than the comparable wood frame U and  compliance results show a credit rather than the penalty that would be generated if the steel framing was included.

Steel Frame Ceilings and Floor should be made unavailable until the algorithms are fixed.

2 Attachments

Discussion

  • Scott Criswell

    Scott Criswell - 2014-08-22

    Originally posted by: scriswel... (code.google.com)@gmail.com

    Steel Framed floors & ceilings removed from CBECC-Res 2013 ver 3 (646) - 8/22/14 PM

    These options were removed w/ no backward compatibility adjustment, so that users would be alerted to the issue.  Here is what the project log shows in a model w/ steel framed floors and/or ceilings is pulled into the new version:

    2014-Aug-22 12:21:12 -    ERROR - reading file: Cons 'Ext [r19] Floor' property Type  =  Steel Framed Floor
    2014-Aug-22 12:21:12 -    ERROR - reading file: Cons '[r38] Ceiling below attic' property Type  =  Steel Framed Ceiling

    In both cases, the Cons:Type re-defaults to wood-framed.

    Status: Fixed

     
  • Ken Nittler

    Ken Nittler - 2016-02-22
    • Status: Fixed --> Fixed2014
     
  • Dee Anne Ross

    Dee Anne Ross - 2020-08-20
    • Description has changed:

    Diff:

    
    
    • Version: --> 2016
    • HERS: --> TBD
    • Milestone: --> Cleanup3
     
MongoDB Logo MongoDB