Learn how easy it is to sync an existing GitHub or Google Code repo to a SourceForge project! See Demo

Close

#222 Wording fix for p45 l34/35

closed
Michael Hucka
5
2014-05-27
2012-06-27
Lucian Smith
No

The sentence "Section 7.8 gives an example of how one can translate into ODEs a model that uses boundaryCondition and constant attributes." should be updated: boundaryCondition and constant are now both required attributes, so all models will use them. Perhaps "...a model with species with different combinations of the boundaryCondition and constant attributes."

Discussion

  • Michael Hucka
    Michael Hucka
    2012-06-28

    But ... nothing in that sentence (or the whole paragraph) implies that the attributes are optional.

     
  • Michael Hucka
    Michael Hucka
    2012-06-28

    • labels: --> Level 3 Version 1 Core
     
  • Lucian Smith
    Lucian Smith
    2012-06-28

    My point was just that 'a model that uses bC and constant' means just 'a model', because *all* models use bC and constant. (In L2v4 there were defaults, so that phrase basically meant 'a model that uses non-default bC and constant').

     
  • Michael Hucka
    Michael Hucka
    2012-06-28

    Okay, I see what you mean. I don't necessary agree it's a significant problem, but changing it to the version you suggest can't hurt, so I agree with the proposed change.

     
  • Michael Hucka
    Michael Hucka
    2012-06-28

    I am accepting this issue as valid.

     
  • Michael Hucka
    Michael Hucka
    2012-06-28

    • milestone: --> 678078
    • assigned_to: nobody --> mhucka
     
  • Lucian Smith
    Lucian Smith
    2012-06-28

    Right; not at all anything hugely significant, but while we were changing things, I noticed it, so threw it on the stack. I'd put it in the 'non-content editing' end of things.

     
  • Sarah Keating
    Sarah Keating
    2012-06-28

    I'm not sure it *has* to change but for particularly pedantic readers it is probably worth just clarifying that there is nothing special about this model having bC and constant; the example surveys to demonstrate usage of different combinations.

     
  • Sarah Keating
    Sarah Keating
    2012-06-28

    I am accepting this issue as valid.

     
  • Michael Hucka
    Michael Hucka
    2012-06-28

    • milestone: 678078 --> Accepted:_Changes_without_conformance_implications
    • status: open --> pending
     
  • Michael Hucka
    Michael Hucka
    2013-12-09

    • status: pending --> accepted
     
  • Lucian Smith
    Lucian Smith
    2014-05-27

    Fixed in SVN for L3v2, and will be part of the forthcoming release of that specification.

     
  • Lucian Smith
    Lucian Smith
    2014-05-27

    • status: accepted --> closed