alex
2013-07-15
If i do:
ngspice 2 -> tran 1e-9 1e-4 0
i get good results (nice looking sine wave)
But if i do
ngspice 2 -> tran 1e-10 1e-4 0
i get bad results (v(4) remains around 4.89 V) !
Consider for example
ngspice 2 -> plot v(4)
for the following circuit file in interactive mode:
Oscillator for a VCO
common base amplifier stage
ICC 1 0 -5
RSource 1 0 1
R1 1 2 100
R2 2 3 4700
R3 3 0 1000
CS 2 0 0.1u
R4 3 6 33
C0 6 0 0.01u
L1 2 4 10n
Q1 4 3 7 Q2N3904
R5 7 0 1500
*feedback network
R6 7 8 100
C1 4 8 470p
C2 8 0 470p
C4 4 0 633p
.op
.control
pz 7 0 4 0 cur pol
print all
.endc
For the bad result v(4) remains around 4.89 V, whereas for the good result I obtain a nice looking sine wave.
The problem is that I get the bad result for the finer time step in TSTEP (1e-10) and the good result for the coarser TSTEP (1e-9)
Is this good or it is a bug and how do I handle this cases ?
Thank you.
Robert Larice
2013-07-25
Hello alex,
Your circuit is an oscillator.
Oscillators need a tiny bit of energy to start up.
In the real world you have at least a bit of thermal noise
which starts an exponential growth of your oscillator.
But if you do a numerical simulation, you don't have such
a helper. If you are lucky, some floating point rounding
during the process of the numerical simulation will start you up.
But it is important to understand, that floating point rounding
is not a random, but a deterministic process.
Thus if all the rounding steps by chance don't change your
simulated values in the first iteration,
then further iterations wont change them too,
which means, you are stuck, no exponential growth, no oscillation.
Since there are a great many of numerical operations when
processing a transient time step, it is practically impossible
to guess which parameters might be mercy-full and cause at least
little bit change to your node values,
causing the impression of something strange and unpredictable
going on.
You can deliberately kick your oscillator to avoid this problem.
One way is to put an initial condition onto the
capacitor of your LC tank.
Another would be do add a PULSE voltage source to kick it.
Sometimes, you might not want to simulate the lengthy startup
of your oscillator at all (costs a lot of simulator time).
To do that, try to estimate an almost correct initial condition,
so as to arrive at equilibrium faster.
Robert
alex
2013-08-10
Thank you very much !