#59 "Group reply" with PR rules leads to unexpected results

open
nobody
None
before_1.4
Major
3.1.10
2012-08-22
2012-08-10
No

Bug 24051 migrated from Mozdev.org

My primary mail client is Thunderbird 3.1.10, and the latest production version
of enigmail. I am a member of the PGPNET Yahoo! group. I have a PRR for that
list that looks like this:

Email:  {PGPNET@yahoogroups.com}
Key:    GROUP:PGPNET@yahoogroups.com
Sign:   Always
Encrypt:Always
MIME:   Never

When I want to reply to the list and click the single reply button (not the
group reply) everything works fine. However if I click the group reply button
the following set of odd things happen. My message text is properly encrypted
to the group, but that encrypted message text is wrapped in a PGP/MIME message
that is itself encrypted, but only to my key. This happens whether or not the
group e-mail address is the only one in the message, so it's not the number of
recipients that is the problem, it's solely limited to the choice of which
button I use to start the reply.

I think that's enough to reproduce it, I can give more details if necessary.

Discussion

    • Description has changed:

    Diff:

    --- old
    +++ new
    @@ -1,3 +1,6 @@
    +Bug 24051 migrated from Mozdev.org
    +---
    +
     My primary mail client is Thunderbird 3.1.10, and the latest production version
     of enigmail. I am a member of the PGPNET Yahoo! group. I have a PRR for that
     list that looks like this: