#467 Support mairix a: query

mh-e-8.3
open
nobody
None
6
2013-02-23
2011-12-27
Bill Wohler
No

Any thoughts on whether this should be an additional search field (Recipient: ?) or whether we should consider a minibuffer mode whereby the user can specify his own search-specific criteria? Since something Recipient isn't really a valid header field, and the minibuffer approach would be more flexible, I'm leaning towards the latter. Alternatively, we could add an additional "header field" in the MH-Search buffer such as "Additional Query Arguments:" in which the user can specify arguments to pass on to the search engine. Thoughts?

From: Stephen Eglen <S.J.Eglen at damtp.cam.ac.uk>
To: mh-e-users at lists.sourceforge.net
Subject: How to do 'a:user at email.org' mairix search?
X-Mailer: MH-E 8.1; nmh 1.3; GNU Emacs 23.0.91
Date: Sat, 19 Sep 2009 13:45:14 +0100
Cc: Stephen Eglen <S.J.Eglen at damtp.cam.ac.uk>
Message-ID: <11497.1253364314@rgc.damtp.cam.ac.uk>

Is it possible to specify mairix searches like the following in the
mh-search interface:

$ mairix -f ~/txt/MAIL/.mairix/config -r a:stephen at gnu.org

where the 'a:' searches in 'From', 'To' and 'CC' fields for the email
address?

If not, would it be of any use to anyone else if I wrote a function
along the lines of
M-x mh-mairix-search

which prompted for a mairix query in the minibuffer (rather than in a
search buffer) and then did the search, returning the results as a
normal mh-search would? (And how easy is to write such a thing? It
would presumably follow along the lines of mh-mairix-execute-search?)

Stephen

Discussion

  • Jeffrey Honig
    Jeffrey Honig
    2011-12-27

    In general, mairix allows combining of fields (a: is equivalent to tcf:) and other things we do not allow (size and attachment name).

    What I think would be best would be a search-engine specific search buffer where you could type in commands. Maybe with a bit of prompting on the syntax (it would know that what the search keywords were and how they could be combined) and a live help window below.

    By live help window I mean that when you are ready to type a search pattern, it gives you the pattern keywords. Once you type a colon, it tells you what syntax is valid for the keywords you typed.

    Thanks.

    Jeff

     
  • Bill Wohler
    Bill Wohler
    2011-12-27

    • status: open --> open-accepted
     
  • Bill Wohler
    Bill Wohler
    2011-12-27

    This just in from Nick. Looking at the mairix man page, it appears that the list below is rather complete. Maybe our MH-Search buffer should display everything that the engine in use can support. Many times I type in the Message-ID field which is a pain. It would be nice if it were there already. While a general version might be useful, adding the search terms to the buffer will save him from going to the man page to look up the syntax--a real plus.

    To: mh-e-users@lists.sourceforge.net
    From: Nick Dokos <nicholas.dokos@hp.com>
    Subject: Re: How to do 'a:user@email.org' mairix search?
    Organization: HPCS
    X-Mailer: MH-E 8.3; nmh 1.3; GNU Emacs 24.0.90
    Date: Tue, 27 Dec 2011 00:11:52 -0500
    Message-ID: <12560.1324962712@alphaville.dokosmarshall.org>

    This particular search can be done already, I believe,
    by adding a header like this in the search-pattern buffer:

    Address: stephen@gnu.org

    followed by C-c C-c.

    The complete list of such translations is in mh-mairix-regexp-builder:

    ,----
    | ...
    | (cond ((eq (car pair) 'to) "t:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'from) "f:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'cc) "c:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'to-or-cc) "tc:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'address) "a:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'subject) "s:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'subject-or-body) "bs:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'date) "d:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'message-id) "m:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'message-body) "b:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'message-size) "z:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'message-attachment-name) "n:")
    | ((eq (car pair) 'message-flags) "F:")
    | ...
    `----

    Of course, this is no substitute for the much more general version that
    Bill is asking about in the feature request.

    Nick

     
  • Bill Wohler
    Bill Wohler
    2011-12-27

    Bumping priority since this seems popular.

     
  • Bill Wohler
    Bill Wohler
    2011-12-27

    • priority: 5 --> 6
     
  • Jeffrey Honig
    Jeffrey Honig
    2011-12-27

    Bill and I agree that to address this bug we will add the missing header fields and an additional header field (Mairix:) that takes a raw search string. This will preserve the current interface as well as being able to save searches.

     
  • Jeffrey Honig
    Jeffrey Honig
    2011-12-28

    Hmm, we'll need a method-specific search buffer initialization file to add the additional headers by default. And this may cause a explicit pick to fail. Needs more discussion.

     
  • Bill Wohler
    Bill Wohler
    2013-02-23

    • labels: General -->
     
  • Bill Wohler
    Bill Wohler
    2013-02-23

    Ticket moved from /p/mh-e/feature-requests/160/

     
  • Bill Wohler
    Bill Wohler
    2013-02-23

    • Status: open-accepted --> open