Hi everyone,
First thanks for a great C# formatter with with nice VS support! I have been using it for a whole and found some C# speficic cases where the formatting can be improved. I hope you do not mind my suggestions.
1) In C# it is comon to use properties with ge
t and set
block. By default, the formatter puts the set
block right behind closing brace ofget
. It would be great to have option like --break-closing-breackets-properties
because we do not want to enable --break-closing-breackets
for the whole project as we like else
to be on the same line as closing brace of if
for example.
Current behavior:
public int Property { get { // some code } set { // some code } }
Desired behavior:
public int Property { get { // some code } set { // some code } }
2) Formatting of structs with the where
keyword double-indents the shole body:
public struct SomeClass<T> : IEquatable<T> where T : class { // All code // in the class // is double-indented }
I would expect just normal indentation:
public struct SomeClass<T> : IEquatable<T> where T : class { // some code // some code // some code }
Also, when where is broken to next line, there is no indentation:
public int SomeLongMethodSignature<TResult>(int with, int many, int parameters) where TResult : class { // some code // some code // some code }
But this is what I would expect:
public int SomeLongMethodSignature<TResult>(int with, int many, int parameters) where TResult : class { // some code // some code // some code }
Or even:
public int SomeLongMethodSignature<TResult>(int with, int many, int parameters) where TResult : class { // some code // some code // some code }
3) Short syntax for properties is not properly aligned:
public class SomeClass { public float SomeProperty => 3.14158f; // Some long property code here. }
I would expect at least an indent:
public class SomeClass { public float SomeProperty => 3.14158f; // Some long property code here. }
There is more things that I have found so let me know if you are interested in more suggestions.
Thanks!
1) Fixed. This occurred when certain brace styles were used.
2) Fixed structs with the where keyword .
These were actually errors in formatting.
I would like to see what else you have.
I may not have time to fix everything though.
Thanks a lot for the fixes Jim!
Any opinion about thewhere alignment and the number 3? Or is current formatting intended?
These wil have to wait for a future release.
I need to do a new release fairly soon.
Ticket moved from /p/astyle/bugs/430/