#1590 Wiki : Pages need a second version to show in lastchanges

All_versions
open-fixed
nobody
3
2004-08-08
2004-07-31
Kolja Sulimma
No

Yesterday I created many pages using the
"Schnellbearbeitung einer Wiki Seite" module (could be
quick edit or something like that in english).

The creation of these pages does not show up in
tiki-lastchanges.php.
Hower pages that I created via the structures editor or
by clicking on question marks show up.

Discussion

    • status: open --> pending-rejected
     
  • Logged In: YES
    user_id=738765

    You probably just need to edit the pages you're talking
    about once to see them appear in tiki-lastchanges.php.
    Although this fits well the "changes" denomination, I'd like
    to know if we really want that understandably confusing
    behavior.

     
  • Logged In: NO

    I know, that the pages show up when I edit them again.

    But,

    1.
    A change from non existing to exisiting and empty is a change.

    2.
    A change from existing and empty to existing and nonempty is
    a change. Probably one of the most important changes that
    can occur in a wiki.

    3.
    If the creation of pages should not show up in last_pages
    than my original submission still discribes a bug, namely
    that in some cases newly created pages show up anyway.

    IMHO consistent behaviour is of greatest importance for
    usability.

     
  • Logged In: YES
    user_id=738765

    Thanks for your feedback.
    With current code, if you got newly created page (not edited
    after) to show in that page, you should indeed try to find
    what conditions can cause this.

     
  • Kolja Sulimma
    Kolja Sulimma
    2004-08-08

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=737498

    You are right, you need to edit the page before it shows up
    in last changes.
    If you create a page in the structures dialog you do not get
    the edit dialog automatically as you do with the quick edit
    module. This confused me (it shows up after seeing the edit
    dialog once, whereas otherwise you need to edit the page
    twice for it to show up).

    I still believe that creating a page should show up in last
    changes.
    The creation is arguably a change to the page, but it is
    definitely a change to the wiki as a whole.

    (I reopend the bug, I hope you don't mind)

     
  • Kolja Sulimma
    Kolja Sulimma
    2004-08-08

    • labels: 544454 --> Visual / Interface
    • priority: 5 --> 3
    • status: pending-rejected --> open-rejected
     
    • milestone: 406228 --> All_versions
    • status: open-rejected --> open-fixed
     
    • summary: pages created with quick edit do no show up in last changes --> Wiki : Pages need a second version to show in lastchanges
     
  • Logged In: YES
    user_id=738765

    No problem, this is already fixed in BRANCH-1-9 anyway.

     
  • Kolja Sulimma
    Kolja Sulimma
    2004-08-11

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=737498

    problem persists in 1.8.4