#881 RssLocator issue: did not detect all feeds and titles

closed
4
2012-09-23
2006-12-14
No
0 up votes | 0 down votes | 0%
2 comments

Navigate to http://dealbook.blogs.nytimes.com/2006/12/08/craigslist-meets-the-capitalists/?&ex=1166504400&en=89c1ba75fe6be330&ei=5070&emc=eta1
There are three feeds at the page:



But in the auto-discovered menu (correct page title there) are only two feeds found: the first, and the last (with both feed titles are wrong - not taken from the attribute.

Discussion

  • Dare Obasanjo
    Dare Obasanjo
    2006-12-23

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=24549
    Originator: NO

    1.) The second link isn't a valid content type for a feed. The valid ones are application/atom+xml and application/rss+xml.

    2.) The title from the autodiscover link is always the format of the feed [which isn't useful since it will always either say RSS or Atom.

     
  • Logged In: YES
    user_id=714452
    Originator: YES

    Agree on the link issue, but the title should be always taken from the attribute - that it does not provide useful infos herein is more an issue of the publisher, than our. If we just take the HTML page title (e.g. from a sub-page), it may not fit the real content delivered by the feed(s).

    So I re-opened the bug to get the title issue fixed later on.

     
  • Dare Obasanjo
    Dare Obasanjo
    2006-12-26

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=24549
    Originator: NO

    According to the spec the title is always 'RSS' or 'ATOM'. This isn't EVER any useful information to end users in that attribute.

    See http://diveintomark.org/archives/2002/05/30/rss_autodiscovery for more information.