Donate Share

Enblend

Tracker: Bugs

6 Horizontal lines when combining large images - ID: 2863465
Last Update: Settings changed ( cspiel )

When combining large images (output size approx >=25000x5000px) enblend
creates horizontal lines like:
http://downloads.moeeeep.com/panoramabug/t1/output.png
It seems to me, that these horizontal lines only occur on a 360° panorama,
when an image has to be "split" like:
http://downloads.moeeeep.com/panoramabug/t1/example.png
This brought me the idea to emulate this behavior and to create a testcase
out of it:
Warning, huge files ahead (30000x10000px)
- The panorama file that enblend should see in its memory:
http://downloads.moeeeep.com/panoramabug/t1/t0_lzw.tif (881K)
- The split file:
http://downloads.moeeeep.com/panoramabug/t1/t1_lzw.tif (775K)

I did put them into a folder an run:
enblend -v -o out_lzw.tif t0_lzw.tif t1_lzw.tif
Output (screenshot):
http://downloads.moeeeep.com/panoramabug/t1/output.png (22K)

Here's the gimp file for those who want to extend the example:
http://downloads.moeeeep.com/panoramabug/t1/t.xcf (3.1M)

The number of horizontal lines seem to correlate to the number of
images split at the edge of the image.

enblend version: 3.2
environment: http://downloads.moeeeep.com/panoramabug/t1/system.txt


Pascal Spörri ( moeeeep ) - 2009-09-21 12:46

6

Open

None

Nobody/Anonymous

Internal error

v4.0

Public


Comments ( 4 )

Date: 2009-10-20 07:26
Sender: moeeeep

What happens if you move the center of the image?
Do you get a lower number of lines?


Date: 2009-10-17 21:54
Sender: rewolff

Here is an image from my stitch. This is a small crop. The weird lines
cover almost 2/3 of the image. The output image is about 1Gpixel, with a
final crop to 0.7 gpixel. The three source images are about 500M
(compressed), the blended image is 1.2G (compressed).

http://prive.bitwizard.nl/p2516_cropped_bad.tif

Roger.


Date: 2009-10-16 13:18
Sender: rewolff

FYI, I've seen this too. It doesn't happen on every 360 degree pano.


Date: 2009-09-21 12:50
Sender: moeeeep

Here's another testcase:
http://downloads.moeeeep.com/panoramabug/hochfuegen.zip (images with hugin
file)

Removing images at the edge of the panorama (in such a way that the
panorama didn't represent a 360° panorama anymore) produced a panorama
without horizontal lines.


Attached File

No Files Currently Attached

Changes ( 3 )

Field Old Value Date By
artifact_group_id v3.2 2009-11-14 06:57 cspiel
priority 9 2009-11-14 06:57 cspiel
priority 5 2009-10-08 03:05 yuv