FTP, CHMOD and Line Endings

tbolick
2007-06-11
2013-05-20
  • tbolick
    tbolick
    2007-06-11

    Just started using EPIC, and I love it, and I hate it.

    It does everything I want EXCEPT make it easy to upload changes only with FTP, along with chmod to make it executable, and ensuring the proper line endings (LF vs CR/LF).

    Can it do this?  Will it ever do this?  Can I make it do this?

    Thanks,
    Tom...

     
    • Matisse Enzer
      Matisse Enzer
      2007-06-11

      The line endings of files is controlled by Eclipse itself, not EPIC - you can set them in Eclipse in:

        Windows > General
      Then look in
          Workspace
      for "New text file line delimiter"

       
    • Jan Ploski
      Jan Ploski
      2007-06-11

      I doubt if EPIC will ever have built-in FTP-related functionality. Basically, this is something not related to Perl programming, but a more general concern and should therefore be addressed elsewhere, either at the platform (Eclipse) level or by additional third-party plug-ins. There is at least one for synchronization over FTP (Aptana), but some integration problems were reported with EPIC (see the bug reports). If they are indeed due to a bug in EPIC, it will be fixed... at some time. Or you could fix it yourself now and submit a patch.

      Depending on what you wish to accomplish there are other synchronization mechanisms which may be interesting:
      - use CVS to check in code from your development environment and check out into production. The chmod issue remains at first, but I think CVS has some post-checkout hooks to address that.
      - use ssh+rsync (maybe there is some rsync plug-in available? if not, just run a script at appropriate times; you could hack EPIC to run it for you). Rsync retains all file permissions.
      - mount the remote file system and work on it directly (NFS, Samba, sshfs)

       
      • tbolick
        tbolick
        2007-06-11

        I guess you are right.  But I do find these issues to be an annoyance when considering Eclipse/EPIC as a Development environment.  I have been using another IDE which seems to no longer be supported, but it did handle these types of issues.

        Yes, most likely Eclipse is where most of these changes should be made.  But I think Eclipse development is not yet sufficiently language/environment agnostic to care about issues that are more important to Perl/Python/Web developers than Java developers.

        Maybe I can figure out how to add an easy way to ftp a file up to my server making sure it has the correct line endings and chmod it all from within Eclipse, but I am not a Java programmer and don't know how easy that will be.

        Any suggestions would be helpful.

        By the way, I never meant to imply that EPIC had anything wrong with it.  It is just that I don't currently see how Eclipse/EPIC is a complete dev environment without ftp/chmod ability, which would probably need to have yet another plug in deal with it.

         
        • Jan Ploski
          Jan Ploski
          2007-06-11

          These links may be of some interest:

          https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=184698
          http://www.eclipse.org/dsdp/tm/tutorial/index.php

          The project described by the second link makes an impression of overengineering. Instead of focusing on solving a single problem well, they aim at solving a multitude of problems "somehow", introducing lots of annoying abstractions in the process. This reminds me of the development of the Java profiler plug-in. There used to be a nice, simple profiler plug-in for Java programmed by a dedicated person (not affiliated with the Eclipse project in any way, AFAIK). At some time it got abandoned and around the same time Eclipse guys came up with the TPTP framework - big, slow and complicated...

           
          • tbolick
            tbolick
            2007-06-11

            Oh my... I think you are right about overengineering.  I much prefer a system built up from smaller working components than one designed from the start to do everything.  Although I think removing the FTP/Webdav is the correct thing.  It works in a pretty specific situation only.

             
      • moni40tng
        moni40tng
        2007-06-12

        We use ant or make to do the installation and to set permissions. In the ant or make-targets we have scp to copy the files and then ssh 'chmod' to set permissions. This works great, and you can always check out your code outside Eclipse to do the installation if you like.

        So my suggestion is that you use ant (ant.apache.org) and write your targets and dependencies there (build.xml file). Right-click on the  build.xml file and choose the "install" target or what you call it.

         
    • tbolick
      tbolick
      2007-06-15

      Just wanted to follow up and say that I found DeployerFTP as a reasonable solution to the FTP issue.  Now I'm bugging them to add CHMOD and CR/LF conversion. :)  If only I were a java coder, I'd do it myself.

       
    • I was on the same stream to findout the FTP func. at e-p-i-c
      and got, couple on the same, but, yet to finalize since, those are yet to stable.

      1. http://www.jcraft.com/eclipse-sftp/ (FTP/Webdav based)
      2. http://www.antimatter-studios.co.uk/sites/chris/projects/esftp/

      ~S