From: Fred Kunz <fredk@bs...> - 2003-01-10 16:41:57
[X ] Sounds great, do it.
From: Earnie Boyd [mailto:earnie_boyd@...]
Sent: Friday, January 10, 2003 5:53 AM
To: MinGW Users; MinGW-MSYS@...
Subject: [Mingw-msys] MinGW and MSYS combined package
I've been contemplating the next MinGW release. I'm wondering if I
shouldn't just package MSYS within this release. So here is the next poll.
[ ] Sounds great, do it.
[ ] Sounds stupid, why would you ever to that?
[ ] Sounds great, but 3 more mega byte for MinGW, ouch!
[ ] Other opinion __________________________________.
This SF.NET email is sponsored by:
SourceForge Enterprise Edition + IBM + LinuxWorld = Something 2 See!
Mingw-msys mailing list
From: Paul G. <pgarceau@at...> - 2003-01-11 03:50:34
> I've been contemplating the next MinGW release. I'm wondering if I
> shouldn't just package MSYS within this release.
> So here is the next poll.
> [ ] Sounds great, do it.
> [ ] Sounds stupid, why would you ever to that?
> [ ] Sounds great, but 3 more mega byte for MinGW, ouch!
> [* ] Other opinion __________________________________.
Adding Mingw as included with Msys distro would only be, at the most, another 6 -> 8
minutes at 56kbps of download time. Maximum download time, at say, 14.4kbs might be an
addition of 15 minutes -- enough time to take a coffee break. I am using broadband, so 3M
of data doesn't really impact anything in terms of time.
Biggest concern (from Mingw users?) seems to be that many of those who want to
continue using "plain vanilla" Mingw, do not want to feel as if they are required to use Msys.
I am not sure what the assumption is in terms of continuing to make available Mingw
Even so, afaik, there have been no plans to remove the Mingw distro or any of the
Mingw related stuff (binutils, gcc, etc.) from SF. Is that still correct?
Bottom line for me: Sure, sounds great to be able to download Mingw with Msys as long
as Mingw related distros (binutils, etc.) are still available without limiting Mingw runtime, etc.
to only being available through the Msys distro.