Menu ▾ ▴

astap_cli does not solve images solved easily by astap

General discussions ASTAP
Luca Fini
2024-01-23
2024-01-25

  • Luca Fini

    Luca Fini - 2024-01-23

    the CLI version of astap does not solve any image whereas some of them are easily solved using the full version.
    This happens both with linux and with windows.

    In both environments I have astap vers. 2024.01.12 and astap_cli vers. 2024-01-04

    Many thanks for any clue

    Luca

     

  • han.k

    han.k - 2024-01-23

    Normally they should perform identical. The difference could be that the GUI version remembers the last FOV and other settings if not specified in the command line.

    No problem to investigate. Can you share an example image where astap_cli fails and astap.exe succeeds?

    Han

     

    Last edit: han.k 2024-01-23

  • Luca Fini

    Luca Fini - 2024-01-24

    Here follows the output of the two commands when solving the attached image (to be unzipped)

    Many thanks for your reply

    $ astap -f TestIm1.fit
    [WARNING] GetPosition called without handle for PairSplitter1(TPairSplitter)
    Using star database D80
    Creating grayscale x 2 binning image for solving or star alignment.
    111 stars, 78 quads selected in the image. 111 database stars, 78 database quads required for the square search field of 0.3°. Search window at 113% based on the number of quads. Step size at 100% of image height.
    4 of 4 quads selected matching within 0.007 tolerance. Solution["] x:=-0.005027x+ 0.383760y+ -577.091993, y:=0.383735x+ 0.004985y+ -581.376595
    Solution found: 14: 03 11.6 +54° 21 11 Solved in 0.1 sec. Δ was 12.5". Mount Δα=1.3", Δδ=-12.2". Used stars down to magnitude: 18.9

    $ ./astap_cli -d astap_db -f TestIm1.fit
    Using star database D80
    Creating grayscale x 2 binning image for solving/star alignment.
    ASTAP solver version CLI-2024.01.04
    Search radius: 180 degrees,
    Start position: 14: 03 11.8, +54d 20 59
    Image height: 0.33 degrees
    Binning: 2x2
    Image dimensions: 3056x3056
    Quad tolerance: 0.007
    Minimum star size: 1.5"
    Speed: normal
    154 stars, 116 quads selected in the image. 154 database stars, 116 database quads required for the square search field of 0.3d. Search window at 100% based on the number of quads. Step size at 100% of image height
    0d,1d,1d,2d,2d,3d,3d,4d,4d,5d,5d,6d,6d,7d,7d,8d,8d,9d,9d,10d,10d,11d,11d,12d,12d,13d,13d,14d,14d,15d,16d,16d,17d,17d,18d,18d,19d,20d,20d,21d,21d,22d,22d,23d,24d,24d,25d,26d,26d,27d,28d,28d,29d,29d,30d,31d,31d,32d,33d,34d,34d,35d,36d,36d,37d,38d,38d,39d,39d,40d,40d,41d,41d,41d,42d,42d,43d,43d,43d,44d,44d,45d,45d,45d,46d,46d,47d,47d,48d,48d,48d,49d,49d,50d,50d,50d,51d,51d,52d,52d,53d,53d,53d,54d,54d,55d,55d,56d,56d,56d,57d,57d,58d,58d,59d,59d,59d,60d,60d,61d,61d,62d,62d,62d,63d,63d,64d,64d,65d,65d,65d,66d,66d,67d,67d,68d,68d,69d,69d,69d,70d,70d,71d,71d,72d,72d,73d,73d,74d,74d,74d,75d,75d,76d,76d,77d,77d,78d,78d,79d,79d,80d,80d,80d,81d,81d,82d,82d,83d,83d,84d,84d,85d,85d,86d,86d,87d,87d,88d,88d,89d,89d,90d,90d,91d,91d,92d,92d,93d,93d,94d,94d,95d,95d,96d,97d,97d,98d,98d,99d,99d,100d,100d,101d,101d,102d,103d,103d,104d,104d,105d,105d,106d,106d,107d,108d,108d,109d,109d,110d,111d,111d,111d,112d,112d,113d,113d,113d,114d,114d,115d,115d,116d,116d,116d,117d,117d,118d,118d,119d,119d,120d,120d,120d,121d,121d,122d,122d,123d,123d,124d,124d,125d,125d,126d,126d,127d,128d,128d,129d,129d,130d,130d,131d,131d,132d,133d,133d,134d,134d,135d,136d,136d,137d,137d,138d,138d,139d,140d,140d,141d,141d,142d,142d,142d,143d,143d,144d,144d,144d,145d,145d,145d,146d,146d,146d,147d,147d,147d,148d,148d,148d,149d,149d,149d,150d,150d,150d,151d,151d,151d,152d,152d,153d,153d,153d,154d,154d,154d,155d,155d,155d,156d,156d,156d,157d,157d,157d,158d,158d,158d,159d,159d,159d,160d,160d,161d,161d,161d,162d,162d,162d,163d,163d,163d,164d,164d,164d,165d,165d,165d,166d,166d,166d,167d,167d,167d,168d,168d,169d,169d,169d,170d,170d,170d,171d,171d,171d,172d,172d,173d,173d,173d,174d,174d,174d,175d,175d,176d,176d,176d,177d,177d,177d,178d,178d,179d,179d,179d,180d,No solution found! :(

     

  • han.k

    han.k - 2024-01-24

    I can see the same here. I will look why it differs. The strange thing it solves with the g05 database. The atap.exe version find 4 quads so solving is on the edge of solving/not solving.

     

  • Luca Fini

    Luca Fini - 2024-01-25

    Many thanks. Now both CLI versions work ok.

    Cheers,
    Luca

     

Log in to post a comment.